Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T02:17:18.723Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

On mixing enhancement by secondary baroclinic vorticity in a shock–bubble interaction

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 November 2021

Hong Liu*
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Bin Yu*
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Bin Zhang
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Yang Xiang
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: hongliu@sjtu.edu.cn, kianyu@sjtu.edu.cn
†Email addresses for correspondence: hongliu@sjtu.edu.cn, kianyu@sjtu.edu.cn

Abstract

To investigate the intrinsic mechanism for mixing enhancement by variable-density (VD) behaviour, a canonical VD mixing extracted from a supersonic streamwise vortex protocol, a shock–bubble interaction (SBI), is numerically studied and compared with a counterpart of passive-scalar (PS) mixing. It is meaningful to observe that the maximum concentration decays much faster in a VD SBI than in a PS SBI regardless of the shock Mach number ($Ma=1.22 - 4$). The quasi-Lamb–Oseen-type velocity distribution in the PS SBI is found by analysing the azimuthal velocity that stretches the bubble. Meanwhile, for the VD SBI, an additional stretching enhanced by the secondary baroclinic vorticity (SBV) production contributes to the faster-mixing decay. The underlying mechanism of the SBV-enhanced stretching is further revealed through the density and velocity difference between the light shocked bubble and the heavy ambient air. By combining the SBV-accelerated stretching model and the initial shock compression, a novel mixing time estimation for VD SBI is theoretically proposed by solving the advection–diffusion equation under a deformation field of an axisymmetric vortex with the additional SBV-induced azimuthal velocity. Based on the mixing time model, a mixing enhancement number, defined by the ratio of VD and PS mixing time further, reveals the contribution from the VD effect, which implies a better control of the density distribution for mixing enhancement in a supersonic streamwise vortex.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.The mixing behaviour of shock-accelerated flows from different studies under different dimensionless times.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic of the initial conditions for SBI.

Figure 2

Table 2.Parameters for different shock Mach number cases, including post-shock pressure $p_1'$, post-shock temperature $T_1'$ and the transmitted shock wave speed $W_t$, calculated from 1-D gas dynamics. Post-shock Atwood number ${At}^+=(\rho _2'-\rho _1')/(\rho _2'+\rho _1')$ is obtained from the post-shock air density $\rho _1'$ and post-shock helium density $\rho _2'$.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Initial conditions for PS SBI shown by (a) isolines of mass fraction, (b) pressure contour and (c) density contour at $t=7.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s of the $Ma=2.4$ case.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Comparison of circulation (a) and compression rate (b) for PS (solid points) and VD SBI (hollow points) for different shock Mach number cases.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Density contour (top) and vorticity contour (bottom) for the $Ma=2.4$ VD SBI case at (a) $t=7.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (b) $t=13.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (c) $t=27.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (d) $t=42$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (e) $t=69.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s. The $Ma=2.4$ PS SBI case is presented at the same moments as that of VD SBI in the bottom line from (f) to (j). Dash–dot line is the isoline of $Y_{He}=1\,\%Y_{max}^0$ ($Y_{max}^0=1$ for VD SBI and $Y_{max}^0=0.0001$ for PS SBI). TP, triple point; AJ, air jet; TS, transmitted shock; MV, main vortex; RS, reflected shock; MS, Mach stem; Br, bridge; SBV, secondary baroclinic vorticity; VM, vorticity merging; TB, trailing bubble; SS, slip stream; SV1 and SV2, secondary vortex 1 and secondary vortex 2.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Normalised mass fraction (top) and scalar dissipation rate (bottom) for the $Ma=2.4$ VD SBI case from (a) to (e). The $Ma=2.4$ PS SBI case is presented in the bottom line from (f) to (j). The moments captured are the same as those of figure 4.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Time history of scalar dissipation rate $\chi$ (3.4) and maximum normalised mass fraction $\bar {Y}$ (3.5), for (a) $Ma=2.4$; (b) $Ma=1.22$; (c) $Ma=1.8$; (d) $Ma=3$; (e) $Ma=4$. For all figures, hollow points represent the VD case and solid points represent the PS case. Green dashed lines show the mixing time when $\bar {Y}=0.97$ is reached. Five blue circles in panel (a) indicate the five different moments in figures 4 and 5. Three blue circles presented separately in panels (b) to (e) indicate the three different moments for each Mach number in figure 30 of Appendix D.

Figure 8

Table 3.Mixing time $t_{\mathfrak {m}}$ of the VD and PS cases when $\bar {Y}=0.97$ is reached. Data are measured from figure 6.

Figure 9

Figure 7.The PS SBI for $Ma=2.4$. (a) Azimuthal velocity contour in the frame of the vortex centre at $t=13.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a1), $t=27.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a2), $t=42$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a3) and $t=69.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a4). Isoline of scalar dissipation rate is plotted as a blue line. (b) Motion of vortex centre with time. (c) Azimuthal velocity distribution along dashed lines in panels (a1)–(a4). Velocity distribution of a Lamb–Oseen-type vortex (4.2) is plotted as a dashed line, obtained from the best curve fit of descending data for Line 2.

Figure 10

Figure 8.(a) Time history of scalar dissipation rate for PS SBI with different shock Mach number. (b) Isoline of cylindrical bubble boundary at initial time to show the compression effect on initial mixing region $\mathcal {V}_b=\eta \mathcal {V}_0\approx \eta {\rm \pi}R^2$ and (c) final mixing region of PS SBI for different shock Mach number. Red, $Ma=1.22$; orange, $Ma=1.8$; blue, $Ma=2.4$; black, $Ma=3$; green, $Ma=4$.

Figure 11

Figure 9.VD SBI for $Ma=2.4$. (a) Azimuthal velocity contour in the frame of the vortex centre at $t=13.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a1), $t=27.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a2), $t=42$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a3) and $t=69.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s (a4). (b) Motion of the vortex centre with time. (c) Azimuthal velocity distribution along the defined lines captured from panels (a1) to (a4) compared with azimuthal velocity distribution at the same time obtained from figure 7. An increase of azimuthal velocity in the VD case is obvious for each comparison.

Figure 12

Figure 10.(a) Synchronous growth of opposite sign vorticity and scalar dissipation for $Ma=2.4$ VD SBI. (b) Isolines of vorticity (top) and contour of scalar dissipation (bottom) at instants near $t_{b}=13.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s: (b1) $11.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (b2) $13.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; (b3) $15.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s.

Figure 13

Figure 11.(a) Dimensionless positive, negative and total circulation in different Mach number cases. (b) The synchronous growth of scalar dissipation and the secondary baroclinic circulation in different Mach number cases. The maximum azimuthal velocity $V_\theta ^{max}$ normalised by post-shock velocity $u_1'$ is also plotted.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Illustration of the SBV production at the bridge structure by a velocity difference model abstracted from the shocked light gas cylindrical bubble and shocked heavy ambient air.

Figure 15

Figure 13.(a) Vorticity contour for different Mach number VD SBI cases at $t=t_b$, namely, $Ma=1.22$, $t_b=58$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; $Ma=1.8$, $t_b=19.2$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; $Ma=3$, $t_b=11$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s; $Ma=4$, $t_b=8$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s. Coordinate $r$ with origin at the vortex centre pointing to the location of maximum azimuthal velocity $V_\theta ^{max}$ is built for each case. (b) Vorticity profile along axis $r$ built in panel (a) for each case. Profile for the $Ma=2.4$ case is extracted as the data from VD Line 1 in figure 9(c) and vorticity contour in figure 10(b2). (c) SBV circulation $|\varGamma ^-/\varGamma |$ for different shock Mach numbers versus the scaled time $\Delta Ut/D$.

Figure 16

Table 4.One-dimensional gas dynamics is used to provide $\Delta {U}=u'_2-u'_1$. Here, $t_{b}$ is the time at the first maximum of baroclinic circulation growth referring to figure 12; $k\equiv (\omega _bD^2)/\varGamma _b$, where $\omega _b$ is obtained from (4.17) at $t=t_b$; $\varGamma _b/\varGamma$ is the peak value of $|\varGamma ^-/\varGamma |$ from figure 13(c); and $\omega _{b,p}$ is the peak negative vorticity measured from figure 13(b).

Figure 17

Figure 14.Azimuthal velocity distribution in the frame of a vortex centre for different shock Mach numbers for VD SBI [shown as panels (a2) to (d2)] by comparing with results for PS SBI [shown as panels (a1) to (d1)]. The moments captured and coordinate $r$ are the same as those in figure 13(a).

Figure 18

Figure 15.(a) Azimuthal velocity distribution along the axis $r$ in figure 14 for VD SBI with different shock Mach numbers. (b) The comparison between $\partial \tilde {V}_{\theta }/\partial r$ and vorticity distribution along the axis $r$ in figure 13(b). (c) Azimuthal velocity normalised by the modelled value (4.23) along the normalised axis $r/r_m$. (d) Normalised vorticity $\omega D^2/\varGamma _b$ along the normalised axis $r/r_m$.

Figure 19

Table 5.Validation of the baroclinic velocity increase model (4.23). Here, $V_\theta =\varGamma /2{\rm \pi} r _m$, where $r_m$ is the radius from vortex centre to the location of maximum azimuthal velocity $\tilde {V}_{\theta }$, measured from figure 15(a).

Figure 20

Figure 16.(a) Compression effect on initial mixing region; (b) stretching of PS blob under the standard point vortex (Meunier & Villermaux 2003); (c) SBV-enhanced stretching in VD mixing.

Figure 21

Figure 17.(a) Maximum concentration decay and (b) scalar dissipation for PS SBI versus scaled time $t/t_{m}$, where $t_m$ is expressed in (5.1).

Figure 22

Figure 18.(a) Maximum concentration decay and (b) scalar dissipation for PS SBI versus scaled time $t/t^*_{m}$. By considering compression effects from the shock on the initial mixing region, the mixing time can be correctly predicted at a time scale of $t/t^*_{m}\approx 1$, where $t^*_m$ is expressed in (5.3).

Figure 23

Table 6.Comparison between theoretical mixing time from (5.1), (5.3) and measured value referring to table 3. The circulation $\varGamma$, diffusivity coefficient $\bar {\kappa }$ (see Appendix C) and compression rate $\eta$ are also listed.

Figure 24

Figure 19.(a) Maximum concentration decay and (b) scalar dissipation for the VD SBI versus scaled time $t/t_{m}$. Under the scaling of mixing time $t_{m}$ (5.1), the VD SBI cases show large discrepancy for different shock Mach number cases.

Figure 25

Figure 20.(a) Maximum concentration decay and (b) scalar dissipation for the VD SBI versus scaled time $t/\tilde {t}_{m}$. Mixing time $\tilde {t}_{m}$ (5.21), considering only baroclinic-enhanced stretching, fails to predict the correct scaling.

Figure 26

Table 7.Comparison between theoretical mixing time of $t_m$ (5.1), $t_m^*$ (5.3), $\tilde {t}_m$ (5.21), $\tilde {t}_m^*$ (5.22) and measured value $t_{\mathfrak {m}}^{VD}$ referring to table 3. Diffusivity coefficient $\bar {\kappa }$ (see Appendix C) is also listed.

Figure 27

Figure 21.(a) Maximum concentration decay and (b) scalar dissipation for the VD SBI versus scaled time $t/\tilde {t}^*_{m}$. By combining the baroclinic-enhanced stretching model and compression effect, satisfactory prediction of mixing time $\tilde {t}^*_{m}$ (5.22) can be found for the VD SBI in general. When $t/\tilde {t}_m^*>1$, the maximum mass fraction begins to decrease rapidly and scalar dissipation enters the diffusion stage with low-level mixing.

Figure 28

Figure 22.Scaling of mixing time for the PS SBI and VD SBI under three dimensionless controlling parameters. (a) Dependence of $\bar {t}$ (5.23) on $Pe$ number. (b) Dependence of $\bar {t}$ (5.24) on compression rate $\eta$. (c) Dependence of $\bar {t}$ (5.25) on $1+3/2|{At}^+|$.

Figure 29

Figure 23.Mach number scaling for mixing time for the VD and PS SBI obtained from table 3.

Figure 30

Table 8.Mixing enhancement number of the measured value obtained from table 3 and from (6.6). The relative errors $\varepsilon$ between modelled value and those measured for different cases are offered in the last row.

Figure 31

Figure 24.(a) Grid dependence study on the helium mass fraction contour at $t=65.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s. From left to right: mesh-1, $\varDelta =8\times 10^{-5}$ m; mesh-2, $\varDelta =4\times 10^{-5}$ m; mesh-3, $\varDelta =2.5\times 10^{-5}$ m; mesh-4, $\varDelta =1\times 10^{-5}$ m. Circulation (b) and maximum concentration (c) of different mesh resolutions.

Figure 32

Figure 25.The results of density profile for (a) Sod's shock tube at $t=0.2$ and (b) one-dimensional shock–slab interaction at $t=0.3$ with different order WENO schemes. Different schemes on a 480-point gird compared with the reference solutions obtained with the WENO 3 scheme on a high-resolution 4800-point grid.

Figure 33

Figure 26.Comparison of density (top) and scalar dissipation (bottom) at $t=16.8$ (144 $\mathrm {\mu }$s) in the $Ma=1.22$ VD SBI simulated by (a) ParNS, (b) the third-order WENO, (c) the fifth-order WENO, (d) the seventh-order WENO and (e) the ninth-order WENO.

Figure 34

Figure 27.(a) Time history of total circulation and compression rate between different schemes. (b) Time history of scalar dissipation and maximum mass fraction between different schemes.

Figure 35

Figure 28.Dynamic viscosity (1 top), diffusivity with scalar dissipation rate isolines (1 bottom), normalised mass fraction (2 top) and vorticity (2 bottom) for the original PS SBI with $\mu ^{ps}_{origin}$ (a) and viscosity elevated PS SBI with $\mu ^{ps}$ (b) at $t=153.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s and $Ma=1.22$.

Figure 36

Figure 29.Effective diffusivity coefficient $\kappa (t)$ in the PS cases (a) and VD cases (b) for different shock Mach numbers. Note that the effective diffusivity coefficients of the original viscosity without elevation, $\kappa _{origin}$, for the PS SBI are also compared in panel (a).

Figure 37

Figure 30.Scalar dissipation rate with red isoline of $Y_{He}=95\,\%Y_{max}^0$ (top) and vorticity with blue isoline of $Y_{He}=5\,\%Y_{max}^0$ (bottom) for (a) $Ma=1.22$; (b) $Ma=1.8$; (c) $Ma=3$; (d) $Ma=4$. For each Mach number, 1–3 indicate VD SBI and 4–6 indicate PS SBI at three identical moments marked as three blue circles in figure 6. Specifically, $t=58$, 96, 176 $\mathrm {\mu }$s for $Ma=1.22$; $t=19.2$, 43.2, 59.2 $\mathrm {\mu }$s for $Ma=1.8$; $t=11$, 19.8, 26.4 $\mathrm {\mu }$s for $Ma=3$; $t=8$, 20, 27.2 $\mathrm {\mu }$s for $Ma=4$.

Figure 38

Figure 31.Temporal evolution of scalar dissipation and its time derivative compared with the source term in (D2) for the $Ma=1.22$ PS SBI (a) and VD SBI (b).

Figure 39

Figure 32.Time history of vortex centre position to obtain vortical translational velocity for (a) $Ma=1.22$, (b) $Ma=1.8$, (c) $Ma=3$ and (d) $Ma=4$. Linear fit are plotted as solid lines for both the VD (black) and PS cases (red).

Figure 40

Figure 33.Post-shock density distribution and its spatial derivative at the bridge structure for (a) $Ma=1.22$; (b) $Ma=2.4$ and (c) $Ma=4$. The extracted lines for each case are indicated through the inserted density contour. Specifically, the pre-shock density distribution and its spatial derivative are plotted in panel (a) for comparison.

Figure 41

Table 9.Validation of (4.12) by comparing with the measured value $(\mathrm {d}\rho /\mathrm {d}r)_m$ from figure 33. Here, $\delta '=\sqrt {\eta }\delta$ is the thickness of the post-shock density transition layer near the bridge structure; and $\Delta \rho '=\rho _1'-\rho _2'$ is the density difference between post-shock air $\rho _1'$ and post-shock helium $\rho _2'$. Ratios between measured value and model value are listed in the last column. For comparison, the last row shows the pre-shock data with compression rate $\eta =1$.

Figure 42

Figure 34.(a) Spiral-type PS mixing of an initial square-shape dye under a deformation field of a Lamb–Oseen vortex. (b) Decay of maximum dye concentration from present simulation, experiment (Meunier & Villermaux 2003) and theoretical mixing time model (G5).

Figure 43

Figure 35.(a) The azimuthal velocity vector (4.1) and the vorticity contour of the $Ma=1.22$ PS SBI at $t=297.6$ $\mathrm {\mu }$s. (b) Nominal core size of the vortex pattern in the $Ma=1.22$ PS SBI measured by a least-square fit of the transformed maximum azimuthal velocity field and compared with (G8) (solid line).

Figure 44

Figure 36.Comparisons of three kinds of PS mixing temporal evolution. The first and second rows are PS mixing under a standard Lamb–Oseen vortex compared with mixing of the $Ma=1.22$ PS SBI. Note that the first kind is in accordance to the assumption in figure 16(a).

Figure 45

Figure 37.Decay of maximum mass fraction from three kinds of PS mixing in figure 36. Theoretical mixing model (G5) with $r^*$ and $s_0^*$ is plotted for comparison.