Mughal Gujarat and the Office of the Mutasaddi
The early 1570s marked a watershed in the history of the Mughal empire's relationship with the Indian Ocean world. During these years, from the new imperial capital of Fathpur Sikri founded in 1571, the Mughal Emperor Akbar (r. 1556–1605) managed nothing less than to conquer the two most important maritime states of the Indian subcontinent: Gujarat, in the north-western littoral of India, which became an imperial province in 1572–73, and Bengal, located on the opposite coast, which was conquered between 1574–76.Footnote 1 It would be difficult to underestimate the significance of these twin conquests, as historians of the Indian Ocean have underscored time and again, derived from the central position occupied by the two sultanates, their port-cities and their merchant communities in the material life of early modern maritime Asia. It was perhaps a Portuguese Jesuit Duarte de Sande who, using a somewhat poetic formula as early as 1579, best captured the economic and political importance of the two newly conquered imperial provinces. Through their conquest, he noted in a letter to his brothers in Coimbra (Portugal), Akbar had become lord of the “gem of India”.Footnote 2
The focus of the present article is Gujarat, the western of these two new imperial provinces or “gems”, whose conquest provided the occasion for a pair of novel experiences in the life of the triumphant Akbar. Remarkably, despite the fact that he was at the time already a mature man in his early thirties, it was only upon reaching the Gujarati port of Cambay (Khambayat) in 1572 that the Mughal Emperor Akbar first laid eyes on the ocean. He then ventured onto a boat for a cruise at sea which, according to the chronicler ‘Arif Qandahari, helped to clear his mind.Footnote 3 Akbar's time in Gujarat was also the occasion for a new experience of a different kind: his first meetings with the Portuguese (initially in Cambay in December 1572, and again in Surat in March 1573), who by then were already well-versed in the intricacies of the commercial and political life of Gujarat, and yet extremely impressed with the Mogor's might. Those encounters are described in Portuguese and Mughal texts alike, and while there are sizeable differences between the two versions, both agree on one point: Akbar took a keen interest in all the exotic commodities that the foreigners brought to him, from Portuguese wine, which he drank in excess, to Portuguese clothes, which he immediately decided to put on.Footnote 4
What were the long-term implications of Akbar's first contact both with the Indian Ocean and with the Portuguese in Gujarat? And what relevance does it hold for the subject of the present article? Although several decades divide these colourful events from the careers of early seventeenth-century Mughal port officials in Gujarat, discussed in the pages below, Akbar's boat journey off Cambay can be understood as a metaphor for the development of the Mughal empire itself, a continental state that first took shape in distant and land-locked Kabul during the very early years of the sixteenth century, but which had grown to encompass considerable maritime domains. As a result Gujarat, and especially the port of Surat,Footnote 5 became the central node in a web of oceanic connections that the Mughal empire was to develop in the following years, gradually transforming the imperial family and ruling elite into artful maritime merchants.Footnote 6
Similarly, the gifts presented to Akbar by the Portuguese on this occasion illustrate the beginning of a long-term connection between Europeans (Firangis) and Mughals which also feature the Gujarati ports as one of its main arenas of interaction. And as we shall see below, such dealings were moulded by an interesting combination of power rituals and mercantile practices, in which the Mughal officials were able to easily switch from political language to commercial talk.
In this respect, the classic and somewhat rigid distinction between merchants and rulers that has informed much of the modern scholarly literature about early modern India and the Indian Ocean is contradicted by the personal and collective trajectories of many Mughal port officials, whose careers can be reconstructed by combining European and Indo-Persian sources. Far from suggesting clear-cut opposition between land and sea, their profiles instead seem to fit best into a model in which politics and trade go hand in hand.Footnote 7
Recent work by Farhat Hasan, especially his book entitled State and Locality in Mughal India, has provided us with a more accurate picture of the office of the mutasaddi (governor) and of the identity of those serving in that position between the late sixteenth and the early eighteenth centuries in the major maritime settlements of Gujarat. Thanks to his work, we now know that the governors of Surat sometimes acted as governors of the subsidiary port of Cambay, but when this was not the case, “there was acute competition between them to attract merchants and a larger share of revenues from overseas trade”. Hasan also notes that the governors of Surat, being merchants themselves, constituted the nodal point of impressive local webs of commercial power and political influence, composed of a large caste of characters ranging from the shahbandar, noble family members, and affluent local merchants as well as members of the Hindu service gentry. Consequently, he goes on to argue that “the state was deeply enmeshed in the local social forces, and that the ‘office’ itself was quite incapable of serving as an earnest instrument of the imposition of imperial will on local customs and practices”. Moreover, these positions were heavily subjected to ‘office-farming’ until at least 1640, yet further eroding the distinctions between state office-holding and private interests.Footnote 8
Hasan's study thus constitutes a seminal contribution to our knowledge of political and commercial relations in the western maritime border of the Mughal domains. However, my own research on the careers of individual mutasaddis of Surat in the first half of the seventeenth-century—based mainly (but not exclusively) on existent Portuguese materials—can help us to better understand the social world of those occupying key-positions in the ‘waterfront’ of the Mughal empire. Below is an analysis of the professional trajectories of two such individuals: Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa.
The “Imperfect Christian”: Muqarrab Khan
In 19 December 1617, travelling in the company of his wife Nur Jahan, the Mughal Emperor Jahangir (r. 1605–27) arrived in Cambay and glimpsed the “salted sea”, as Jahangir himself described it. Once on the shore, and in a way strikingly similar to his father some 45 years earlier, Jahangir went for a short boat ride off Cambay, which he also describes in his memoirs together with a digression on the history and commercial relevance of that port.Footnote 9 Meanwhile, concerned about the intentions behind this potentially threatening activity, the Portuguese viceroy in Goa used his local informants to follow developments closely. But his suspicions were at least partly allayed by a report that Jahangir's empress (a Tehrani) had simply asked her husband to take her to the littoral because she wanted to see the ocean for the first time.Footnote 10
Thus, on the surface, this episode would seem to be a perfect repeat of Akbar's gestures of 1572, although one has to admit that conditions had changed substantially during the intervening decades. For one, by the late 1610s the chief maritime settlements of Gujarat were undoubtedly frequented by more (and more diverse) European visitors than in the early 1570s. Both the English East India Company (EIC) and the Dutch Verenigde Oost-Indische Compagnie (VOC) acquired a substantial presence in the region by the beginning of the seventeenth century,Footnote 11 and a multitude of independent western travellers also entered the empire via the local port-towns, such as the French Augustin de Hiriart, the English Thomas Coryat, the German Henrich von Poser or the Flemish Jacques de Coutre. Mughal Gujarat had thus become a ‘fashionable spot’ for different groups of Europeans, who engaged themselves in a sort of ‘Great Game’ out of time and place.
To meet the new commercial and political challenges posed by this mounting foreign presence, it was therefore important for Mughal policy makers in the imperial capital to make the right choices concerning the nomination of port officials. As a result Jahangir, unlike his father Akbar, did not primarily select members of the traditional Afghan nobility to occupy relevant positions in Gujarat. Instead, he clearly defined a different profile of candidates, opting for the most part for ‘cosmopolitan’ Indian Muslims (Shaikhzadas) and Persians. Within this milieu, one of the figures emerging from both Mughal and European sources is a certain Shaikh Hasan, who was later granted the title of Muqarrab Khan (“Royal confidant”) by Jahangir, and who has attracted a considerable amount of recent attention from historians.Footnote 12
Born in Kairana (Muzaffarnagar district, Delhi province), Muqarrab Khan was the son of a distinguished doctor and surgeon (Shaikh Bina) and soon followed his father's footsteps, with whom he actually jointly worked to save Akbar's life in 1596. Thereafter, Muqarrab Khan's notable political career became closely associated with Jahangir and his strategy of promoting the Shaikhzadas within the imperial elite, as the attribution of the extremely high administrative rank or mansab of 5,000/5,000 in 1615–6 clearly reflects.Footnote 13 Despite having many enemies at the imperial court,Footnote 14 varied sources note that Muqarrab Khan managed to maintain his status as member of Jahangir's inner circle for many years,Footnote 15 and it is certainly no coincidence that a good number of Mughal miniatures (painted by prominent artists such as ‘Abid, Balchand and Abu'l Hasan) depict him side by side with the emperor at some of the more significant moments of Jahangir's reign.Footnote 16
Numerous European observers understood the contours of this close relationship between the two. Both Jesuit missionaries and Portuguese officials regularly underscored the fact that Muqarrab Khan was one of the most prominent favourites (valido, privado) of the emperor,Footnote 17 and the same holds true for the English: Thomas Aldworth wrote in 1613 that Muqarrab Khan was “a great man with the King and a politic”,Footnote 18 while Thomas Elkington noted two years later that “the present Governor is so favored, and the King ruled by hym, that whatsoever good is to be exspected from the courte must bee by meanes of this man hear, the King referring all concernynge us to hym and will not do any thinge in our behaulfes but what from hym he shall bee advised”.Footnote 19
Muqarrab Khan served in different capacities in a number of imperial provinces, but the positions that he intermittently occupied in Gujarat for at least 15 years (1608–23) were certainly among the most prominent.Footnote 20 Consequently, he became a key figure in terms of Mughal contacts with Europeans during that particular period. Shah Nawaz Khan points out that the emperor may have chosen him to occupy such positions due to his solid knowledge of the jewel trade and because the Gujarati ports were a “mine of rarities and a center of treasures”, and it is well known that Muqarrab Khan kept sending rarities to the imperial court, from European paintings and ‘Frankish’ hats to bejewelled items and exotic animals.Footnote 21 But the same author also goes on to state that the emperor's favourite, once he had become Gujarat's provincial governor or subadar, proved unable to rule the province effectively or to control the army, prompting Jahangir to replace him in 1617 with his own son, Khurram. It is thus possible that Muqarrab Khan, who had shown himself to be quite efficient when dealing with the affairs of individual maritime settlements, was not up to the economic and political challenge of ruling over the entire province of Gujarat.Footnote 22 This impression is reinforced by a farman, or imperial decree, that was subsequently issued by prince Khurram to the Portuguese, in which he states that his father had chosen him for that position with the explicit charge of improving the economic and social situation of the province.Footnote 23
Such administrative shortcomings notwithstanding, there is little doubt that Muqarrab Khan was one of the first Mughal nobles appointed in the maritime province of Gujarat to really master the relationship with the Europeans. One proof of his ability to manipulate the rivalries between the various communities of Firangis is that no one—Portuguese, English or Dutch—was fully satisfied with his behaviour.Footnote 24 More importantly, he understood how to mould the foreigners to the needs of the empire and the desires of the emperor, without losing sight of his own material interests. Like many other members of the Mughal elite, including the imperial family and the emperor himself,Footnote 25 the governor of Surat owned vessels and engaged in private trade in maritime Asia,Footnote 26 taking advantage of strategic partnerships with people like the affluent Khwaja Nizam. Besides this, Muqarrab Khan's performance as a political and commercial entrepreneur certainly benefitted from a solid family network. His brother, a certain Shaikh Abdur Rahim, was also based in Surat,Footnote 27 while his son-in-law was described by his contemporary Nicholas Dowtown as “a very ingenious young man”.Footnote 28
During Muqarrab Khan's extended stay in Gujarat, his relationship with the Estado da Índia was shaped by two major events. The first of these occurred in 1611 when, following a practice established by Akbar in the 1580s, he was sent as Jahangir's envoy (hajib) to the Portuguese administrative capital in Goa in the company of Father Manuel Pinheiro. Previous Mughal ambassadors, who like Muqarrab Khan frequently hailed from Gujarat, were typically seen in Goa as simple merchants, or worse, as disguised spies. Such was the case, for example, of Khwaja Muhammad Tahir, who visited Goa in 1579–80 and was son of the then mutasaddi of Cambay, Imaduddin Hasan.Footnote 29 But Muqarrab Khan, despite a profile that was not substantially different from that of his predecessors, certainly seems to have made a much stronger impression in the capital of the Estado.
An excerpt from an anonymous and unpublished Jesuit chronicle provides us with a rather detailed account of the events surrounding his visit to Goa in 1611.Footnote 30 According to the text, Muqarrab Khan travelled by sea from Cambay to Goa accompanied by 300 people and was received by the Portuguese viceroy Rui Lourenço de Távora (1609–12) with all diplomatic conventions. Apart from the usual rituals and gestures common to these occasions (formal audiences and dinners, public festivals, exchange of gifts), Muqarrab Khan discussed commercial matters thoroughly with his Portuguese counterpart and, as expected, spent some time acquiring expensive rarities (peças coriozas e de preço) on behalf of Jahangir. He failed to buy an exquisite piece of furniture costing 30,000 cruzados and was later criticised by the emperor for having left behind such a precious object. Among the commodities brought back from Goa to the Mughal court was a turkey, which was received with great excitement. Not only did Jahangir describe the animal in his memoirs,Footnote 31 but he also asked the celebrated painter Mansur to depict it.Footnote 32 Along the same lines, another Mughal miniature painted by Bulaqi ca. 1625 shows Muqarrab Khan presenting this and other exotic animals brought from Goa to the emperor.Footnote 33
The most intriguing section of this chronicle, however, is the one narrating the alleged conversion of Muqarrab Khan to Christianity in Goa at the hands of Father Nicolau Pimenta, the Jesuit Visitor. The conversion was kept secret to avoid uprisings among the Muslims, and the Portuguese viceroy was thus unable to take advantage of what would always then have been considered a victory across the Catholic world: a century earlier, Pope Leo X had transformed the public baptism of al-Hasan al-Wazzan (or Leo Africanus) into the triumph of Christendom over “the Turk”.Footnote 34
As far as we know, Muqarrab Khan never wrote about this spiritual experience and his move, if he really made it, is one that can today be interpreted in different ways, ranging from a simple survival strategy to a genuine expression of spiritual curiosity. For someone as familiar with the eclectic approach to the world of religion exhibited by emperors like Akbar and Jahangir, the latter hypothesis seems to be a solid one. Avril Powell has compared Muqarrab Khan's gesture to other (later) cases of individual conversion to Christianity among the elites of north-western India. More importantly, by building on the work of Richard Eaton, Powell draws a distinction between ‘conversion’ and ‘adherence’, the former corresponding to a full spiritual reconfiguration while the latter being determined by special circumstances and implying nothing else than a ‘superficial’ performance of rites and gestures pertaining to another religion. In sum, one could receive baptism without necessarily converting to Christianity.Footnote 35 In the end, a fundamental and inevitable misunderstanding seems to have occurred: the Portuguese envisaged Muqarrab's conversion as full and definitive, while we know that in the early modern world one's approach (and eventual conversion) to Christianity in different cultural zones was often an incomplete, incoherent and contradictory process.Footnote 36
Be that as it may, the Portuguese were truly excited by the prospect of this ‘conversion’, which was facilitated by Muqarrab Khan's close friendship with Manuel Pinheiro and had been preceded by a number of hints as to his intentions, including his devotion to Christian imagery and the baptism of his adopted son in 1608.Footnote 37 But even so the metamorphosis of Muqarrab Khan into D. João de Távora (adopting the family name of his local host, Rui Lourenço de Távora) did not take long to disappoint the Portuguese: as early as December 1611, the viceroy of Goa noted wryly that this “crooked Muslim” (mouro velhaco) immediately returned to his old religious practices and failed to meet his spiritual and temporal commitments.Footnote 38
The story of Muqarrab Khan's relationship with the Portuguese does not end here, however. A second opportunity came only two years later during an outbreak of open hostilities between the Mughal empire and the Estado da Índia. Seriously worried about the growing threat posed by other European rivals in the region, as well as with the number of ships circulating between the Red Sea and Gujarat without a safe-conduct (cartaz),Footnote 39 in August of 1613 the Portuguese decided to capture a rich “nau of Mecca” off Surat. But contrary to what Goa had expected, this act was to cause a violent reaction by Jahangir and provoke a major crisis between the two states, which was only to be solved two years later.Footnote 40 Muqarrab Khan took the lead in this process acting as Jahangir's mediatorFootnote 41 and he eventually signed an agreement with the Estado da Índia in June 1615.Footnote 42 My purpose here is not to analyse this conflict in detail, but rather to decode Muqarrab Khan's actions during the crisis.
A Portuguese document dated February 1615 describes the tough negotiations between the Mughal envoy and his Portuguese counterpart (Gonçalo Pinto da Fonseca, the chancellor of the Estado) in Surat. In the main surviving account of these negotiations, Muqarrab Khan is portrayed as a skilled power-broker without a trace of a merchant's demeanour, presenting himself almost as a head of state by cultivating distance from his Portuguese petitioners and engaging in rituals full of symbolic meaning. Upon the arrival of Pinto da Fonseca to Surat, for instance, Muqarrab Khan at first refused to allow him to enter the city, subjecting the chancellor and his men to an endless, useless and humiliating wait in a tent without providing any sort of explanation. Subsequently, he adopted challenging gestures in peak moments of a rather tense negotiation process, at one point sending two empty baskets to the Portuguese and ordering the viceroy to fill them up with “some wine from Portugal, olives and capers”.Footnote 43
One problem with the interpretation of this series of interactions, however, is that the account that we have been closely following is drawn from a pamphlet that was written against viceroy Dom Jerónimo de Azevedo (1612–7) in the form of a fictitious letter written from Surat by an anonymous author (“an official of the secretary”) to his brother. Given this subtext, is it possible that the meeting between Gonçalo Pinto da Fonseca and Muqarrab Khan may not have been that tense after all? The chronicler António Bocarro, for one, gives a totally different version of events. He writes that Muqarrab Khan had later excused his initial lack of response to Fonseca as the result of serious heath problems suffered by his wife after a difficult childbirth. Recalling to the Portuguese his splendid reputation as doctor and surgeon, he argued that had he not intervened she would certainly have died. Bocarro then goes on to note that Muqarrab Khan was eager to reconcile himself with the chancellor of the Estado, and with the help of the Jesuits he sent Fonseca some gifts, and even wrote him friendly letters headed with the sign of the Cross and the name of Jesus. Moreover, with regard to the question of Muqarrab Khan's religious identity, Bocarro classifies the Mughal noble not as a false convert but rather “an imperfect Christian” because he lacked “that perfection of faith that makes one despise all goods, honors and riches of the world, and even one's own life”.Footnote 44
Muqarrab Khan may well have been an “imperfect Christian”, but he certainly was the perfect political dissimulator, skilfully combining the paths of diplomacy and war. For even while negotiating with the Estado, we also know that he was secretly preparing an attack on the Portuguese stronghold of Daman, for which he tried to gain the support of both the EIC and the VOC.Footnote 45 In fact, in their own report about the outcome of these negotiations, the English explicitly stated that Muqarrab Khan had instructions from Jahangir not to make peace with the Portuguese.Footnote 46
In any case, the conflict in Gujarat between the Mughal empire and the Estado da Índia eventually came to a peaceful end in 1615, and in subsequent years there was no sign of any lingering Portuguese acrimony towards Muqarrab Khan. Moreover, his Christian identity seems to have survived longer in Goa than might have been predicted. The Jesuit annual letter of 1621, for example, states that, while serving as subadar of Bihar, Muqarrab Khan had openly favoured the missionaries in Patna. In their account of his activities, the Jesuits portrayed the governor of the province as a sort of “hidden Christian”, unable to “declare himself Christian without risking his life”,Footnote 47 but still holding enough authority to patronise a church, encourage conversions and organise theological debates between Catholic priests and ulama, somehow replicating the tolerant religious policies that had been pursued in earlier decades by Akbar. Two years later, in 1623, Muqarrab Khan was subadar of Delhi and his connection to Christianity and the missionaries seem to have grown even stronger: the Jesuit correspondence of that year reported that “the nababo D. João de Távora intends to build a church in his hometown and he is now a declared Christian. He very much favours the padres and takes every possible occasion to mention them to the Mogor. He wants to build a royal hospital in Agra, following the same model of the Royal Hospital of Goa, which he saw”.Footnote 48
Mir Musa: “More Merchant than Noble”
My second case takes us to the 1630s and the reign of the Emperor Shahjahan (r. 1628–58), and analyses the career of Mir Musa Mu'izzul Mulk, who first appears in contemporary Portuguese and other European sources as the result of another major dispute between the Estado da Índia and the Mughals.Footnote 49 Much like his predecessor Muqarrab Khan, Mir Musa, who was serving at the time as mutasaddi of Surat, became the Mughals’ interlocutor with Goa during a crisis caused by the capture in late March 1630 of two ships (one of which belonged to the emperor himself) in the main port under his jurisdiction.Footnote 50 Although this action was controversial even among the Portuguese, the motives of the Estado remained essentially similar to those stated back in 1613–15: Mughal ships navigating without a cartaz and open imperial protection of Dutch and English maritime trade in Gujarat.
In the early phase of the crisis, Mir Musa was instructed by the emperor to retaliate by imprisoning the Portuguese living in Surat (including three Jesuit missionaries), and to seize all of their property. There were important names among the captives, such as Father António de Andrade, the Provincial of the Society of Jesus, and Manuel Velho, a Portuguese expert on Mughal matters who the Viceroy Count of Linhares (1629–35) had just dispatched to Surat as his negotiator. The Portuguese responded in kind by arresting all the Gujarati merchants residing in Goa and confiscating their assets as well.Footnote 51 The situation thus became rather tense, and Shahjahan even pondered briefly an outright attack on Daman and Diu. As the English Presidency of Surat put it in April 1630 “how the King will resent these affronts, one of the juncks being his owne wee daily expect. In all appearance a great breach is like to insue”.Footnote 52
The confrontation between the Mughals and the Portuguese was brief, yet intense. It ended with an agreement signed between the parties on 13 September 1630, in which Mir Musa agreed to restrict Dutch and English activities in his ports but left the decision on their definitive expulsion to the authority of Shahjahan, therefore urging Goa to send an ambassador to the imperial capital.Footnote 53 Similar to the treaty of 1615, only the Portuguese text has survived, and it is possible that its contents do not match the Mughal version of the agreement. Further complicating the issue is the fact that the viceroy of Goa demanded that the agreement be ratified by the emperor, but the only additional document that he ever received was a copy of an imperial farman to the officials of the empire dated July 1631. This farman, which we know today from a Portuguese translation inserted in the viceroy's diary, establishes free circulation and trade between the imperial ports and the maritime settlements controlled by the Estado da Índia. However, it includes not a single word about the expected prohibitions to the commercial enterprises of either Dutch or English. And the farman itself was tricky from the Portuguese viewpoint since, as Linhares noted, it was directed to the Mughal officials and not to the viceroy of Goa.Footnote 54
Just as in a seismic crisis, there were aftershocks to the events of March 1630 in the months that followed. On 19 September, the Portuguese took another nau de Meca (a Mughal ship returning from Jiddah) off Surat, but this time the viceroy of Goa was quick to prevent a major conflict and a new treaty with the Mughals was signed two months later in Bulsar.Footnote 55 Once again, Mir Musa acted as the Mughal representative vis-à-vis the Estado da Índia during this entire crisis (March-November 1630) and consequently his name is frequently cited in Portuguese records of the period. However, he was identified in other European sources well before that. According to EIC officials, Mir Musa was jagirdar of Cambay as early as 1623.Footnote 56 And if Jacques de Coutre's testimony is to be credited, he had already visited Goa as Jahangir's envoy in the late 1610s, although unfortunately we have rather scarce information about this mission. At any rate, Mir Musa was said to have acquired an impressive quantity of jewels and pearls during this early visit to Goa, which he bought (apparently without paying) from the German entrepreneur Ferdinand Cron as well as from the Flemish Coutre brothers. Jacques de Coutre, one of his ‘victims’, spends four chapters of his book (“Vida de Jacques de Coutre”) narrating how he followed Mir Musa from Goa to Bijapur and finally to Agra. The Flemish merchant-adventurer states that Mir Musa was already at this early date a protégé of Prince Khurram (the future Emperor Shahjahan) and he takes every opportunity to underline the close connection between the two. Coutre would eventually return to Goa without recovering his money, and his portrait of “Mir Mosa Moluco” is therefore anything but flattering.Footnote 57
Mir Musa's reputation among the English was equally negative. In 1630, they considered him to be “inclined more to the Portugall then to us, as wee gather by some passages betweene them”. And they go on to note: “certain we are hee is more their friend then ours, yet firm to none, being a most falsehearted dissembling fellow as lives in India”.Footnote 58 Still, a decade later, duly impressed by the warm reception given to Mir Musa by the population of Surat when he returned once more as the newly appointed mutasaddi, the Surat Presidency was pleased to develop a good relationship with its local interlocutor.Footnote 59
Mir Musa is one of the many Iranians who managed to build a career that straddled both business and politics and easily found a niche in the Indian subcontinentFootnote 60 or even further east, in states such as Siam and Japan.Footnote 61 Despite having also served during the latter part of Jahangir's reign, it is clear that the main source for his influence and affluence was Shahjahan. In 1653, reporting on an encounter between the emperor and his favourite protégé in Lahore, the Dutch Joan Berckhout and Joan Tack underscored Mir Musa's optimism, confident as he was that Shahjahan would again make him governor of Surat.Footnote 62 His highest mansab, achieved during these years, was 1,500/300, and references to him both in Mughal and English sources are to be found even later, coinciding with the beginning of the reign of Shahjahan's successor Aurangzeb (r. 1658–1707).Footnote 63 Mir Musa thus enjoyed at least three full decades of political visibility, almost permanently serving in Gujarat, and artfully controlling key positions in the maritime settlements of the province.Footnote 64
In a way, what Muqarrab Khan represented for Jahangir in the 1610s is what Mir Musa meant for Shahjahan twenty years later, even if the declared enmity of the powerful Asaf Khan (Shahjahan's father-in-law) may have occasionally damaged his career and limited his influence at court.Footnote 65 Both Mir Musa and Muqarrab Khan were men with solid experience in maritime and European affairs, capable of performing a vast array of tasks, from managing political crises and serving as diplomatic envoys to gathering relevant information and channelling valuable goods from the maritime border to the imperial cities of the interior.
Moreover, while a mansabdar of relatively high stature (although Muqarrab Khan had a far higher rank among the Mughal nobility) Mir Musa also had his own trading vessels,Footnote 66 secured commercial monopolies, counted on the collaboration of family membersFootnote 67 and nurtured close relations with prominent Gujarati merchants such as Hari Vaisya, who was one of the richest traders of Surat in those days. In fact, Hari Vaisya had accompanied Mir Musa to Bulsar in order to negotiate the agreement signed with the Estado da Índia on 28 November 1630, and he may well be the “Andregissá” that some Portuguese documents present as the trading agent and representative (feitor and procurador) of the governor of Surat in Goa.Footnote 68
The dealings between the viceroy Count of Linhares and the “captain of Surat” provide us with telling details about Mir Musa's profile. Beginning in 1630, the Mughal noble wrote a sizeable number of letters to the Portuguese viceroy, and Linhares included some of them (in Portuguese translation) in his diary.Footnote 69 A cursory analysis of these documents clearly demonstrates that they were penned by someone who was schooled in the conventions of Mughal diplomacy and letter-writing, revealing Mir Musa to have been cautious where names and titles were concerned, and skilful at inserting rhetorical expressions of affection and friendship even in the midst of hard negotiations. As one could expect, he also gives special importance to gift-giving, sending rich presents to Linhares and his two representatives in Surat (Manuel Velho and the Jesuit António de Andrade, both meanwhile released), ranging from horses and diamond rings to silk carpets and tents.Footnote 70 In the end, the Portuguese viceroy may have realised that the Mughal mediator was too complex a character on whom to put a single and linear label. Was he devoted to business or to the affairs of the state? Probably eager to diminish his counterpart and to stress his own diplomatic achievements, Linhares considered that “Mirmuza captain of Surat is more of a merchant than of a noble and thus desires to make peace with the Estado”.Footnote 71
In other words, trade and politics were not antagonists in this epoch and region, and, as this article has already stressed, Mir Musa was just one among many mutasaddis of Surat and Cambay with such a profile as both merchant and official. One of his successors in 1646–47 is another case in point. We refer here to a certain Mirza ‘Ali Akbar Isfahani, who like Mir Musa—whom he knew well—was of Persian stock,Footnote 72 and who shared with Muqarrab Khan an expertise in precious stones, in addition to a deep knowledge of horses and the horse trade. Portuguese sources demonstrate that he served as governor of Surat at least as early as 1634, and took the office again in 1640. On that occasion, in fact, he arranged to send one of his ships from that port to China, and eventually succeeded in becoming a business partner of the Estado for that specific trading voyage. According to the agreement worked out with the Portuguese, ‘Ali Akbar offered to pay all the duties in the Portuguese custom-houses related to the voyage as well as to hire a Portuguese pilot capable of sailing to the South China Sea. The Persian magnate also agreed to present himself as vassal of the king of Portugal and suggested that a baniya merchant could travel to China aboard his vessel as procurador of the Portuguese crown. In Goa, the revenue council (Conselho da Fazenda) did not take long to approve the proposal put forward by the “Moor Ali Acabar”, who was described in Goa as a true “friend of the Estado”.Footnote 73
Towards a Profile
What may one conclude from this brief outline of the careers of Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa? How can we present a coherent profile of the mutasaddi of the Gujarati ports in the first half of the seventeenth century by drawing from these two cases?
Firstly, while both may certainly be portrayed as merchant magnates, their role as political entrepreneurs cannot be neglected. Their multiple activities and ‘faces’ allow us to present them as ‘portfolio capitalists’,Footnote 74 those who acted simultaneously as merchants and princes, businessmen and political actors. Despite being close to the world and language of maritime merchants, both Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa always knew how to maintain a strong public image as powerbrokers. As already stated, it was rather common to find in different ports of the Indian subcontinent in the early modern period other Persians such as Mir Musa, people who easily combined government (Imarat) and trade (Tijarat) in their careers.Footnote 75 Das Gupta's assertion that “the amir would seldom stoop to act like a bania” does not always prove to be correct.Footnote 76
In this respect, Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa differed substantially from those who served in the same positions in Gujarat during the early years of Pax Mogolica. Not that the first Mughal governors of the major Gujarati ports did not engage in private maritime trade. However, they seem to have lacked the appropriate skills to deal with the Europeans, as the permanent conflicts with the Portuguese, apparently shaped by religious orthodoxy, suggest. The majority were Afghan (Turani) nobles, men like Qulij Khan Andijani (captain of Surat fort), Qutbuddin Muhammad Khan (captain of Broach), or Shihabuddin Ahmad Khan (subadar of Gujarat) who, unlike our seventeenth-century mutasaddis, were never able to adopt a pragmatic attitude vis-à-vis the Firangis.Footnote 77
On the other hand, Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa profited from a close association with a number of affluent Gujarati merchants but do not seem to have been fundamentally overshadowed by them. Those Mughal nobles acting as governors from the late seventeenth century onwards were far less fortunate, for they had to deal with men like Mulla Abdul Ghafur and other leading merchants, whose agency seem to have strongly limited the political authority and the economic power of successive port-officers.Footnote 78 The later deposition of the mutasaddi of Surat in 1732 by Muhammad Ali, Ahmad Chellaby and Seth Laldas Vitaldas is a telling example.Footnote 79 One may argue that the first of half of the seventeenth century constituted the ‘golden age’ of the mutasaddi of Surat: simultaneously successful in the worlds of business and politics, he was no longer the ‘unskilled’ Turani noble, while the ‘menacing’ Gujarati merchant remained at bay.
My second point relates back to the arguments of Farhat Hasan, already discussed briefly at the beginning of this article, about the undisputed supremacy of locality over the state in Mughal India – expressed in the supposed ability of different mutasaddis to master their relationship with the emperor and successfully resist becoming simple tools of imperial authority. While it is certainly beyond dispute that the Mughal state was never so centralised as historians once believed, and that the different provinces and regions were always active participants and driving policy and implementing their own agendas, it is also true that our sources seem to indicate a much more balanced relationship between local and central, and between the agency of the mutasaddi and the authority of the emperor, than that suggested by Hasan. Furthermore, by stressing so emphatically the ‘independence’ of the governors of Surat vis-à-vis the Mughal court, Hasan ends up by characterising them primarily as merchants rather than imperial officers, and I would argue that they embody a far more complex reality.
My third and final point, building on the previous two, concerns the cultural and intellectual dimensions of these ‘merchants’ and their activities. Most notably, in their dealings with the Portuguese, both Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa managed artfully to cope with tense religious issues. Muqarrab Khan seems to have deliberately cultivated ambiguity in this particular area and he apparently walked the tightrope of his double religious identity sufficiently skilfully to enhance his reputation with the Portuguese without damaging his standing among his Mughal patrons. Mir Musa was never as close to Christianity, but it is known that he too nevertheless cultivated a strong relationship with the Jesuit missionaries, encouraging them to establish missions and open churches in Gujarat.Footnote 80
Similarly, both men were responsible for purchasing rarities for their respective emperors, and each seems to have been a collector of exotica in his own right as well. In this respect, however, Mir Musa was certainly less of a cultured person than Muqarrab Khan, whose many intellectual interests do not entirely match the regular profile of a ‘merchant-prince’ of Surat. The Portuguese too seem to have identified such socio-political differences between the two: while they say nothing about their respective ranks within the Mughal nobility, they understood that Muqarrab Khan had a solid position as valido of Jahangir. And although those who wrote from Goa knew little about Muqarrab Khan's prominent role as a member of the Mughal empire's cultural elite, the “Aristocratic Surgeon” (to borrow Rezavi's image) wrote medical treatises, had a keen interest in horticulture and was fascinated with western technology. His project of creating in Agra a hospital modelled after the one in Goa was part and parcel of such stance. Moreover, Muqarrab Khan also became known for building and renovating, both in Gujarat and in his home town of Kairana, a number of architectural structures.Footnote 81 And while Mir Musa's achievements in this particular field – if any – are unknown, his successor as mutasaddi of Surat, ‛Ali Akbar, is recognised as founder and patron of a Friday Mosque in Cambay.Footnote 82 Nor is Muqarrab Khan and Mir Musa's patronage of Catholic temples in Gujarat or in Bihar considerably distant from this pattern of philanthropic support for mosques.
Merchants and political entrepreneurs, diplomats and collectors of rarities, ‘Christians’ and Muslims, patrons of churches and mosques, here are some of the ingredients that made up the complex world of the mutasaddi of Surat in the first half of the seventeenth century.
Abbreviations:
- AHU
Arquivo Histórico Ultramarino, Lisbon (Portugal)
- ARSI
Archivum Romanum Societatis Iesu, Rome (Italy)
- BA
Biblioteca da Ajuda, Lisbon (Portugal)
- BNP
Biblioteca Nacional de Portugal, Lisbon (Portugal)
- HAG
Historical Archives of Goa, Panaji (India)
