Michael Walzer tells us that he wrote In God's Shadow as “an ordinary reader of the biblical text,” but there is nothing ordinary about what he brings to his task as one of the most distinguished political philosophers writing today, author of Exodus and Revolution, Exilic Politics in the Hebrew Bible, and several monographs on the morality of warfare, including warfare in the Hebrew Bible. Most of the chapters of the book (eight out of twelve) reproduce or are based on lectures delivered by the author over the years, but together they constitute a fairly comprehensive critical overview of what counts as politics in the Hebrew Bible. Rather than presenting a flat exposition of the issues treated (covenant, law, conquest and war, kings, prophets, priests, etc.), Walzer starts out with questions and then sets about probing for answers: How is political society conceived and political power used? How is authority described, defended, and challenged? How is the past used and the future imagined? What are we to make of Israel's genocidal wars of conquest?
Walzer aims to figure out what the ideas of the biblical writers were in their own time and place and in chronological order, which he knows is no easy task. At the most obvious level, these are ancient texts. The past, we have been told, is a foreign country in which people do things differently. There is the problem, to which Walzer alludes, of reconciling the many opinions expressed in the texts with the overwhelming presence of an almighty and active deity which calls into question the possibility of an autonomous political realm. The author's proposal to work through the material chronologically is praiseworthy, indeed necessary, but comes up against the problem of dating and the presence of innumerable additions and glosses. What is at stake here is the issue of development. Walzer notes differences between the three law codes he identifies, for example, where they deal with slaves and women, but the codes incorporate unwritten customary law, reflect the impact on this traditional legal material of the formation of the state and the creation of a central judiciary, and presuppose the rise of a class of legal specialists, referred to disparagingly by Jeremiah as “handlers of the law” (Jer. 2:8). This also calls for attention. Another example: In his first chapter Walzer deals with covenants. There are two covenants, the first with Abraham, described twice (Gen. 15 and 17), the second with Israel at Sinai mediated by Moses (Exod. 19–24). He notes that the model on which the covenant is based is the Assyrian suzerainty treaty, for example the treaty between the Assyrian emperor Esarhaddon and the vassal king of Tyre, part of which is extant. The formal features of these treaties fit the biblical analogue, but the disparity between suzerain and vassal, as between God and the Israelite people, raises further serious questions, including questions about validity. But Walzer does not take account of another covenant which occurs prior to the Abrahamic and Mosaic covenants, namely, the covenant with all living creatures in the damaged world after the deluge recorded in Genesis, chapter 9. This covenant is unconditional, that is, it involves no stipulations contingent on the observance of which God agrees to do something. It is a decree of God's free and benevolent will, therefore more a testament than covenant. It is also, according to critical consensus, a product of the priest class and later than the standard Deuteronomic covenant type, perhaps induced by a profound sense of the limitations of human moral capacity after the liquidation of the Judean state and the reflection to which that catastrophe gave rise.
Walzer is on surer ground in dealing with the legal material in his second chapter. He notes the unique or at least special characteristics of Hebrew jurisprudence. Unlike the law collections that have come to us from the ancient Near East, among them the famous Code of Hammurapi, biblical laws do not emanate from the monarchy. All, including the monarch, are subject to the laws, a situation illustrated by the prophetic condemnation of King Ahab's confiscation of Naboth's vineyard (23). Another characteristic is that most of the laws are presented in a narrative context which can serve an interpretive role, and several of them carry motivation clauses. One of the case laws offers a very specific example: “If you take your neighbor's cloak in surety you must return it to him by sunset, because it is his only covering. It is the cloak in which he wraps himself; how else will he sleep? If he appeals to me I shall listen, for I am compassionate” (Exod. 22:26–27). This injunction corresponds to one of the very few specific references to laws in the prophets to whom books are attributed (Amos 2:8). Apropos of this, Walzer notes that the prophets were the only ones who could challenge the law, but in fact there are relatively few references or appeals to the laws in prophetic texts prior to the exile.
In his chapter “Conquest and Holy War,” Walzer avoids any semblance of justifying or even mitigating the problematic nature of the accounts of the conquest of Canaan and genocidal slaughter of the indigenous populations and, on a smaller scale, the way in which the tribe of Dan secured new territory by conquering and killing its inhabitants (49). To these examples we may add the extermination of the Arab tribes of Amalekites (Exod. 17) and Midianites (Num. 31). On the other side of the ledger, Israel's long experience of subjection to imperial rule—Assyrian, Babylonian, Persian, Macedonian, and Roman—gave rise to the question what to do and what policy to adopt faced with the overwhelming power of empire, a major issue in any study of ancient Israelite politics. In his chapter “Prophecy and International Politics,” Walzer suggests that the religiously sanctioned foreign policy recommended by the prophets was to do nothing (100). This may appear to be the case if we confine ourselves to certain passages in Isaiah, but the accounts in 2 Kings 24–25 and Jeremiah 34–44 of what happened immediately preceding the fall of Jerusalem and liquidation of the Judean state in 586 BCE reveal a quite complex scene of parties and politics, with prophets on both sides of the issue whether to support or oppose revolt against the Babylonian empire. Jeremiah appears as the spokesman for those whom their opponents would have viewed as the appeasement party, while ranged against him was the prophet Hananiah in Judah (Jer. 28) and Ahab and Zedekiah, executed (martyred?) by the Babylonians in the diaspora (Jer. 29:21).
In his final recapitulatory chapter, “Politics in the Shadow,” Walzer insists once again that, in contrast to the Greek-speaking world, ancient Israel was innocent of political theory, and that it would be anachronistic to conclude from the idea of equality under a divinely sanctioned law that it was in some way democratic. He does, however, go on to describe it, unhelpfully in my opinion, as a “democracy under God” or an “almost democracy” (199–200). What, perhaps, is lacking is a realistic description of the kind of society in which these texts were produced by relatively small schools of intellectual and religious specialists. It is an agrarian society, for the most part illiterate, for which the kinship network was more important than the state and which, in addition to the worship of the national deity, practiced its own immemorial family cults including the cult of the goddess under different titles and forms, as the abundant archaeological and textual evidence attests. (For the latter, see the reply of the deportees in Egypt to Jeremiah in Jer. 44:15–19).
All in all, In God's Shadow is the work of a humane and generous spirit, the kind not always in evidence in discussions and debates about the Bible and politics. When we add to this the author's detailed familiarity with these texts and the insights he draws from them, this is a book no one with a serious interest in politics and religion can afford to miss.
