This is not just a review essay, but an intervention. We are living at a time in which all identities based on color—and that includes whiteness—are being reconsidered in unexpected ways. Barack Obama's successful political career seems to indicate that in the United States racism is receding, but at the level of our everyday lives pigmentation-based inequality is still quite palpable and tragically dominant; this juncture at which an alleged postracial condition shares the national stage with the ongoing, blatant discrimination of darker skins is a new historical formation that deserves—and demands—to be understood, appreciated, and critiqued on its own terms. Furthermore, the first black president is both a self-declared African-American male—and a mulatto. While Obama's mixed heritage is considered broadly to be an example of how Americans can slowly erode their racist past by dismantling the walls of segregation, some critics feel that emphasizing his interracial genealogy may serve only to underline the fact that he is not exactly—or even mainly—just black. Is the affirmation of brown or mulatto positionalities a move that enforces the hegemony of whiteness by decreasing the visibility of blackness? Jared SextonFootnote 1 and Tavia Nyong'o,Footnote 2 among others, have called attention to how a recourse to multiracial narratives as models of social progress may either elide or overlook the violent sources of American hybridity in the slave trade, and Frank B. Wilderson IIIFootnote 3 argues that a society that exists as a result of the social death of the slave will never be able to obliterate the traces of such a traumatic foundation.
Multiracialism can have, then, a disempowering effect that jeopardizes the autonomy, resilience, and validity of an exclusively black identity. This observation is not new: in 1996 August Wilson famously confronted the legacy of Usonian (U.S.–American) multiculturalism during an event sponsored by the Theatre Communications Group. During his speech, Wilson deliberately embraced a double standard: African American audiences, playwrights, and actors, he suggested, needed to foster ethnocentric theatrical spaces while still seeking to become fully integrated into the national cultural fabric.Footnote 4 Wilson's call for a political aesthetics of emphasized differences—as opposed to color-blind neutralizations—remains controversial, especially in view of recent, Obama-era claims that the United States is moving into a so-called nonracial futurity. His intervention also, however, remains timely: it reminds the theatre community that racial equality cannot be afforded at the cost of forgetting the specific histories that explain how our identities have been molded, modified, and preserved. Wilson's ideas motivated a highly publicized debate with Robert Brustein, the director of the American Repertory Theatre in Boston.Footnote 5 In Brustein's view, an extreme investment in racial politics compromises the universal appeal of art; an American theatre should be accessible to all American audiences alike. Brustein thus defended a multicultural and inclusive posture against Wilson's demand for strategic segregation.
In my opinion, the kernel of Wilson's argument is that it is imperative to stop privileging a view of race based on relations between black and white in order to explore the nuances of black life within black communities. (Multiracial subjects are not necessarily excluded from this exploration, but they are not hailed as the ideal solution to racism, either.) Wilson's goal was not to move us beyond race (or, indeed, back to it) but to welcome racial difference as something valuable by and in itself. The following, panoramic review essay spotlights three recent scholarly texts that, through a variety of methodologies and archival records, manage to document the extent to which the concept of race is now, and has historically been, both restrictive and necessary. Just as crucially, these books pay special attention to the within of racial constructs, the internal diversity of the African American self. Reading them, I came to the realization that a post-Obama America should not become a land free of race, but—if we work hard enough—may yet be a land in which race can be lived more freely.
According to editor Harvey Young, The Cambridge Companion to African American Theatre “centers the struggle to create a uniquely African American theatre” by focusing on the work of “those individuals whose efforts helped to fashion a more accurate appearance of black life on stage” (3, 5). After himself recalling Wilson's 1996 speech, Young states that his primary goal is to describe how African American artists have historically fought to gain control over the ways in which they are represented onstage and in performance. His anthology is qualified as a whole by a desire to privilege African American theatre companies and social organizations and by a commitment to evaluate African American voices on their own terms and stages, and in their own plays. Chronologically, the collection covers a period from the early nineteenth century to Barack Obama's first term as president of the United States; but instead of an encompassing narrative arc we find here a sampling of projects attempted or fulfilled, an insightful series of close-ups and medium shots that gradually coalesce into a deliberate portrait of a community that is as diverse within itself as the bigger country that contains it. From the conundrums of black minstrels entertaining white audiences (in a contribution by Douglas A. Jones Jr.) and oblique or direct references to rebellious slaves (in Heather S. Nathans's chapter) to the cumulative appearance of black directors, playwrights, and musicals on Broadway and elsewhere (in essays by Monica White Ndounou, Soyika Diggs Colbert, and Samuel O'Connell), the material Young here collects reveals his preference for highlighting communal efforts and their aesthetic and political impact (described in contributions by Aimee Zygmonski, Jonathan Shandell, and Nadine George-Graves) as well as a special focus on the contributions of women (exemplified by the research of Adrienne Macki Braconi, Faedra Chatard Carpenter, and Sandra G. Shannon).
Two chapters in particular illustrate how Young shapes his focus on African American conflicts and histories that complicate black racial identities. In “Black Theatre in the Age of Obama,” Harry J. Elam Jr. calls attention to the fact that blacks are still more successful at being produced by whites in America than at sharing in the decision-making process that leads to those artistic opportunities. Visibility and presence, he suggests, are not easily translated into power. At the same time, Elam argues, postmodern forms of multiculturalism in which nonblacks are willing to write African American characters are becoming more acceptable, and there has been an increasing acknowledgment of mixed, multiracial subjectivities. Still, Elam's conclusion manages to honor August Wilson's agonistic critique:
[T]he space and places for new black work remain limited. The mechanisms of production, the control over venues, budgets, and artistic selections are for the most part not in black hands [. . .] And so, perhaps now more than ever—in this age of Obama with its evolving definitions of race—is a time in need of the establishment of black cultural institutions. And yet, it is precisely the racial politics in the age of Obama that decry the necessity of constructing separate black institutions. (276)
Obama's presidency is forcing African American creators and theorists to redesign their intellectual parameters: in Elam's view, African American artists and critics are facing the conundrums of accessing the political mainstream—through the presence of a black president—while still being underrepresented in their own society as a whole.
In a similar key, Sandra L. Richards's concise but valuable chapter, “African Diaspora Drama,” starts by recognizing that “[i]n an anthology of criticism about African American theatre, an essay about African Diaspora drama may initially seem out of place because many of the authors and plays that can be grouped under this heading originate from and concern life outside the United States. Yet the inclusion is appropriate, for self-identification as black has always exceeded the nation-state” (230). Her selection of the term “African” over “black” here is deliberate, and marks a desire to address a tendency in many American works on race to emphasize African American communities and the Middle Passage at the cost of marginalizing or ignoring continental Africans. Richards also proposes some promising areas of future study: race as a construction of colonial governmentality; the impact of a text, event, or idea (like the Haitian Revolution) on performance making; intersections between African and other racialized groups (such as Asian, or Hispanic); and the cracks produced in all these discourses by the appearance of queer voices that both complicate and reencode existing categories of difference. Her distinction between modalities of recognition (ways of identifying a common or shared identity) and ranges of articulation (how identities signify their differences from each other) is particularly astute:
In arguing that we understand African Diaspora drama as a range of articulations, I have asserted that we are challenged not only to identify similarity but, equally importantly, to reflect upon how we may be instituting exclusion. At stake in all these articulations are fundamental questions: how do we recognize the humanity of (an) other and build a community? How do we as spectators, readers, and /or practitioners use the space of drama and theatre to imagine, rehearse, and share hopes for a better world in which people can be at home? (248–9)
Richards's decision to conclude her essay with a series of questions is emblematic of this collection as a whole. While many volumes in the Cambridge Companion series tend to construct a panoramic outlook that summarizes recent speculations around a particular historical period or topic, Young has assembled an open-ended incursion into a field that is in a state of flux. The anthology describes African American theatre and performance as a work in progress, a bundle of stories still in the making. As editor, Young is more interested in showcasing how contemporary African American performances overflow the conceptual frames inherited from ethnic and cultural studies; the entire collection intentionally embraces the impossibility of fixing its own contents. This is a daring approach that focuses less on the history of African American theatre than on the contingencies that are constantly redirecting that history. Instead of pursuing an elusive desire for completeness, Young allows the reader to build up his or her own sense of what African American theatre is becoming. As Elam notes, the meaning of blackness is constantly shifting: as a result, “Black theatre [. . .] is not simply a being but a doing; it is a thing done” (256).
While Harvey Young underlines in his collection how internally diverse African American perspectives on race are, in The Problem of the Color[blind]: Racial Transgression and the Politics of Black Performance Brandi Wilkins Catanese convincingly argues that thinking beyond race is not only implausible but also politically ineffective. Catanese remaps our epistemic priorities by positing a critical discourse in which blackness unapologetically disjoints the conciliatory efforts of civic politeness. In its first chapter Catanese's book proposes a hermeneutics of confrontation: instead of aspiring to transcend the racial divide, we should tackle that divide head-on, twisting, reversing, and eroding its edges as much as possible. Catanese claims that blackness—when aesthetically mediated by a deliberate revamping of its traditional modes of representation—can actually trouble, if not dismantle, some of the blind spots of so-called color-neutral casting practices.
In her account of the debate between Wilson and Brustein in her second chapter, Catanese explores the ways in which their seemingly oppositional views actually worked together to turn color into an immanent quality. For Wilson, blackness is both genetic inheritance and experiential responsibility; for Brustein, blackness is a divisive construct that should be replaced by a call to national coherence. Wilson overlooks the fact that color is not essence, but encoded contingency; Brustein prefers to forget that racism, once naturalized, is affectively inscribed into the social body. Catanese suggests that both men's approaches thus have serious limitations. Race cannot be transcended (as Brustein would like) because it is a historical fact, but race is also not something immanent (as Wilson occasionally assumes)—it too is historically conditioned. Is there any way to walk the color line without either reenforcing or diluting it? This is the question Catanese's insightful book tackles head-on.
The impossibility of transcending blackness is exemplified in Catanese's third chapter, “The Limits of Color Blindness: Interracial Sexuality, Denzel Washington, and Hollywood Film.” Examining Denzel Washington as an iconic figure of black masculinity and a black actor who can play other roles, Catanese argues that Washington has been able to elude, quite frequently, the constraints of the color line. Black women adamantly expect him always to prefer them, whereas white women (at least in his movies) might be willing to consider him as a tempting friend or colleague. One thing is certain, however: Washington will almost never take the risk of mixing things up. Catanese celebrates the way his avoidance of white romantic partners in his films reflects the power of African American female audiences to monitor and shape Hollywood's production machine, but she also utilizes his example to illuminate the dead ends of blind casting:
Washington's deception is not visual, since his brown skin cannot disappear; but connotative, regarding the surplus meanings his presence as a black actor will or will not introduce into the film. [. . .] The color blindness that Hollywood claims to grant Washington is ideological and conditional: at times, traditional definitions of blackness will be irrelevant to his function within a narrative. However, this color blindness is never embodied: as black women spectators will attest, Washington's race is never invisible. (88, 111)
Catanese's point here is that any elision of Washington's skin color is basically a trick: we are never blind to his race, but his films allow his skin color to become something we prefer not to see while still knowing it is there. In either case Washington is, no matter which character he is playing, either a black being black or a black not playing black. There is no “blindness” to his casting—only wishful thinking.
If Washington's career exposes the limits of transcendence, in Chapter 4, “Transgressing Tradition: Suzan-Lori Parks and Black Performance (as) Theory,” Catanese argues that the plays of Suzan-Lori Parks carve out the possibilities of deconstructing racial immanence. Although Parks is quite alert to the function of blackness as a constant other of whiteness, she is also invested in contemplating the internal fissures of blackness itself. A willingness to face the discomforts of casting against type are at the center of Catanese's reading of Parks's Venus, and the story of Saartjie Baartman is seen here thorough the lens of her relationship with her white owner, the Baron Docteur. In Richard Foreman's production of Venus in 1996 at the Yale Repertory Theatre, this character was performed by a black man. In that particular case, a deliberate mismatch between a white historical figure and the black skin color of the actor playing that role served to short-circuit normative dialectics of race. If the Baron Docteur is acted by a black male, Parks's text becomes less a critique of whiteness than a critique of how blacks may participate in their own oppression: there are, after all, “records that suggest Saartjie Baartman's original owner, Hendrick Cezar, was himself a free black in Southern Africa” (137). Unorthodox casting procedures can thus enable an audience to inhabit a critical situation in which color is still relevant without being static or predictably marked.
The last chapter of Catanese's book, “Are We There Yet? Race, Redemption, and Black. White.,” focuses on Ice Cube's transformation from a lost child in John Singleton's Boyz n the Hood (1991) into an exemplary American father figure in Brian Levant's Are We There Yet? (2005). Catanese claims that Ice Cube's career responds to a double strategy in which his value as an authentic representative of blackness merges with a capacity to be just human—and American. Ice Cube himself endorsed this maneuver by producing in 2006 a reality TV show called Black. White. In this show, people of both colors were invited to experience each other's everyday milieu. Relying on makeup and a mimetic—and inevitably biased—reproduction of certain cultural and somatic racial traits, white and black participants were supposedly able to pass for each other in public. The program aspired to reconcile the contradictions of this highly contrived premise by recourse to individual agency, a belief that if we try hard enough to relocalize ourselves in the Other's perspective, we will discover that race, albeit inflected by history and circumstance, can still be redefined by our personal choices. Catanese, of course, suspects better:
As it practiced in American society, color blindness involves an acute awareness and subsequent disavowal of the significance of another person's racialized material presence, difference, and reality, rather than simply the inability to recognize them. In the case of Black. White., however, race has to be real enough for audiences to accept and distinguish between different people's racialized sense of themselves, yet permeable enough that the charade to which the series aspires is not offensive or impossible to imagine succeeding. The disavowal of difference in this scenario involves reducing it to something inhabitable by or transferable to another. (159)
I personally, however, would also argue that Ice Cube's effort to foster a transracial embodiment ended by actualizing something that was neither white nor black: Black. White. performed a mixing of colors that still remains underrepresented in our visual repertoire, and the fact that its structural, interracial condition was primarily a cosmetic simulacrum should not “[blind]” us to this unusual semiotic leap into miscegenation.
In Racial Innocence: Performing American Childhood from Slavery to Civil Rights, Robin Bernstein begins her work where Ice Cube ended his. Expanding on the ideas of Martin Heidegger, Bernstein elaborates a groundbreaking phenomenology of how mixed our racial perceptions truly are—and she accomplishes this without remobilizing the sociobiological tropes of hybridity, métissage (racial mixing), or miscegenation. Instead, Bernstein focuses on everyday objects and interprets them as texts that link racial representations to the fabric of everyday American life: “The method of reading material things as scripts aims to discover [. . .] what a thing invited its users to do. This act of scripting, this issuing of a culturally specific invitation, is itself a historical event” (11). Here the archive is the repertoire: material objects, such as dolls and household goods that have survived the passing of time, can be recirculated as condensed narratives that evoke today the bodies that used them in the past. In this particular case, the objects Bernstein analyzes are all related to childhood and specifically evoke the implications of playing with racialized toys.
In Chapter 1, “Tender Angels, Insensate Pickaninnies: The Divergent Paths of Racial Innocence,” Bernstein explains how the representation of childhood in the United States has been inflected by a double gesture that assigns to white bodies a capacity for feeling while denying black bodies access to their pain. She notices how after the American Civil War white girls were presented as angelic and sensitive, but black girls were depicted as affectively flattened. This code of emotional disparity was particularly associated with certain scenes from Uncle Tom's Cabin and the multiple household objects inspired by that novel that were manufactured for public consumption during the second half of the nineteenth century. Bernstein's genealogical retracing of dolls, toys, and illustrations carefully describes how inanimate objects can be transformed into animated participants in the construction of raced social environments. Her analysis opens our eyes to the racialized entanglements of object and flesh that support and facilitate the playing hours of our childhoods.
Bernstein provides, in unexpected and exciting ways, a methodology that helpfully distinguishes agents (persons) from motivators (commodities). Objects in her analysis are indexes of social intentionality; they have been designed to circulate from hand to hand, from room to room, channeling textiles and figurines into the routines of everyday life: “The ontological distinction between things and objects,” she carefully notes, “is that things hail” (77). While an object is not an incentive to action, a thing provokes an action. In Chapters 2 and 3, “Scriptive Things” and “Everyone is Impressed: Slavery as a Tender Embrace from Uncle Tom's to Uncle Remus's Cabin,” Bernstein documents how an object becomes a thing when its potential to interpellate us activates an affective response. Books like E. W. Kemble's A Coon Alphabet trained readers to assemble their contents into quite disturbing scenarios: playing games with cards that included portraits of little Eva and Uncle Tom allowed people to rehearse social equations that were otherwise rejected or feared by their communities; a black doll, dismembered and punished, recalled a violent history in which destroying a black body was considered acceptable. A black doll, in other words, was never just a toy.
If a thing is an object that calls us, a piece of matter that gives us permission to act, the concern over presence and disappearance that has marked performance theory from the start is immediately thrown into question. Between emerging and vanishing there is an uncanny region in which ordinary things like dolls can make us do something. In Chapter 4, “The Black-and-Whiteness of Raggedy Ann,” Bernstein describes how, depending on how we manipulate them, topsy-turvy dolls can be either white or black. Chapter 5, “The Scripts of Black Dolls,” meanwhile unpacks the uncanny significations of specifically black toys:
All dolls in play, and all stories about sentient dolls, trouble the boundary between person and thing—the terror at the ontological core of slavery. Nineteenth-century black dolls, however, uniquely literalized these functions in that they were owned, insentient things that often explicitly represented enslaved humans. Black dolls marked and eroded the border between person and thing; thus they functioned as devices in the meaning and memory of slavery. (222)
What I find most tantalizing in this book is the way Bernstein recounts how the movements that made Raggedy Ann's game of hide-and-seek possible also actualized, at a different level, the same interracial ambivalences that affected American society as a whole (146–93). As an artifact, Raggedy Ann was always more than one color and less than two; the topsy-turvy doll brings to the picture the notion that one color can turn into another at any moment, and in that sense it destabilizes the rigidity of racial classifications while still preserving their asymmetric features.
In the introduction to her book, Bernstein tells the story of a justice of the peace in Louisiana who, in 2009, denied wedding rites to a racially mixed couple. The justice claimed that he wanted to protect the unborn children of this couple from a callous society that is not yet comfortable with miscegenation (1–4). With ethical finesse and theoretical dexterity, Bernstein's book explores, to the contrary, the extent to which our national reality has been a topsy-turvy one from the start. Raggedy Ann (a doll that dances on the color line itself) alerts us to the fact that—pace August Wilson and Robert Brustein—the boundaries between black and white are always partial, and frequently undecidable.
Barack Obama's presidency is not, and should not be read as, an overcoming of the color line; on the contrary, his personal story reminds us that the United States is, by definition, a polyracial country. What I have learned from these three books is that if we stop talking about race, we will also have to stop talking about our very national history. The United States is the result of innumerable demographic entanglements and segregations, hyphens, diasporas, and accents, and these important texts encourage a dynamic revamping of our collective narratives about race. Young's anthology reveals how African American groups and artists defy, indeed have always defied, any monolithic rendition of their blackness. Brandi Wilkins Catanese suggests that ignoring race solidifies racism: blackness has to be displayed, shaken, and pushed into critical exasperation. Robin Bernstein shows how race inhabits not only our bodies, but the domestic milieu in which we dwell and the objects we manipulate and use every day: color travels and touches our children even when they are playing in the privacy of our own homes. The color line has been for a long time a tightrope; today, our historical balance hinges on our ability to turn that tightrope into a highway of critical engagement and debate both between and within inherited racial demarcations.
Interestingly enough—and just like Frederick Douglass, W. E. B. Du Bois, Halle Berry, and Barack Obama—August Wilson was a mixed-race citizen. The fact that métissage is still a problematic position in our country, that for some of us choosing one parental skin over another can be an ethical imperative, underscores how polarized our racial politics still are. For many, the land of the brave is the land of the either/or. But hybridity also needs to be seen as one road among many others, and not as a road out of our racialized past. Liberated from their role as diplomatic mediators between black and white, mixed, interracial experiences should be understood, for a change, on their own terms. Blackness and whiteness—and redness, and brownness—can stand together, mixed or not, as spaces of difference without being forced into artificial sameness. At their core, the three books I've explored here share a common request: that we avoid racial simplifications. While writing these lines I am, of course, already wondering which dolls Michelle Obama's daughters play with, or which leading man will play the role of Barack Obama when that movie gets made. Denzel Washington will be too old by then.
