Critique and Apologetics: Jews, Christians and Pagans in Antiquity has two connected, but not entirely convergent aims: to explore conflict and interaction between the religious groups in question, and to study the apologetic writings that emerged during that interaction — what counts as apology and can it be seen in a wider range of texts than is sometimes thought? This changed focus and shift in aims has left its mark on this volume. The volume starts with an essay by Petersen which includes a theoretical study of apologetics and engagement with the seminal work of M. Edwards, M. Goodman and S. Price, Apologetics in the Roman Empire. Pagans, Jews and Christians (1993). This reviewer finds it unhelpful that these issues are not discussed in the preface by the editors, which seems to play the rôle of a general introduction, failing to make clear where the volume as a whole stands in relation to these questions. Is the implication that all the essays in the volume follow Petersen in working with a model of apologetics as a genre that can be defined in broad and inclusive terms? Petersen's view of apologetic is in direct opposition, as he tells us, to that put forward by Edwards et al. and it would be useful to know if it was shared by the volume editors and all the contributors as well.
It soon becomes clear that far from all the contributions to the collection are explicitly or primarily concerned with the issue of what counted as apology. Here we see the outcome of the changed or divergent focus of this volume of essays. Some of the essays in the volume seem more concerned with religious conflict and religious interaction, whilst others take the nature of the apologetic genre as their subject. Thus Lieu's excellent essay is primarily concerned with whether apologetic writings, here defined as speeches in defence of Christianity purportedly addressed to emperors, and martyrologies reveal a consensus model of religious interaction, as opposed to a conflict model, rather than with defining what counts as apology. Similarly, Becker provides some careful discussion of the use of polemic and satire in representations of Jewish-Christian conflict in Revelations 2–3, but includes no discussion of how this might relate to the genre of apology.
The coverage of the volume is admirably broad; the editors have sought out contributions that allow them to explore every possible potential site of written apologetic, including Graeco-Roman (Wischmeyer), Rabbinic/Jewish (Avemarie and Barclay), Gnostic (Aland), martyr (Engberg), heresiological (Ulrich) and Augustinian (Pollman) texts, as well as the more obvious Christian apologetic works (Lieu, Jacobsen, Perrone, Kahlos, and also Engberg). However, if this diversity is meant by implication to support Petersen's model of a broad and inclusive genre of apologetic, it is a little odd that some of the chapters come to such negative conclusions. Thus, Wischmeyer collects examples of Graeco-Roman criticisms of Judaism to show that the stereotypical views they embody of the Jewish ‘other’ never amount to polemic or apologetic in a way that would allow for true dialogue between these religions. Aland and Avemarie come to similarly negative conclusions about the existence of apologetic in Gnostic and Rabbinic texts. Even the essays that do focus on texts that are generally acknowledged to be apologetic often do not show themselves to be very aware of the more general issues raised by Petersen and the preface. Thus, Jacobsen's perfectly sensible study of the topics and strategies of traditional apologetic texts provides no discussion of how the topics and strategies outlined here were characteristically ‘apologetic’ or might be shared with other genres.
The essays in the volume that most successfully explore the relationship between apologetic and other, more obviously inwardly-focused, genres of Christian writing are Engberg on the relationship between martyr literature and apologetic, Ulrich on anti-heretical writings and apologetic, and Pollman on the relationship between Augustine's more outward-looking writing, exemplified by the City of God, and writings that seem primarily addressed to a Christian audience, exemplified by De Genesi ad Litteram. Others show a related concern with the way that apologetic writings could not avoid being concerned with the characterization of what it was to be Christian while, ostensibly at least, addressing external audiences. This is one of the key points in Petersen's argument for a broad definition of the genre of apology; it can also be seen in Perrone's interesting attempt to find a ‘positive Christian discourse’ on Christian cultic practices in Christian apologetic writings. Barclay also makes a serious attempt to explore how far Josephus' Contra Apionem can be considered apologetic and does explicitly engage with some of the theoretical issues raised by the chapter.
In a review of Edwards et al., Apologetics in the Roman Empire: Pagans, Jews and Christians in BMCR, Jason Davies asks, ‘where is the paganism so prominent in the title and implicit in the choice of arena?’ The volume currently under review suffers from a similar imbalance with essays on Jewish and Christian texts predominating; Wischmeyer's essay is the only one that takes Graeco-Roman texts as its focus, although Perrone does include some discussion of non-Judaeo-Christian work. It is thus particularly useful that Kahlos's essay on Lactantius' Institutiones divinae argues for the problems of trusting Lactantius' representation of Roman religion as the polar opposite of Christianity and that Lieu shows Christian apologetic texts appealing to values shared with adherents of other religions. If we are not going to consider defences put forward by pagans themselves, we should at least consider how Christian apologetic might distort pagan views or make attempts to relate to them.
