Research Handbook on Law, Governance and Planetary Boundaries constitutes a crucial and innovative collection. The handbook opens by acknowledging the inadequacy of existing international environmental law and related domestic legal regimes in our era of profound socio-ecological breakdown. Climate change and other aspects of the global ecological crisis, such as acute biodiversity loss and environmental justice issues along lines of race, gender, Indigenous status, the Global South and North divide, etc., require more transformative approaches than those steeped in our current “neoliberal sustainable development” paradigm. Thus, the planetary boundaries framework offers a potentially vital path forward for ecological governance from global to local scales.
As the editors unpack in Chapter 1, the planetary boundaries are an influential framework initially proposed by Johan Rockström and related environmental science researchers in 2009. This framework posits that there are nine boundaries within the Earth system required to maintain a “safe operating space for humanity,” the crossing of which results in “‘dangerous levels’ or, where applicable, ‘tipping points’ in Earth system processes” crucial for human existence. The nine planetary boundaries as articulated in 2009 include climate change, biodiversity loss rate, nitrogen and phosphorus cycles interference, use of global freshwater, land use change, acidification of oceans, chemical pollution, stratospheric ozone depletion, and atmospheric aerosol loading. The researchers estimated that three of the boundaries (climate change, biodiversity loss, and nitrogen cycles interference) already had been crossed. Moreover, a follow-up 2015 study estimated that a fourth boundary had been crossed (land system change), and these researchers otherwise further tailored and updated the planetary boundaries framework.
The editors assert that the central thrust of the handbook is to work towards “translat[ing] the significance and consequences of the planetary boundaries framework into the human dimensions or social world of the Earth system,” and that “in this book we focus on law, and more specifically the legal aspects of planetary boundaries governance.” The editors add that one primary motivation of the book is that “law by its very nature is remarkably good at setting boundaries and limiting human behavior, and it could therefore be used, alongside a range of other social regulatory interventions, to ensure humanity does not cross the planetary boundaries.” The handbook focuses primarily although not exclusively on international environmental law in its explorations.
The handbook is divided into three major parts. Part I covers the Legal, Ethical and Governance Dimensions of the Planetary Boundaries. Chapters in this Part cover such topics as the influence, to date, of the boundaries framework within governance regimes, the incorporation of the framework within the social sciences, a critical evaluation of the ethics underpinning the framework, and localized explorations of the framework in cities and urban contexts. Next, Part II covers International Law and the Planetary Boundaries. Chapters in this Part explore how different international law regimes must account for the intertwined reality of the boundaries within the Earth system, questions of equity and causation within the framework, and issues of compliance with the framework as potentially incorporated into treaties or customary law.
Lastly, Part III of the handbook covers Planetary Boundaries and the Law. Chapters in this Part provide a more granular analysis of current legal regimes intersecting with planetary boundaries, including nature conservation legislation and the emerging rights of nature (relating to the boundary for biodiversity loss and extinctions), the Paris Agreement on Climate Change (relating to the boundary for climate change), the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer (relating to the boundary for stratospheric ozone depletion), and the European Union regulation for the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (relating to the boundary for chemical pollution).
Much of the handbook's especially innovative work directly engages with the potential of the planetary boundaries framework to radically reshape global environmental governance. One important example, Chapter 4, titled Planetary Boundaries, Planetary Ethics and Climate Justice in the Anthropocene, contends that a “fundamental paradigm shift” beyond international environmental law is required that challenges “western ideas of development based upon the ceaseless exploitation of nature.” Such a paradigm shift may be implicated by the radical “ecocentric ethic” inherent in the 2010 Cochabamba People's Agreement “that corresponds to the existential, planetary nature of the climate emergency.” Through such transformative approaches, we collectively can “replace the current fragmented, polycentric environmental governance regime with one that is more responsive to the multiple challenges of the planetary boundaries framework.”
Another important example, Chapter 8, titled Changing Role of Law-Making in Responding to Planetary Boundaries?, similarly argues that we must overcome hegemonic western power structures, and that as one key mechanism, we may “draw upon understandings and world views which depart from the ‘norm’ of the liberal market economy,” such as the “understandings some indigenous peoples have the world.” Such transformative approaches often radically “focus on responsibilities” of states and non-state actors as compared to traditional and exceedingly limited rights-based western regimes.
Research Handbook on Law, Governance and Planetary Boundaries ultimately is of immense value to researchers, students, and scholar-activists. As the editors correctly conclude, “the planetary boundaries have highlighted the ecological reality in which we can—if we so wish—craft our desired human society,” and that, in dire contrast, “[t]ransgressing those boundaries will create untold and planetary-level perturbations which will ‘destabilize the [Earth system] at the planetary scale.’” Thus, the handbook has the potential to ably contribute to further research and to concretely inform practice and praxis regarding law, the global ecological crisis, and transformative socio-legal change, which indeed illustrates its nature as a groundbreaking, much-needed collection.
