Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:18:15.644Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Capturing the influence of intermolecular potential in rarefied gas flows by a kinetic model with velocity-dependent collision frequency

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2022

Ruifeng Yuan
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanics and Aerospace Engineering, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen 518055, PR China
Lei Wu*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanics and Aerospace Engineering, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen 518055, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: wul@sustech.edu.cn

Abstract

A kinetic model called the $\nu$-model is proposed to replace the complicated Boltzmann collision operator in the simulation of rarefied flows of monatomic gas. The model follows the relaxation-time approximation, but the collision frequency (i.e. inverse relaxation time) is a function of the molecular velocity to reflect part of the collision details of the Boltzmann equation, and the target velocity distribution function (VDF) to which the VDF relaxes is close to that used in the Shakhov model. Based on the numerical simulation of strong non-equilibrium shock waves, a half-theoretical and half-empirical collision frequency is designed for different intermolecular potentials: the $\nu$-model shows significantly improved accuracy, and the underlying mechanism is analysed. The $\nu$-model also performs well in canonical rarefied microflows, especially in thermal transpiration, where kinetic models with velocity-independent collision frequency lack the capability to distinguish the influence of intermolecular potentials.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The Mach 5 shock wave structures for molecules interacting through inverse power-law potentials: Shakhov model, blue dashed line; ESBGK model, green dash-dotted lines; Boltzmann equation, red circles; $\nu$-model, Asterisks. Note that the characteristic length is chosen to be the mean free path $L=({16}/{5{\rm \pi} })\sqrt {{{\rm \pi} }/{2mk_BT_0}} ({\mu (T_0)}/{n_0})$ in the upstream part of the normal shock wave, so we take $Kn=5{\rm \pi} /16$ in the numerical simulation. The shock density centre is at $x_2=0$. (a) Maxwell gas, $\omega =1$; (b) inverse power-law potential, $\omega =0.75$; and (c) HS gas, $\omega =0.5$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Molecular-velocity-dependent collision frequency based on the semiempirical formulae  (5.1) and  (5.2) for different intermolecular potentials. The Lennard-Jones potential for argon with the potential depth $\epsilon =119.2k_B$ is considered.

Figure 2

Table 1.Numerical fitting of the equilibrium collision frequency by the quartic function $\nu ^{0}_{eq}(\xi )=\sum _{j=0}^{4}c_j\xi ^{j}$, when $\xi \le 5$, as well as the constants $A$ in (3.13) and $\beta$ in (3.14). When $\xi >5$, the collision frequency $\nu ^{0}_{eq}$ can be approximated when the first-order Taylor expansion is applied to (2.17), resulting in $\nu ^{0}_{eq}= (2-\omega )\sqrt {{\rm \pi} }\xi ^{2(1-\omega )}$. In the calculation of $\beta$ we take the Prandtl number to be ${Pr}=2/3$, while the collision frequency is given by (5.1).

Figure 3

Figure 3.The Mach 5 normal shock wave in argon, using the Lennard-Jones potential: solid lines, Boltzmann solutions with the collision kernel (4.5); asterisks, the $\nu$-model with the collision frequency (5.2); blue dashed lines, Shakhov model.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Marginal VDFs in the argon normal shock wave of ${Ma}=5$, using the Lennard-Jones potential. (a,b) Number density distribution $\int {f}\, {\textrm {d}}v_1\, {\textrm {d}}v_3$ and (c,d) thermal energy distribution $\int {c^{2}f}\, {\textrm {d}}v_1\, {\textrm {d}}v_3$. Solid lines, Boltzmann solutions; asterisks, $\nu$-model with the collision frequency (5.2); blue dashed lines, Shakhov model.

Figure 5

Table 2.Proportions of the molecular number density $\int _{{v_2} < 0} {f\, {\textrm {d}}\boldsymbol v}/\int {f\, {\textrm {d}}\boldsymbol v}$ and thermal energy $\int _{{v_2} < 0} {c^{2}f\, {\textrm {d}}\boldsymbol v} /\int {c^{2}f\, {\textrm {d}}\boldsymbol v}$ occupied by molecules with $v_2<0$, in the argon normal shock wave with ${Ma}=5$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Reciprocal shock thickness in argon normal shock wave. $\delta _\rho =({{{\rho _1} - {\rho _0}}})/{{\max ({\textrm {d}}\rho /{\textrm {d} x})}}$ and $\delta _T=({{{T _1} - {T _0}}})/{{\max ({\textrm {d}}T /{\textrm {d} x})}}$, where $\rho _0,T_0$ and $\rho _1,T_1$ are the upstream and downstream quantities, respectively. Results of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are adopted from Valentini & Schwartzentruber (2009). Experimental results are adopted from Alsmeyer (1976) and Schmidt (1969). (a) Density-based thickness and (b) temperature-based thickness.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Space-homogeneous relaxation of bimodal distribution function. Evolution of (a) the reduced number density distribution $\int f \, {\textrm {d}}v_y\, {\textrm {d}}v_z$ and (b) the thermal energy distribution $\int \boldsymbol {c}^{2}f \, {\textrm {d}}v_y\, {\textrm {d}}v_z$. The time, normalised by $\mu /p$, corresponding to each line (in the direction towards Maxwellian distribution) is $t=0, 1.2, 2.4, 3.6$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Evolution of the collision integrals for different moments in the space-homogeneous relaxation of bimodal distribution function: (a) $C_{\sigma _{xx}}=2\int (c_x^{2}-|\boldsymbol {c}|^{2}/3)Q \, {\textrm {d}} \boldsymbol {v}$; (b) $C_{q}=\int c_x|\boldsymbol {c}|^{2}Q \, {\textrm {d}} \boldsymbol {v}$; (c) $C_{4}=\int c_x^{4}Q \, {\textrm {d}} \boldsymbol {v}$; (d) $C_{6}=\int c_x^{6}Q \, {\textrm {d}} \boldsymbol {v}$. The time $t$ is normalised by $\mu /p$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Density, velocity and temperature variables along the central horizontal line in the front of cylinder, in supersonic flows of HS gas around a circular cylinder: (a) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (b) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$; (c) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (d) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Temperature contours in supersonic flows of HS gas around a circular cylinder. Colour bands, $\nu$-model; black dashed lines, Shakhov model; black solid lines, DSMC results. Here (a) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (b) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$; (c) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (d) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Thermal energy distributions $\int {c^{2}f\, {\textrm {d}} {v_z}}$ in supersonic flows of HS gas of $Ma =5$ around a circular cylinder, at locations before the bow shock: (a) ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$ at $(x,y)=(-2.2r,-0.055r)$, molecules with $v_x<0$ occupy 15.38 % and 5.65 % of the total thermal energy in the Shakhov model and $\nu$-model, respectively; (b) ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$ at $(x,y)=(-4.4r,-0.11r)$, molecules with $v_x<0$ occupy 23.63 % and 14.70 % of the total thermal energy in the Shakhov model and $\nu$-model, respectively. Grey surface, $\nu$-model; wire frame, Shakhov model.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Distributions of the shear stress and heat flux along the cylinder surface, in supersonic flows of HS gas around a circular cylinder: (a) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (b) $Ma =5$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$; (c) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=0.1$; (d) $Ma =20$, ${Kn}_{{HS}}=1$.

Figure 13

Table 3.Drag coefficient $C_d$ and heat transfer coefficient $C_h$ in supersonic flows of HS gas of ${Ma }=20$ around a circular cylinder. Here $C_d=D/(\frac {1}{2}\rho _\infty \boldsymbol {u}_\infty ^{2}r)$, $C_h=H/(\frac {1}{2}\rho _\infty \boldsymbol {u}_\infty ^{3}r)$, where $D$ and $H$ are the total stress and the total heat flux on the cylinder surface, respectively. The numerical errors for the results of kinetic models are estimated as 0.2 % for $C_d$ and 0.45 % for $C_h$.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Couette flow: panels (i–iii), $Kn=0.1$; panels (iv–vi), $Kn=1$. The abscissas $x_2$ are for the spatial coordinate, which is in the direction perpendicular to the two plates and normalised by the wall distance. The two plates are located in $x_2=0$ and $x_2=1$. Variables are under the normalisation of (4.1). The heat flux is parallel to the wall velocity. Due to symmetry, only the half-spatial region is shown. (a) Maxwell gas and (b) HS gas.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Velocity profiles in the thermal transpiration between two parallel plates. Abscissas are for the spatial coordinate $x_2$ which is perpendicular to the two plates and normalised by the wall distance. The two plates are located in $x_2=0$ and 1. Due to symmetry, only half-spatial region is shown. Note that the Shakhov and ESBGK models do not distinguish the influence of intermolecular potential, and the $\nu$-model is reduced to the Shakhov model for Maxwellian gas. Here (a) $Kn=0.01$; (b) $Kn=0.1$; (c) $Kn=1$.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Mass flow rate $2\int _0^{1} {{u_1}\, {\textrm {d}} {x_2}}$ versus the rarefaction parameter in the thermal transpiration of argon when the Lennard-Jones potential is used. The wall temperature is 300 K. The reference result is the Boltzmann solution calculated by the fast spectral method (FSM).

Figure 17

Figure 15.Thermal transpiration of HS gas in a rectangular cavity of aspect ratio 5: temperature fields and streamlines (in half of the channel) calculated by Boltzmann equation and different kinetic models. The Knudsen number is 0.5.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Thermal transpiration of HS gas in a rectangular cavity: velocity and normal stress profiles calculated by Boltzmann equation and different kinetic models. The cavity aspect ratio is 5, Knudsen numbers are 0.1 (results passing through circles) and 0.5, respectively.

Figure 19

Table 4.Computational time of the multiscale implicit scheme (see the Appendix A) to reach the residual $10^{-9}$ for the lid-driven cavity flow simulation. The spatial mesh is $61\times 61$. Computation is executed on a single core of the computer with Intel(R) Xeon(R) Gold 6148 CPU @ 2.40 GHz.

Figure 20

Table 5.Computational time of the multiscale implicit scheme (see the Appendix A) to reach the residual $10^{-9}$ for the Mach 5 flow around a circular cylinder. The spatial mesh is $50\times 128$ and the velocity space is discretised as $90\times 90\times 50$. Parallel computing is used for these calculations on 40 cores of a computer with Intel(R) Xeon(R) Gold 6148 CPU @ 2.40 GHz.