Anand Pandian and Daud's Ali's stimulating edited collection of thirteen essays on ethical life in South Asia is anchored by the keen editorial eye of the ethnographer and the literary historian respectively. Under such an interdisciplinary editorial impetus, the thirteen essays offer up rich and provocative meditations on ethical life in the subcontinent.
Most recent scholarship on ethics in South Asia has overwhelmingly focused on religious subject matter through careful textual analysis of scripture. Even as scholars have explored the historical conditions for the emergence of concepts such as dharma, they have also sought to determine the practical applicability of the same. Ethical Life builds on this daunting body of previous scholarship while also moving our understanding of South Asian ethics in a different direction: on the embodied, performed and lived dimension of ethics, particularly as they are evidenced in the everyday.
This emphasis of embodiment and the lived dimension of ethics in South Asia is most obviously signaled by the book's title and is thoroughly explored in the brief but dense introduction co-authored by the editors. Elegantly charting out the theoretical foundations of this volume, the introduction does more than offer synopses of the thirteen essays. It ably demonstrates the volume's relevance for the study of ethical behavior in general, and on South Asia in particular. Helping steer the conversation across disciplinary boundaries and regional specializations, is the work on ethics by Michel Foucault, who looms large as a theoretical touchstone. Such a keen theoretical focus succeeds in creating cohesion across a range of disciplines and regions, and empowers the astute reader to locate the question of ethical life in South Asia within their own fields of sub-specializations.
The essays are divided into four evenly balanced sections, and nicely amplify the book's imperative (articulated in the introduction) on self-fashioning, collective conduct, and in locating South Asian ethical traditions within their specific historical contexts. Thus, Part 1: Traditions in Transmission (3 essays) and Part 2: Ethics and Modernity (3 essays) explore the relationships between South Asian ethical practices and the past. Part 3: “Practices of the Self” (4 essays) and Part 4: “Ethical Lives of Others” (3 essays) draw particular attention to the lived and embodied qualities of ethical conduct. Nonetheless, the boundaries between each of the four sections are permeable, and several articles such as Bhavani Raman's “Disciplining the Senses, Schooling the Mind” (pp. 43–60) from Part 1, or Bernard Bate's “The Ethics of Textuality (pp.101–15) from Part 2, could easily find happy homes in any one of the companion sections. Such malleability both in content and in the organizational structure of the book, suggests fruitful ways of engaging with these articles, and indeed brings up useful ways of considering the body as an active site for the production and consumption of ethical conduct, knowledge and behavior.
Although Pandian and Ali are careful to chart a path for the study of ethics in South Asia outside the domain of the textual and religious, neither is completely absent from this volume. Ali's essay, “The Subhāṣita as an Artifact of Ethical Life in Medieval India” (pp. 21–42) opens the book, and beautifully demonstrates that the recitation and citation of subhāṣita (the well-spoken) was essential to cultivating an ethical sensibility within the context of medieval courtly culture. Charles Hallisey's “Between Intuition and Judgment” (pp. 141–52) takes up Pali texts to explicate the significance of reading, in nurturing the quality of satisampajañña (moral discernment) among Theravada Buddhists.
In keeping with the Ethical Life's emphasis on the “body as a site of ethical engagement” (p. 5), the essays also investigate the performative dimensions of ethical practices. For instance, memorization and orality, two kinds of linked embodied practices, emerge as key tools in the cultivation of virtue. Bhavani Raman's essay, “Cultivating the Mind,” studies the practice of memorization of Tamil ethical poems in the context of the tiṇṇai-school, to demonstrate that the cultivation of memory in pre-colonial South India was equivalent to the cultivation of virtue. As a corollary, Emma Flatt's “Young Manliness: Ethical Culture in the Gymnasiums of the Medieval Deccan” (pp. 153–73) takes up the ethic of “young manliness” to articulate the relationship between regimenting the body and fashioning the self. Bernard Bate's “The Ethics of Textuality: The Protestant Sermon and the Tamil Public Sphere” (pp. 101–15) links Protestant critiques of Indic (here, Tamil) textual practice itself to the emergence of the sermon, and thus to a radically new way of using language.
Ethical Life of South Asia is a welcome addition to the growing body of literature on ethics in South Asia. While not losing sight of the significance of texts and religion, the essays move the discussion forward by expanding their purview. The recurring theme of embodiment of ethical knowledge through memorization and recitation is as much an important and useful intervention in the study of ethics, as it is in the study of the interface between text and performance in South Asia. This book is recommended for advanced undergraduates and graduate courses on South Asian ethics, identity and language.
