Sparks drawn from an electrical machine, birds suffocating in an air-pump, ghostly apparitions projected from the laterna magica: spectacular demonstrations performed in public were crucial to the rise of eighteenth-century natural philosophy. Such has been shown by, among others, Larry Stewart, Jan Golinski and Simon Schaffer over the past two decades. Yet most of these studies have concentrated on Great Britain.
Now Michael Lynn has taken a thorough look at popular science in eighteenth-century Paris. Such attention to this side of scientific life in the French capital has been long overdue. Previous studies on French science in the Enlightenment by Charles Gillispie, Roger Hahn and others have tended to gesture occasionally towards popular science while keeping focused on the Académie des sciences and its luminaries, while Geoffrey Sutton's Science for a Polite Society (Boulder, CO, 1995) mainly looked at the salon. Lynn's work on experimental physics practised in the workshops and clubs, and on the streets and public squares, nicely complements these previous studies.
He contends convincingly that popular science played a major role in the ‘appropriation’ of science. The material Lynn has dug up – to a large extent ads for lectures on experimental physics from newspapers such as the Affiches de Paris and the Journal de Paris – brings to light the impressive range of courses being offered to Parisians between roughly 1735 and 1793. He identifies more than seventy different lecturers for this period. From 1775, fifteen lecture courses per year were on average competing for audiences. The lectures dealt with mechanics, optics, electricity, magnetism, the chemistry of gases and so on. Course length ranged from one day to up to a year, with two or even three sessions a week.
Lynn also tackles the tricky question of audience. His evidence is indirect. Who did the demonstrators try to attract through their advertising? What time of the day did they schedule their shows for? Who could afford the often pricy lectures? Were women admitted? Impressively, Lynn comes up with an urban ‘geography’ of popular science, identifying different areas of eighteenth-century Paris which catered for different classes and purses, with the Palais Royal being the most expensive and socially exclusive (a map would have helped to visualize this aspect of the analysis). More generally, popular science took place on different levels and in different institutions. Chapter 4 deals with the musée (nowadays we might say ‘club’), a ‘mixture of philosophical salon, scientific academy, reading society, and public lecture’ (p. 72). Here members could try out instruments and machines for themselves. ‘The ability to actually do experiments’, Lynn argues, ‘created a sense of individual involvement in the Enlightenment enterprise’ (p. 85).
As Lynn repeatedly emphasizes, the public consumed natural philosophy not only in the form of books and magazines but also in the form of lectures and services. He transfers Robert Darnton's idea of the ‘grub street philosophes’ from literature to natural philosophy, i.e. a sizeable group of science popularizers struggling along, with only very few of them, the abbé Nollet for example, being able to gain aristocratic patronage. The most reliable patron was the public itself, eager to be instructed and, more importantly, entertained. In sum, science was rather more shown than taught; what mattered was the demonstration being performed, and the more spectacular the better. ‘The utility of popular science in France centred on its role in providing cultural capital’ (p. 34).
This thriving culture of popular science had its heyday in the decade before the Revolution. Yet, paradoxically, the success of popular science was also the reason for its demise, Lynn concludes. Chapter 5 tells the instructive story of the dowser Barthelemy Bléton. In 1782 his capabilities with the divining rod were put to the test in public, the audience including some members of the Académie des sciences. A public battle ensued over how these experiments were to be interpreted. The following year saw the culmination of Ancien Régime popular science in the ‘balloon craze’, subject of Chapter 6. Typical, in this respect, of popular science generally, at least in the eyes of the elite scientists, ballooning's initial promises of usefulness remained unfulfilled and the ascents turned into a mere spectacle for the uneducated masses. Some of the scientific salesmen had to fight allegations of fraud, and were accused of misleading the public or even fostering superstition. In the 1780s the balloon craze and other enthusiasms led to a showdown between popular science and elite science. The academicians felt more and more called upon to denounce individual popularizers as charlatans. In the debates on dowsing, ballooning and Mesmerism, the academicians succeeded in establishing themselves as the final arbiters in determining scientific truths and what counted as proof.
Popular Science and Public Opinion in Eighteenth-Century France is rather slim, less than two hundred pages, and it is not hard to imagine what might have been added. There is not much of a comparative aspect to Lynn's book. How did popular science in France differ from popular science in Britain, Germany or Italy? The latter two had no commanding capital, for example, and therefore no scientific centre. With so many case studies on the table, it might be time for an overall picture. One would also like to know more about the ‘material’ side of the story. What kinds of instruments and other devices were used in the lectures and who manufactured them? In what ways were they different from ‘research instruments’? Coulomb's highly sensitive torsion balance, for example, excluded any watching audience. Such a focus on instruments might have helped to elaborate further the epistemological questions that Lynn raises, for instance by referring to Peter Heering's juxtaposition of Coulomb's ‘royalist’ approach and Jean Paul Marat's ‘democratic’ approach in dealing with electrical phenomena, linking different experimental styles to political agendas. Surprisingly, the imminence of the Revolution gets a little lost in Lynn's account, despite Robert Darnton's important work of some forty years ago, when he identified a radical political element in Mesmerism in the 1780s in Paris.
