In the Preface to this book, Roger Wilson makes clear his intentions behind its appearance: to raise awareness amongst the scholarly community of the villa at Caddeddi and its extraordinary mosaics by offering interim observations on its architecture and decoration in advance of the final publication by the excavator, Giuseppe Voza. It achieves this superbly. It is underpinned by an excellent text which is crystal clear, tightly argued and highly knowledgeable, and is supported by lavish and abundant illustrations of the key elements of the site and of the extensive comparanda. It will appeal to anyone interested in late antique culture, especially the display strategies of wealthy elites or the socio-economic processes behind the commissioning and production of multi-material interior decoration.
It is not, however, narrowly focused. It presents the wider contextual setting within Sicily and briefly explores the world of Late Antiquity into which it fits. The structure starts with the bigger picture. Ch. 1 gives an account of the known Sicilian villas belonging to the fourth century a.d. — Gerace, Patti Marina, Piazza Armerina, Pistunina, Settefrati — to provide background and context to the finds at Caddeddi. With these villas reviewed, and the Sicilian economy and society sketched out, W. concentrates his attention on Caddeddi, beginning with a chapter (2) discussing its recent history and excavation, the original architectural layout of the villa, and the likely chronology — broadly, the mosaics belong in the second half of the fourth century. W. also introduces the mosaics here, focusing on one of the corridors to the north of the peristyle.
Entered from this corridor are three neighbouring rooms, each decorated with a large figurative mosaic. Each of the next three chapters focuses on a room, starting at the eastern end and moving west. In Room 8 (ch. 3), only the south-west corner of the mosaic survives, including part of one decorative panel and its borders. W. identifies this packed scene as the ransom of the body of Hector, while also unpicking the unusual formulation and other interesting iconographical features. It was surrounded by two borders, a floral band with a tragic mask and a particularly dynamic acanthus scroll populated by wild animals. It was a large room with an apsidal end. The rectangular part of the pavement may have originally had twelve different panels, perhaps all mythological, and must have been an extraordinary visual feast.
In Room 9 (ch. 4) was found another vibrant mosaic with a design based on a cross vault, realised in abundant floral garlands emanating from craters positioned at each of the four corners, and Bacchic representations in the centre of the floor and the middle of each side. Next comes Room 10 (ch. 5) which had a large mosaic, preserved almost in its entirety, depicting thrilling scenes of the hunt and capture of wild and exotic beasts in the upper registers and a more relaxed picture of outdoor dining in the lower. All of this is presided over by a female personification in the centre and surrounded by a virtuoso three-dimensional meander interspersed with identifiable birds. Originally these rooms displayed nearly 150 square metres of exuberant and dramatic mosaic pavement.
The final chapter (6) is a concluding discussion focusing on the interpretation of these mosaics, where W. is confident and assured, as for example during his identification of the personification on the Hunt mosaic as Aethiopia (see his earlier article, ‘On the personification in the Hunt mosaic at the Roman villa of Caddeddi on the Tellaro, Sicily’, Mosaic: The Journal of the Association for the Study and Preservation of Roman Mosaics 42 (2015), 23–35). It concludes with a more speculative and cautious section on the processes behind the production of the mosaics, from the people who laid them, their organisation and place of origin, to the commissioning and choice of iconography.
Throughout W. demonstrates his rich knowledge of Sicilian archaeology, along with a healthy scepticism of precise dates for and specific owners of the villas. More difficult are the issues of who made these mosaics, how and why. W. argues for the end result having close associations with the North African repertoire and connects this to a group, perhaps from Carthage, coming over to Caddeddi to produce them, perhaps at the behest of an agent. W. is in control of the scholarship and rightly calls out the inadequacies of our current understanding of these processes. Petrographic analysis might have helped clarify some aspects of the production, as W. himself accepts, but we are still some way off understanding in detail the nature of artistic projects, in this case from the client deciding to commission the mosaics to the completion of the installation.
Following this final chapter are two appendices focusing on specialist aspects of dress that appear on the mosaics, namely shoes and saddles. The end matter includes a useful index and also an extended summary in Italian. The book will certainly increase knowledge and understanding of the villa and its decoration amongst scholars who read English, and will be accessible to those with Italian too. The price tag is not insignificant, meaning that most will want their libraries to purchase a copy. I highly recommend that they do.
The villa offers another fascinating insight into the interests and buying power of fourth-century elites. The mosaics are superb. W. refers to their style as ‘impressionistic’ and ‘an outstanding success’. He is right. They are extraordinarily vivid, striking any contemporary viewer as visually strong and stylistically confident. The iconographies are rich and fascinating. Even if they draw on a well-known repertoire, they adapt it to the particular needs of the architecture and client. Experiencing them in the late fourth century must have been quite sensational and their sheer size ensured that they were also a physical treat to explore and unravel. W. does an excellent job of bringing this material together and interpreting it. In so doing he achieves his aim to prepare the way for an even more detailed publication of the excavations, but until then this is the book to go to on the villa and its mosaics.
