Between 1884 and 1888, a vigilante band known as the Bald Knobbers rose to prominence in the Ozark counties of Taney, Christian, and Douglas, all located in the southwest corner of Missouri. Claiming to represent the good, sturdy, tax-paying, and law-abiding folks, the original group—in Taney County—lynched two young white men in Forsyth and then initiated a campaign against the so-called criminal element that targeted principally lower-status white people. The Bald Knobbers spread north into Christian and Douglas and executed two more men in 1887. The vigilantes, numbering some nine hundred at the height of the movement, provoked the formation of an Anti-Bald Knobber faction that soon bred more violence and ultimately provoked intervention of the governor and his administration. Ultimately, the authorities in Christian County prosecuted several of the Bald Knobbers involved in one of the killings and sentenced four to die. One escaped but the other three prisoners died on the scaffold in 1889.
In Faces Like Devils, historian Matthew J. Hernando examines the famed Bald Knobbers and their sensational killings and other acts of intimidation. He acknowledges that local historians have addressed these vigilantes but charges that professional historians have not given them sufficient consideration. With this study he claims two interventions. First, he places the Bald Knobber violence into the larger context of the Civil War and Reconstruction periods, creating a “legacy of bitterness and mistrust” (15) that would define the Ozarks—indeed, define much of Missouri—for decades to come. Second, he differentiates between the original Bald Knobbers in Taney County and the upstarts in Christian and Douglas, arguing that the former consisted primarily of more well-to-do and supposedly respectable people and the latter attracted poorer white members.
Hernando is a good writer and storyteller and, while much of it focuses closely on local contexts, Faces Like Devils is a lively and engaging book that merits attention from those scholars focusing on vigilante and Ozark history. Furthermore, he delves deeply into local archival sources, producing an extraordinary portrait of the people, economy, and culture of the Missouri Ozarks. He utilizes numerous maps, tables, and photographs that enhance the book and contribute to its readability. He provides several important insights that augment the ever-expanding scholarship on the guerrilla violence that defined the Civil War and its aftermath in Missouri. Although some scholars have argued that postwar animosities lined up closely with those of the war period itself, Hernando shows that the military conflict certainly hardened many of those who later became involved in the Bald Knobber conflict, but it did not necessarily influence which side they took. “Civil War loyalties do not, by themselves, explain the conflict between the two groups,” he writes. “Nine of the Bald Knobber veterans and four of the Anti-Bald Knobber veterans served in Missouri units, meaning that they witnessed and participated in some of the cruelest and ugliest fighting in the war. As a result, they had little reason to feel sympathy or show compassion for people on the other side” (94).
The book does have several limitations that may impair its utility for precisely those professional historians that the book seeks to reach. First, the author relies on an older historiography, including the influential work of Richard Maxwell Brown in Strain of Violence from the 1970s, but does not engage newer scholarship that could offer so much to his analysis—and which his analysis, in turn, could advance: works by Lisa Arellano, W. Fitzhugh Brundage, William Carrigan, or Michael J. Pfeifer, for instance, are nowhere to be found. The author's heavy reliance on Brown's work means that he largely internalizes its problematic assumption that lynch mobs headed by men of property and influence were somehow good and justified in their actions while those headed by working-class whites were somehow no good and lawless. Second, the author bypasses almost entirely any discussion of race in the book; one infers that his subjects are white because he does not say otherwise. In the wake of decades of whiteness studies, the fact of white mobs murdering fellow whites to enforce class, gender, or other hierarchies demands at least some reasonably sophisticated discussion of race and class. In a related point, the author fails to tie the Bald Knobber violence of the 1880s to the infamous outbreak of anti-black mob violence and expulsions that tore across that area of the Ozarks, followed by the banning of further black settlers, an outbreak discussed at length in Kimberly Harper's White Man's Heaven.Footnote 1 While these outbreaks had different victims and pursued different objectives, Hernando could have elevated the significance of his research by placing these historiographies into conversation, by identifying the continuities and discontinuities among them, and speculating on their significance. Despite these limitations, however, Hernando has produced a useful study that will be of value to scholars of mob violence and Missouri history.
