This book is an erudite discourse on just war theory from a historical and regional perspective. In a nutshell, the book examines the normative criteria for the just use of armed force as delineated by a variety of influential thinkers, in the West and the East, in three parts.
In Part I, Gregory A. Raymond provides a rhetorical examination of the Greco-Roman roots of the just war tradition. He rightly argues that it was during the Greco-Roman period that some of the key concepts associated with Western just war thought began to coalesce. Howard M. Hensel provides a very useful and detailed analysis of the influence of Christian belief upon just war thought during different periods (late Roman period, the Middle Ages, and the early modern period). Drawing on the writings and thoughts of St Augustine, St Thomas Aquinas, Francisco de Vitoria, and Francisco Suarez, the author skilfully demonstrates the point of consensus among the classical and neo-classical Christian thinkers in their just war approach—a theocentric and humanistic approach to the just war question. Tyler Ruert continues the historical study into the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries of Western just war thought by analyzing the criteria for just war posited by European thinkers such as Hugo Grotius, John Locke, Emmerich de Vattel, and Immanuel Kant. The author convinces the reader of how all four thinkers concurred affirmatively on the question of whether war should be a rule-governed activity, which in turn also proved the occurrence of an evolutionary shift in the just war movement, from the theocentric approach to an anthropocentric natural law approach (espoused by Grotius, Locke, and Vattel) and a positivist approach (espoused by Hobbes and Kant). Taken as a whole, the chapter is a succinct, well-written and informative discussion on the contribution made by these positivist thinkers to positivism, which dominates in international legal circles today.
In Part II, John Kelsay assesses the perspective of Sunni Islamic thinkers, who offered norms for regulation of war so that military force might be harnessed for legitimate political ends. He shows the continuity and change in the characteristics of the Sunni approach to Shari'a reasoning about war and proffers a useful critique of the Shari'a reasoning for jihad as advanced by al-Qa'ida in their book, The Neglected Duty. Valerie Morkevicius continues the thread of study by examining in detail the Shia Islamic perspective on the just use of force in Chapter 5 and the Hindu approach to war in Chapter 6, wherein he briefly touches on erstwhile significant approaches in Hinduism, the alternative paths to international order: (i) federation under a world sovereign and (ii) ahimsa or non-violence.
In Part III, David A. Graff analyzes the concept of righteous war in ancient China. The author has put together the righteous-war doctrine (yi zhan or yi bing) that evolved in ancient Imperial times and has attempted to find in it some parallels with the ideas of just war that later evolved in Christian Europe; in particular, the belief that war should be waged only for a just cause and with the goal of restoring peace. Notably, this chapter takes Chinese texts such as Daodejing, Analects, Mozi, The Tradition of Zuo, and Annals of Lu Buwei as its objects of analysis rather than theorists or schools of thought. This chapter, hence, will be particularly appealing to scholars who are keen to study the just war concepts/interpretations in influential Chinese texts. Chapters 8 and 9, by Edward A. Olsen, provide interesting case-studies of patterns of change and continuity in the complex and diverse ways in which Japanese and Korean societies have perceived the concept of just war. These final two chapters give due attention to otherwise sparingly mentioned but relevant contemporary perspectives and contain a captivating narration of historical perspectives.
All in all, this book serves as a good reflection on the various religious, philosophical, and cultural foundations which serve to inform and condition the diverse perspectives held by various Western and Asian just war theorists. The books rightly enunciates how many of the Asian just war thinkers addressed some of the same questions as those contained within the framework of analysis that Western just war thinkers gradually developed and applied as they formulated their various criteria for just war. The valuable contribution of the book lies in its combining different dominant cultural perspectives on just war theory into one volume, thereby offering readers a quick preview of the genesis, transmutation, consolidation, and continuing evolution of the present-day just war principles. Bearing in mind the title of this book, one would have expected something more than the historical rhetoric of just war theories. Including a discussion of the contemporary Asian and Western approaches to the legitimate use of force such as the pre-emptive use of force, which are much debated between the scholars in the East and the West, would have added more value by producing a volume that is more comprehensive. Hence, it would not be wrong to state that this book is not the first or the most comprehensive discourse on the Asian and Western perspectives on the legitimate use of force.
That being said, this book is a one-stop guide to appreciating the same-but-different ways in which various Western and Eastern cultures approach the important question of when and how armed force should be justly used. Therefore, it is a welcome addition to the existing plethora of scholarly works on the ever-debatable subject of the “just” use of force.
