The book under review is part of a resurgence of studies on eighteenth-century electricity. With the old heroic histories now firmly set aside, the lives and works of electric celebrities such as Alessandro Volta, Luigi Galvani and (thanks to this book) Benjamin Franklin have begun to emerge in relation to their contexts, local and international, and in relation to a constellation of other actors whose roles were no less crucial to the making of electrical knowledge. The familiar emphasis on rival theories has been replaced by an insistence on the practical applications of electricity – notably in medicine, physiology, public safety and meteorology – and on the various means by which electrical science was made meaningful.
James Delbourgo's cultural history of electricity in early America benefits considerably from its attention to the circulation of knowledge across the Atlantic. It provides a fresh analysis of Franklin's work while also offering a fascinating case study of the intellectual, natural-philosophical exchanges between the Old and the New Worlds. In line with recent scholarship questioning the centre–periphery approach to Enlightenment studies, Delbourgo illuminates the two-way trajectory that electrical science followed across the Atlantic. We see both how electrical wonders arrived in America as one of the cultural curiosities imported from the mother country, and how the work of the colonial Franklin had a tremendous impact on electricians working in Europe. Treading in the footsteps of their Old World counterparts, demonstrators such as Ebenezer Kinnersley created ‘amazing scenes of wonders’ that fuelled interest among the colonists in the new science. American parlour games with attractions, sparks and shocks were almost identical to those that thrilled conversazione in European salons and courts. In the span of a few decades, electricity translated into food and clothes for various colonial practitioners who, like their European counterparts, performed demonstrations, offered healing treatments, wrote treatises or traded instruments.
Here as in most recent works on the topic, the history of eighteenth-century electricity is a history of travel and circulation. One of the main strengths of A Most Amazing Scene of Wonders is that it unveils the relevance of the transatlantic trade in exotic specimens for prompting research on the nature of animal electricity. Physiological inquiries into the nature of the electric organs of fish such as the ray and the Gymnotus stood at the basis of the Galvani–Volta controversy in the 1790s and of the invention of the Voltaic battery in 1800, as Giuliano Pancaldi, Marco Bresadola and Marco Piccolino have demonstrated (correcting the narrow perspective offered by Marcello Pera's Ambiguous Frog (Princeton, 1992), which seems nonetheless to remain the favourite source for anglophone historians). This now well-known story is enriched by Delbourgo's study of the colonial history of the electric eel, which was brought to Europeans' attention by the Massachusetts physician Edward Bancroft, a friend of Franklin's and the secretary of the American delegation in Paris, later to become a British spy.
Delbourgo convincingly shows how, after travelling across the Atlantic, electricity became entangled with local dynamics. Colonial enthusiasm for electrical wonders, as well as sensitivity to the language of economy and common sense, provided the context for the emergence and acceptance of Franklin's work. His explanation of the electric nature of lightning, and his advocacy of metallic conductors as a means of protecting people and buildings from its dire effects, merged with political and theological concerns. In the age of revolution, the convulsive power of electricity provided a new language for the supporters of republican virtues while offering a new repertoire for loyalists' satire. At the same time, the aspiration to master such a powerful natural element mingled with discussions on the relationship between natural laws and divine agency. The tension between the attempt to acquire a rational mastery of nature and the sense of disorientation caused by potentially disruptive, unpredictable natural phenomena stood at the core of Enlightenment electrical science, not only in North America. Franklin himself suggested that, in addition to lightning, earthquakes and volcanic eruptions too could be explained according to the motion of the electric fire – a view that proved tremendously influential in Europe.
Lightning protection, electrotherapy and other useful applications of electricity were much discussed in eighteenth-century electrical works, which thereby tuned electrical science to the utilitarian refrain of the Enlightenment. There were, too, many ‘men on the margins’, in the European countries as well as in North America, who lived off these potentially useful, if almost always controversial, applications. However, local dynamics proved essential in the making of the careers of such figures, as this book convincingly shows. Its final chapters deal with two cases in particular – the millenarian Dr Gale and the anti-intellectual Elisha Perkins. Here Delbourgo sets the ground for his concluding discussion on the distinctive features of the American Enlightenment, as they emerge from electrical history and in their relationship with revolutionary politics and anti-intellectualism.
