In answering the question “how does Malcolm X's icon work?” (1), Graeme Abernethy's The Iconography of Malcolm X makes several important contributions. It is the first book to give formidable consideration and analysis to the semiotics surrounding the image and historic presentation of Malcolm X. Second, it makes the original and compelling case that Malcolm X's image bares more than a passing resemblance to those found within the Christian iconic tradition. Finally, Abernethy chronicles and dissects an impressive array of Malcolm's images – from Richard Avedon's “skull-like” portrait in 1963 (203) to Mos Def's 2009 The Ecstatic, which begins with Malcolm's closing lines from his 1964 Oxford Union address (214). The result is a compelling addition to the ever-burgeoning oeuvre of X-lit.
The Iconography of Malcolm X, like all new works on its subject, raises the question “why another?” Abernethy's study works in large part because it is as much an exposition on the theoretical and contemporary value and state of popular iconography – an education unto itself – as it is an exposition on (mostly) visual representations of Malcolm X. As Abernethy notes, the use and at times abuse of Malcolm's image is ubiquitous. From Barack Obama's invocation of Malcolm X to that of al Qaeda's Ayman al-Zawahiri (21), Malcolm has functioned as a shield of sorts for any number of political parvenus. Covering this field of literary and visual instantiations of Malcolm (perhaps the critical identifier of Abernethy's subject in a lifetime filled with adopted names), is no easy task. Doing so while thinking of Malcolm X's cultural and political legacy alongside the life of St. Augustine of Hippo is truly novel and exciting scholarship.
Range matters in works of this sort – they capture the subtleties and complexities of figures that we presume to know. And yet much scholarship on Malcolm X has relegated his life, image, or politics to the equivalent of camp-ground academics, replete with categorical simplicities. There is the Malcolm of hip-hop. Of black nationalism. Of radical Islam. Of “true” Islam. Not to be forgotten, there is socialist Malcolm. And so on. Abernethy pays these diverse stories (yes, read plural) associated with the life of Malcolm X their just due by recognizing that the portraits are multifaceted and difficult to classify. The Iconography of Malcolm X employs them while resisting the temptation to succumb to hero worship or second-stage idolatry. “Only a dedicated study of Malcolm's campaign of collaborative self-representation across a continually increasing variety of written and visual media provides answers” to the question of meaning associated with Malcolm's image, Abernethy writes (228). He can be confident that he has engaged in just such a study, one written with fluidity and respect for what the archival material, not his own suppositions, offers up.
Perhaps Abernethy's most extensive and thought-provoking contribution centers around his deconstruction of Alex Haley's rendering of Malcolm in the Autobiography. It is the one representation of Malcolm that draws chapter-length attention. Following an accelerating trend towards rethinking if not debunking much of the story-making found in Haley's book (and, like Manning Marable in his 2011 biography, Abernethy clearly puts the Autobiography of Malcolm X in that discrete category), The Iconography of Malcolm X finds the simplicity of Haley's narrative arc compelling, but ultimately disingenuous. It is most honest as a sinner-cum-martyr demi-fable where Malcolm's life falls in and out of identity shadows. Malcolm Little, Detroit Red, Malcolm X, El-Hajj Malik El-Shabazz – these are all more or less characters in Haley's pageantry of presentation. Few scholars accept their presentation today as Haley intended. And this, it seems for Abernethy, is good – a normative leap in an otherwise restrained work in this regard. There are few places that readers can go to get into the depths of the Autobiography's offering of Malcolm as well conceived and broad as Abernethy's chapter. While Marable's biography was in many ways a powerful if not uncontroversial response to the entirety of Haley's book, Abernethy's brief landing is nonetheless compelling and sweeping in the evidence it brings to bear in opposition to the story “as told to Alex Haley.” Abernethy convincingly assigns the work to myth, however magical, however significant.
There are quibbles to be found in The Iconography of Malcolm X – there are times in Abernethy's coverage of Malcolm's depiction in novels, for example, where the surfeit of facts takes away some of the strength of the author's focus. Touching all the bases is commendable, but there is an element of subtraction by addition at times in tackling so much. But still, Abernethy has given the literature on Malcolm X something new – a different window into thinking about what we believe to be the familiar name, face, and story of the Augustine of our times. Ultimately, Abernethy does his readers credit by having faith in their ability to see this truly iconic figure on his own terms, truthfully, and without a lover's overture in the background. He trusts us to put the mighty man back together on our own – provided we have the tools to do so. And in large part because of Abernethy, we are much further along in having them.
