To reconsider the evidence for the start of concrete construction in Roman Italy is obviously a worthwhile project, since our general view rests to a large extent on typologies created long ago when less information was available and dating could be described as largely schematic. This was the subject of Mogetta's doctoral and post-doctoral research at Michigan, and prior to this book he had published articles revising the dating for early concrete in Rome and Pompeii and reviewing Cosa. As well as an Introduction and Conclusion, the present volume has five substantive chapters: ‘Deconstructing Roman Concrete’, ‘A new date for Concrete in Rome’, ‘A view from the Suburbium’, ‘Building Samnite Pompeii’ and ‘Colonial Networks’. That list shows the book's ambitious scope, to look in all parts of Italy (mainly north of Magna Graecia) and at rural as well as urban sites. A very simple result is that concrete construction is seen to be not earlier than the middle of the second century b.c. at any of this range of sites and not clearly earlier in one place than any other. In fact, although there is some justified correcting of dates, notably in Rome, the dating evidence overall is still not that precise, and does not really support some of the cause-and-effect discussions that are attempted. Regional histories of the emergence of concrete are well shown, but again it does not necessarily follow that it was invented several times in slightly different ways in different places.
In the ‘Conclusion’, M. expresses the hope that this book will serve as a reference tool in the future. A huge amount of information is collected here, and this will always have value for looking up particular sites, such as Luna or Teanum. But for more systematic reference, this is not an easy book to use. Partly it reads as if it was written in a hurry, and quite a bit of the English has the quality of an unrevised first draft, making it difficult for the reader to follow the meaning. Many descriptive passages without illustrations also make for difficult reading. There also seems to be ambiguity or slippage in the use of some key terms: for example, ‘opus incertum’ and ‘cemented rubble’ seem to be interchangeable through many parts of the book, but in the ‘Catalog of sites’ they are classified separately. It is not clear when ‘concrete villas’ and ‘concrete architecture’ mean those with ‘opus incertum’ and/or ‘opus reticulatum’ walls, and when a distinction should be made. Going back to the introductory chapter, a decision not to use ‘opus caementicium’ as a generic term could be seen as strictly correct, given the sparsity of ancient authority for it and the likelihood that Vitruvius would have seen it as a structura rather than an opus. At a theoretical level, one might also applaud the distinction between ‘mortared rubble’ and ‘cemented rubble’ (13), but if only scientific methods can be used to determine reactive ingredients properly in lime-based mortars, this is not going to work easily with the bulk of archaeological data that we have. Some confusion seems to stem from that. However, where it can be done, M. takes care to distinguish clay-based or less cohesive mortars in describing particular sites. But there is a large body of evidence where that cannot be easily done, or has not been done.
A merit of the book is its attention to factors other than the availability of materials that probably played a part in when and how the use of concrete developed: such as the ambitions of elites in private and public building, the development of rural estates, the drive towards urbanisation in second-century b.c. Italy and the nature of building contracts. But beyond saying that these factors need to be taken into account, it is difficult to do much with them. M. also does himself no favours by an inclination to attack straw men: concrete as an essentialist expression of Romanitas, its spread as an example of diffusion or Roman imperialism. Of course, writers can be found who said words to those effects, but how prominent are these ideas? On the typological front, there seemed to be an over-zealous putting-down of Coarelli's distinctions of wall types in Republican Rome (granted that the dating needed revision), and of Tombrägel's opus incertum typology in the Ager Tiburtinus. The point is taken that walls of different types could be contemporary, even in the same building project, but it nevertheless was useful to have made those distinctions.
So while this book addresses a topic where revised thinking is needed, and to some degree provides it, it also frustrates the reader. The serious point might be that, while articles correcting dates and pointing to adjusted views at particular sites — as already written by the author — are useful, the overall range of information may not yet be good enough for a book, or not for one conceived like this. That is shown particularly in the ‘Conclusion’, where few statements are made that feel like solutions rather than opinions.
