As those of us in universities play our parts in such curious rituals as lecturing, examining, graduating, drawing up reading lists, responding to initiatives from on high, interviewing and making appointments, sitting on faculty boards and senates, and writing references for colleagues facing promotion or tenure committees – and all this while publishing or perishing – we must, if we are historians, wonder how and where it all began. The usual short answer is: Germany around 1800. What William Clark has done in this book is to enrich this answer by revealing how, during an earlier period, universities evolved. It turns out that the familiar rites – and even things like research assessment and teaching-quality assurance that seem to us abominable novelties – have long histories. Our predecessors spent or wasted their time not so very differently from us.
Clark's focus is upon Germany, with ‘charismatic’ professors from the medieval period, but as a comparison he has something to say about Oxbridge, with its ‘traditional’ colleges, and about ‘rational’ Jesuit institutions. In each model, authority was derived somewhat differently; there is not a simple straight-line evolutionary development. Clark begins with a look at academic costumes and pecking orders in the early days of universities, at lecture catalogues, and at the way disputations were advertised and run. He moves on to ranking and degrees (especially the slow emergence of the Ph.D.), and then to questionnaires and the bureaucratic ordering and tabulation of data, and to library catalogues, where we can see how gifts of books from professors were gradually supplemented by purchases, attempts to achieve systematic listing gave way to alphabetic author order, and closed stacks began to be used to cope with larger holdings. Review journals were launched, guiding librarians and private purchasers in choosing books.
From the start, Clark sees ministries and markets as crucial in this history, as nepotism and patronage give place fitfully to meritocracy, to be measured somehow – here, the Jesuits were the leaders. He follows new subjects, first usually taught privately by professors or untenured teachers who might thereby acquire the reputation (fame and applause) for which ministers began to look when making appointments. The Reformation is important in his story, but the Thirty Years War hardly features. Gradually, and especially in Protestant lands, publications became important indicators of esteem, and scholarship rather than piety and orthodoxy came to be seen as desirable. Ministries began to budget not only for salaries, but for library purchases – notably at the new university set up in the little town of Göttingen in eighteenth-century Hanover, which soon became a model, though not universally admired. Because Germany was a mass of states, competing among other things for students and academic prestige, universities were studied and reported upon by visitors, formal or informal, from other states, in a process rather like contemporary industrial espionage.
Through all this, Clark sees ongoing academic babble – in general deeply conservative – increasingly disregarded by ministers who took confidential advice from respected individuals rather than accepting faculty nominations when making appointments, or formally consulting when determining policy. They built up still-surviving dossiers of various kinds on candidates. Going to university to learn what one's father had learned, so that one could step into his shoes, had been the norm. But even before 1800 research, novelty and originality were coming to be valued, as the idea of a university where old and young were learning gained ground. Clark ends with Lorenz Oken, his problems in getting a job and his founding in 1822 of the Association of German Naturalists and Physicians, which was the model for the BAAS, AAAS and other peripatetic bodies which inaugurated the world of academic conferences. By then, the University of Berlin was the model for others in Germany, and ultimately in France, Britain and the USA – though full acceptance of the research ethic sometimes took a very long time indeed.
Clark wants to deal with our unconsciousness of how the academic world has come into being, and his close study of university administration provides us with both an overview and vivid snapshots of institutions (with their ups and downs) and individuals across the changing centuries. He is entertaining about pedantry, but does not wear his own learning lightly – it is possible to be academic and amusing, but Clark's book is too laboured, and has too many digressions, and would have been much improved by compression. Long books are not more important or influential than short ones. Knowing what to leave out is an important academic gift. Here it would have made the work much more accessible, as it deserves to be, for Clark fascinatingly opens up a world hitherto overlooked, using neglected sources, complementing studies on students (notably A. J. La Vopa's Grace, Talent and Merit: Poor Students, Clerical Careers and Professional Ideology in Eighteenth-Century Germany, Cambridge, 1988), and casting much light on what people studied, how they got jobs, and how their activities were justified and supervised in the period before the research university – in which most of us academics now live and work – came explicitly into being.
