When Works Progress Administration (WPA) interviewers asked farmer Dixon Skenandore about his life he responded, “Whenever a white man is nice to you[,] make up your mind he is after something that you have.”Footnote 1 Born in 1871 on the Oneida reservation in Wisconsin, Skenandore had lived through the Gilded Age, which left him irredeemably cynical. Longing for the time when Oneidas controlled land and resources, he displayed his bitterness openly. Many authors have documented, primarily through tribal histories, the assault on Native American lands and cultures during the Gilded Age that led to farmers like Skenandore becoming landless. Railroad companies, entrepreneurial locals and their representatives in Congress, government officials, as well as the “Friends of the Indian” reformers all agreed that in the name of progress Native Americans needed to give up communalism, including their hold on millions of acres of land. Edmund Danziger, distinguished teaching professor in the history department at Bowling Green State University, explores the topic from another angle: how Native Americans were able to survive this onslaught and remain as collective peoples into the twentieth century. As those WPA interviewers found, although many Oneidas had lost their land, they had not lost their identity. Danziger concludes that, in order to retain a measure of autonomy, Great Lakes Indian communities accepted some changes and resisted others (xi, 26).
Danziger tells this story thematically by exploring economics, education, religion, and politics. After detailing the cultural similarities and differences among the Indian peoples of the Great Lakes, both in Canada and in the United States, he introduces the various reservations to which they were confined by roughly 1850. Economically, Great Lakes Indian communities resisted pressure from both Washington and Ottawa to adopt large-scale commercial agriculture on individual land allotments (31–32, 100–01). Instead, they used both old (farming, hunting, gathering) and new (land leasing, tourism, timber sales) methods of making a living. In addition to continuing economic autonomy, Great Lakes Indian communities maintained control over their children's education. Their dominant institution was the day school, not the infamous boarding school far away from the reservation. Parents and tribal officials, Danziger shows, helped choose teachers and controlled many of the school funds (129–32). Churches also became important institutions in reservation communities. As individuals and families determined whether or not to join one of the many Christian denominations proselytizing in the region, they mostly added these new beliefs to their already existing traditional religions (178). Politically, tribal members maintained autonomy by continuing to rely on their leaders and by rejecting government offers of citizenship and individual status and property apart from tribal structures (101, 194–202).
To demonstrate that Native Americans of the Great Lakes deliberately chose between accommodation and resistance according to how each would fit their aim of maintaining autonomy, Danziger recounts illuminating survival stories. These help him to keep the focus on Indian experiences and responses, though he admits that the shortage of Indian-produced documents hampered his efforts. His theme of selective change, however, is certainly not novel for Native American history or for that matter any social history of the Gilded Age.Footnote 2 Recent immigrants to the United States as well as those considered mainstream Americans faced this same choice every day.Footnote 3 What is unique, Danziger points out, is that Great Lakes Indians had once controlled the entire region and had treaty rights as well as a unique legal status that obligated Washington and Ottawa to look out for their welfare (242–45). The fact that neither country lived up to those obligations makes this story of survival that much more compelling.
While arguing a consistent thesis throughout, Danziger has also produced a synthesis of sorts because he relied on many excellent tribal histories and state/regional treatments of the early reservation period. His use of both American and Canadian sources, however, provides a larger scope to his arguments. Seeing the similarities between the United States and Canada in this period is revealing. The same motives determined actions on both sides of the border so it should be no surprise that the policies of both governments were similar. These policies, put in place mainly by the General Allotment (Dawes) Act of 1887 in the United States and the 1876 Indian Act in Canada, were to reduce Indian land holdings by emphasizing individual agriculture and to support white development rather than protection of Indian lands (97–100). The paternalism that resulted—ironically, because the stated goal of each country was Indian independence—also was the same (188, 191–94). There is often an assumption, however, that Canada has somehow treated its Aboriginal peoples better than has the United States. For Danziger to seamlessly move between anecdotes about Walpole Island (Canada) and Lac du Flambeau (United States) underscores not only the common experience across the border but also how insignificant that border has been for the native people living on either side of it (227–29).
Danziger has produced a solid book. The main contributions for Indian specialists are the specific anecdotes and the occasional transnational comparisons. The book should also prove valuable to those seeking to understand Native American responses and reactions to the events of the Gilded Age. Additionally, scholars may extrapolate from Danziger's historic research answers to such present day questions as why Indian tribes currently pursue gaming compacts and fight to maintain treaty rights to hunting and fishing and to issue their own driver's licenses and passports. Native American communities lost so much that it should surprise no one that they continue to hold on tenaciously to what they can.
