Each year, PS editorial staff provides a report of activities to the APSA Publications Committee and the APSA Council, and usually we report on a few items in that report to our readers. Below we offer highlights and a summary of the results of the 2012 PS Reader Survey. In addition, because articles in PS are peer-reviewed, we take this opportunity to acknowledge the work of the reviewers who offered their time and service to PS and the profession. Their names and affiliations are listed at the end of this report.
Mission and Editorial Statement
PS: Political Science & Politics features timely, peer-reviewed articles on contemporary politics written for the informed, general reader, and commentary and debate on major issues in the political science profession. Incorporated into PS is “The Teacher,” a dedicated forum for teaching providing resources for college faculty, high school teachers, and students. PS, founded in 1968, also serves as the association's journal of record.
Submission Guidelines
Each year PS receives more than 100 manuscripts for consideration. To help authors and reviewers, we have refined the editorial guidelines to provide potential PS authors with better information regarding length. We now recommend articles not exceed 3,650 words, including references and notes, tables and figures rather than 15-page limit, and specific guidelines for submitting manuscripts through the Editorial Manager system. We hope these revised guidelines, shared with the PS Editorial Board and the APSA Publications Committee and Council, will result in a smoother submission process and appropriate, timely, well-written, concise articles for our readers, both those in the discipline and other general readers.
PR Reader Survey
In October 2012 the PS editor reported to the APSA Council the results from the 2012 PS Reader Survey, completed in the summer of 2012. These results were also shared with the PS Editorial Board at is 2012 meeting (held in April 2013 due to cancellation of the board meeting in August 2012). Key findings include:
-
• Nearly two thirds (65%) of all respondents are satisfied (very, somewhat) with the journal.
-
• Most readers of PS read the journal in print only; readers with the greatest satisfaction with the journal read it in both print and electronic format. These results suggest that it would be premature to recast PS as an electronic only journal.
-
• Most readers do not share the journal (33%), and few forward their electronic copies of the journal to others (12%). Again, this latter finding suggests that electronic versions of the journal are not used in a way that we might expect.
-
• Many readers regularly read the several sections of PS, and most read them at least on occasion.
-
• Readers are satisfied with the quality of all the sections of PS. There is less in the professional sections of the journal to generate dissatisfaction, which is to be expected.
-
• As with professional journals generally, most readers are using the journal for professional development, but also for staying abreast of work in their area of research.
-
• Non-readers generally report having no opinion (48%) about PS or being neither satisfied nor dissatisfied (22%) with the journal; fewer than 10% report being very dissatisfied with the journal.
-
• Only one-fifth (20%) of respondents reported having submitted a manuscript to PS.
-
• A majority of PS submissions come from faculty, despite encouraging students and postdoc submissions.
-
• The vast majority of submitters had a positive experience in submitting manuscripts.
-
• Most respondents report never being asked to be a reviewer for PS.
-
• Notably, readers of PS read the other APSA journals—APSR (63%) and Perspectives on Politics (46%)—more often than other political science journals. AJPS (36%) and JOP (31%) are also popular among PS readers.
PS is committed to covering contemporary politics, advancing professional development, contributing to political science pedagogy, and, as the journal of record, keeping members informed of APSA's programs and activities.
Author Demographics
In the 2012–13 report, we reviewed the four most recent issues of PS: October 2012 (45.4), January 2013 (46.1), April 2013 (46.2), and July 2013 (46.3) to determine how well the 184 authors in PS reflect the rank, institutional, and gender demographics of APSA's membership. We reported that 32% of PS authors are full professors, 20% are associate professors, 21% are assistant professor, and 17% are students (mostly postdoctoral and other graduate, but a few, this year, were undergraduates who served as coauthors), and 10% are nonacademics. Regarding the distribution of PS authors by types of institutions 59% are based at public universities, 28% at private universities, 6% at colleges and nonacademic institutions (e.g., Congressional Research Service), and 1% are at other academic institutions.
There is a preponderance of PS authors from four-year PhD- and MA-granting institutions (87% public and private combined). This class of PS authors significantly exceeds their representation among APSA members (65.0%). Faculty members from four-year BA-granting institutions make up 18% of APSA members, but only 6% of PS authors. Although this type of faculty has historically been underrepresented in PS, this marks a decrease from 10% last year and certainly a decline from 2010 when they amounted to 14% of PS authors. We will continue to watch these percentages in the coming year.
The gender distribution of PS authors this year falls short of the gender distribution of APSA's total membership: 32.19% women and 66.46% are men (no code assigned to 1.34%) with 75% of the PS authors male and 25% female. The gender distribution in the past nearly mirrors the APSA gender distribution. Possible reason for this may be the underrepresentation of women in election forecasting, predominate in both the October and January issues. Of the 13 authors of the forecasts, only one author was female. It is not possible to determine if PS authors reflect the racial, ethnic, or sexual identities of the general membership.
Submission and Decision
Unsoliticited manuscripts in PS (in Features, The Profession, and The Teacher sections) have increased over the past several years (Tables 1 and 2). In both 2011 and 2012 PS witnessed an increase in the percentage of submissions in the teaching category, from 39% in 2011 to 45% in 2012. Table 3 reflects the growth in symposium/articles, and Table 4 reviews the acceptance rate of the journal.
New Submissions
Submissions by Category
Symposia Published. 2009–2012
Acceptance Rates 2009–2012
Most Downloaded Articles
The Cambridge Journals page provides monthly updates to the most downloaded article as well as most cited articles. Be sure to check out the Journal pages, via your MY APSA account, to view the most up to date information.
Reviewers
As noted in the PS Readers Survey, most of our readers have never been asked to review. We encourage you to contact us; at ps@apsanet.org , and we will help you update your information, alert the editor to your willingness to review, and involve you in this review process. If you have not reviewed before, read: “How To Be a Peer Reviewer: A Guide for Recent and Soon to be PhDs” by Beth Miller, John Pevehouse, Ron Rogowksi, Dustin Tingley, and Rick Wilson in PS 46 (1): 120–23. This article “includes why reviewing is important to the development of one's own scholarship but includes some nuts and bolts on reviewing.” See also the Cambridge University Journal page for author and peer reviewers, alike, for responsibilities of both authors and reviewers. Visit http://journals.cambridge.org/action/stream?pageId=6728&level=2
PS Reviewers 2012
In 2012, PS: Political Science and Politics published articles covering a vast range of topics. The journal's commitment to publishing articles on pedagogy and the profession, as well as exemplary topical scholarship on a spectrum of issues, call for an equally broad stable of reviewers. PS cannot publish such diverse work without the outstanding work (and open-mindedness) of our peer reviewers. The peer-review process relies on the professionalism and generosity of those who contribute their time and knowledge to read and evaluate the work of others. The editors of PS thank the following scholars who completed reviews for PS between January 1, 2012, and December 31, 2012:
Jennifer Abbassi, Randolph College
Paul Abramson, Michigan State University
Viviana Abreu-Hernandez, Research and Program Development
Yasmeen Abu-Laban, University of Alberta
Martha Ackelsberg, Smith College
Brian Adams, San Diego State University
William Adams, William Jewell College
Christopher Adolph, University of Washington
Joseph Aistrup, Kansas State University
Ayhan Akman, Sabanci University
Julia Albarracin, Western Illinois University
Jilda Aliotta, University of Hartford
Mahalley Allen, California State University, Chico
J. Theodore Anagnoson, California State University, Los Angeles
Josephine Andrews, University of California, Davis
Mark Anner, Pennsylvania State University
Phillip Ardoin. Appalachian State University
Peri Arnold, University of Notre Dame
Victor Asal, SUNY, University at Albany
James Avery, Richard Stockton College
Valentina Bali, Michigan State University
Elsie Barnes, Norfolk State University
Scott Basinger, University of Houston
Staci Beavers, California State University, San Marcos
Ann Beck, Murray State University
Lauren Bell, Randolph-Macon College
Elizabeth Bennion, Indiana University South Bend
Jeffrey Bernstein, Eastern Michigan University
Merike Blofield, University of Miami
Paul Brewer, University of Delaware
Hannah Britton, University of Kansas
Russell Brooker, Alverno College
Michelle Brophy-Baermann, Rhode Island College
Thomas Brunell, University of Texas, Dallas
Kevin Bruyneel, Babson College
Matthew Burbank, University of Utah
Miguel Centellas, University of Mississippi
Caleb Clark, Auburn University
Elizabeth Corley, Arizona State University
Michael Craw, University of Arkansas, Little Rock
Austin Crothers, Illinios State University
David Darmofal, University of South Carolina
Jeffrey Davis, University of Maryland, Baltimore
Janet Day, SUNY, University at Oneonta
Michelle Deardorff, Jackson State University
Mary Durfee, Michigan Technological University
Heather Evans, Sam Houston State University
Victoria Farrar-Myers, University of Texas, Arlington
Jasmine Farrier, University of Louisville
Kenneth Foster, Concordia College
Martial Foucault, University of Montreal
Brian Gaines, University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign
James Garand, Louisiana State University
J. Gillespie, College of Charleston
Johnny Goldfinger, Marian University Indianapolis
Jane Gordon, Temple University
Benjamin Gregg, University of Texas, Austin
Leon Halpert, Siena College
Charles Helm, Western Illinois University
Sunshine Hillygus, Duke University
Donna Hoffman, University of Northern Iowa
James Hutter, Iowa State University
John Ishiyama, University of North Texas
Stephen Jessee, University of Texas, Austin
Whitt Kilburn, Grand Valley State University
Brian Lai, University of Iowa
Edward Lascher, California State University, Sacramento
Howard Lehman, University of Utah
Tracy Lightcap, LaGrange College
Adam Luedtke, Richard Stockton College
Lindsey Lupo, Point Loma Nazarene University
Renee Marlin-Bennett, Johns Hopkins University
Seth Masket, University of Denver
Kenneth Mayer, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Allan McBride, University of Southern Mississippi
Kristine Mitchell, Dickinson College
Jack Nagel, University of Pennsylvania
Hans Noel, Georgetown University
Eric Novotny, US Agency for International Development
Manju Parikh, College of Saint Benedict and Saint John's University
Thomas Pepinsky, Cornell University
Andrew Perrin, University of North Carolina
Delia Popescu, LeMoyne College
John Rausch, West Texas A&M University
Joachim Rennstich, CJD Arnold-Dannenmann-Akademie
Joseph Roberts, Roger Williams University
Michael Rocca, University of New Mexico
Amanda Rosen, Webster University
Mark Sachleben, Shippensburg University
Mikael Sandberg, Halmstad University
Todd Sechser, University of Virginia
Mack Shelley, Iowa State University
Gordon Shockley, Arizona State University
Mark Souva, Florida State University
Katina Stapleton,
Jerold Waltman, Baylor University
M. Stephen Weatherford, University of California
Joseph Wert, Indiana University Southeast
Irene Wu, Federal Communications Commisssion
