Medieval Islamic historiography has attracted considerable scholarly attention over the past few decades, but very few books have attempted to follow the historiographical evolution of central themes and topics of early Islam in the longue-durée. This is the challenge undertaken by Heather N. Keaney, who traces narratives of the rebellion against ʿUthman and the eventual murder of the third caliph of Islam across centuries of medieval historical writings. This book thus aims to highlight the “ongoing dynamism of the medieval Islamic historical discourse” (p. 75) and at “bridging the gap” (p. 16) between al-Tabari (d. 923) and Ibn Khaldun (d. 1406). The task is, needless to say, quite formidable since potentially every single medieval historian had something to say about this founding episode of early Islamic history. To make it manageable, Keaney selects a sample of significant sources for each century between the 9th and the 14th century. While her selection of texts remains necessarily questionable (the focus on Arabic texts at the detriment of Persian historiography should in particular have been addressed), the number of sources that she includes belonging to different historiographical genres is truly impressive.
Keaney shows how this trauma was reinterpreted over time and how it became a focal point in tensions between Sunnis and Shiʿa. She identifies four major debates in the narratives of ʿUthman (p. 11): history versus hagiography (understood as ahistorical, which proves at times problematic); Sunni versus Shiʿi; religious versus political authority; preserving unity versus pursuing justice. Inspired by Hayden White, this allows her to document the various narrative strategies implemented over time by successive generations of scholars. Such an investigation notably reveals the intense competition between those willing to redeem ʿUthman's memory, and those eager to blame him for marking the swan song of a united umma. This sharp dichotomy between radically opposed agendas resulted in a paradigmatic opposition: ʿUthman's defenders portrayed him as the blessed companion of the Prophet Muhammad, while his detractors focused on the shortcomings of his caliphate. In other words, the opposition between the meritorious companion and the sinful caliph allowed scholars to choose between a good and bad ʿUthman, and to likewise oppose an early convert, married to two daughters of the Prophet, to a weak ruler inclined to nepotism. ʿUthman's efforts to collect the Qurʾan could thus be seen in a positive or negative light: he either ensured the preservation of the sacred text or was guilty of having manipulated it.
In surveying centuries of historical writing, Keaney also makes a broader intervention in medieval Islamic historiography. She notes in particular a marked decline in universal histories concomitant with the political fragmentation of the Abbasid Empire (especially from the mid-10th century), and the subsequent rise of different genres, first and foremost prosopographical dictionaries and faḍāʾil/manāqib literature. It is only at a later stage, in the 13th century, that universal histories resurface with historians such as Ibn al-Athir (1233). Keaney goes on to argue that this gap explains the relative oblivion of al-Tabari and other 9th- and 10th-century chronographers up to the 13th century, thus challenging a more traditional view that Islamic historiography was static in this period and solidified around the towering figure of al-Tabari.
This last point, while raising formidable questions, might be overplayed. Is it legitimate, for instance, to argue strongly for the disappearance of universal histories in the 11th and 12th centuries when, in fact, we have an uninterrupted chain of continuators of al-Tabari's famous Taʾrikh (see Franz Rosenthal, A History of Muslim Historiography [Leiden: Brill, 1968], esp. 81ff.)? The argument for a “rediscovery” (p. 107) of al-Tabari in Ibn al-Athir's text is also problematic when one takes into consideration evidence pointing to the large number of manuscripts of al-Tabari's work held in various medieval libraries (see Konrad Hirschler, “Islam: The Arabic and Persian Traditions, Eleventh-Fifteenth Centuries,” in The Oxford History of Historical Writing, vol. 2, 400–1400, ed. Sarah Foot and Chase F. Robinson [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012], p. 281). Another metric of al-Tabari's rapid and widespread success in the 11th and 12th centuries is, of course, its Persian “adaptation” by Balʿami (d. between 992 and 997), which became immensely popular (see Andrew C. S. Peacock, Mediaeval Islamic Historiography and Political Legitimacy: Balʿamī's Tārīkhnāma [London: Routledge, 2007]). In other words, al-Tabari's fame does not seem to have languished in the period as much as suggested by Keaney. It is true that a lot more needs to be done to “de-Tabarize” Islamic history, as once suggested by Fred M. Donner, but perhaps not to the point of “un-Tabarizing” it altogether. It is possibly the question of the representativeness of the surviving corpus of historical texts that should be asked more often (see, for the Medieval West, the stimulating discussion of Arnold Esch, “Chance et hasard de transmission: le problème de la représentativité et de la déformation de la transmission historique” [Chance of Transmission: The Problem of Representativeness and Distortion of Historical Transmission], in Les Tendances actuelles de l’histoire du Moyen Âge en France et en Allemagne: Actes des colloques de Sèvres [1997] et Göttingen [1998] organisés par le C.N.R.S. et le Max-Planck-Institut für Geschichte [Current Trends in the History of the Middle Ages in France and Germany: Proceedings of the Sèvres (1997) and Göttingen (1998) Conferences Organized by the CNRS and the Max-Planck Institute for Geschichte], ed. Jean-Claude Schmitt and Otto Gerhard Oexle [Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne, 2003], pp. 15–29). On this point, curiously, the sources selected by Keaney for the 9th century do not support her argument for a golden age of universal histories since most of them (Ibn Khayyaṭ, Ibn Saʿd, Ibn Hanbal, al-Bukhari, al-Baladhuri, etc.) do not belong to this genre.
Another problem has to do with the lack of spatialization of the source material. Keaney carefully picks up examples from various regions of the Muslim (Arab) world in any given century, but never discusses the implications of the geographical provenance of the sources. This is especially puzzling when one considers that the overwhelming majority of Syrian sources discussed throughout the book are vocal in their defense of ʿUthman (the only notable exception being al-Dhahabi [d. 1348]; on the efforts to reinstate Syria into Islamic historical discourse, see Paul M. Cobb, “Virtual Sacrality: Making Muslim Syria Sacred Before the Crusades,” Medieval Encounters 8 [2002]: pp. 35–55). And this leads to another question surprisingly ignored by the author, namely the status of ʿUthman as an Umayyad and the related issue of the redemption of the first dynasty of Islam's memory (on which see Umayyad Legacies: Medieval Memories from Syria to Spain, ed. Antoine Borrut and Paul M. Cobb [Leiden: Brill, 2010]).
Memory is actually another problem of the book. The author uses the notion uncritically and overlooks all the relevant scholarship in the booming field of memory studies, despite the book subtitle's focus on remembrance. The direct consequence is a tendency to oppose memory to history (e.g., p. 45), whereas such an old-fashioned dichotomy has been thoroughly rejected in memory studies.
This last point takes me to a broader bibliographical complaint. A significant number of important references are simply absent from the bibliography, with non-Anglophone scholarship almost totally neglected. Thus, al-Bukhari and Muslim's Sahihayn (p. 25) should have been discussed in light of Jonathan Brown's important contribution (The Canonization of al-Bukhārī and Muslim: The Formation and Function of the Sunnī Ḥadīth Canon [Leiden: Brill, 2007]), while Elton Daniel's discussion (“Al-Yaʿqūbī and Shiʿism Reconsidered,” in ʿAbbasid Studies: Occasional Papers of the School of ʿAbbasid Studies, ed. James Montgomery [Leuven: Peeters, 2004], pp. 209–31) of the manuscript tradition of al-Yaʿqubi's History would have been beneficial on several occasions (esp. 57ff). It is even more problematic to engage with Ibn Khaldun's opus magnum without Gabriel Martinez-Gros's groundbreaking work (Ibn Khaldûn et les sept vies de l’Islam. [Ibn Khaldun and the Seven Lives of Islam] [Paris: Actes Sud, 2006]). And how is it possible to dedicate a book to ʿUthman without even mentioning Hichem Djaït's classic study of the first fitna (La Grande discorde: Religion et politique dans l’islam des origines [The Great Discord: Religion and Politics in Early Islam] [Paris: Gallimard, 1989])? Tayeb El-Hibri's work on the redemption of Umayyad memory (“The Redemption of Umayyad Memory by the ʿAbbāsids,” Journal of Near Eastern Studies 61 [2002]: 241–65) would also have been useful, as well as the work of the present reviewer on early Islamic historiography and on Umayyad memory (esp. Entre mémoire et pouvoir: L’Espace syrien sous les derniers Omeyyades et les premiers Abbassides [v. 72–193/692–809] [Between Memory and Power: The Syrian Space under the Latter Umayyads and the Early Abbasids (ca. 72–193/692–809)] [Leiden: Brill, 2011]). Keaney's study should now be complemented by Sean Anthony's work (The Caliph and the Heretic: Ibn Sabaʾ and the Origins of Shīʿism [Leiden: Brill, 2012]), given how commonly Ibn Sabaʾ was blamed for all of ʿUthman's shortcomings.
Finally, the structure of the book leads to several repetitions, while the maps reproduced in the various chapters are of poor quality and of limited relevance to the discussion.
These reservations should not obscure the fact that, if the interest of narratives dedicated to ʿUthman had been highlighted in previous scholarship, no one has ever attempted such a tour de force of tracing the image of a companion and caliph across centuries of Islamic historiography. It is a challenging task, but a worthy one. This book should thus spark important debates at the historiographical level, especially between specialists of early Islam and specialists of the “Middle Period.”
