The stated goal of this edited volume is to challenge the dominant concept of citizenship as “a unitary and homogenous legal status granted to an individual by a sovereign state” (p. vii). To this end, 11 chapters identify a fascinating variety of historical and contemporary case studies in which some elements of citizenship—membership regimes, rights, political participation, identity, and belonging—are provided by and experienced at local, municipal, regional, transnational, or supranational levels. Willem Maas explicitly rejects, however, the attempt to develop an alternative model of citizenship to that of national citizenship; indeed, he argues that such an endeavor is doomed to failure, given the multiplicity of citizenship practices revealed in the book (p. 6). Ample evidence is provided for Maas’s claim that state-centric citizenship may be a “historical anomaly whose fortunes rose and will wane with those of sovereign nation-states as the dominant form of political organization” (p. 21). Many questions remain, however, about the political consequences of the alternative conceptions of citizenship presented here. The volume thus highlights the need for more detailed considerations of the ways in which existing and future multilevel citizenship practices, outside of those in the much-studied case of the European Union, will be accommodated by citizenship theory. It also leaves unanswered questions about the difference between disaggregated citizenship “practices” and the particular combinations of such practices required for democratic citizenship, whether or not it occurs at the nation-state level.
In the first of three sections, entitled “Migrants and Migrations,” Luicy Pedroza looks at the implications of noncitizen residents’ (denizens’) enfranchisement for a model of citizenship that places political participation at its heart. Using an original data set of 46 countries’ rules on denizens’ electoral rights, Pedroza argues that cross-country variations in relation to denizen enfranchisement are significant enough to challenge the idea that there is an international trend toward the decline of “citizenship-as-nationality” (pp. 27–31). She finds that many rules for denizen enfranchisement, and immigration entry criteria, are still tied to nationality traditions. Her findings are important, although her claim that the New Zealand case, the only country to grant full voting rights to non-citizens after one year’s residence (not six months as stated by Pedroza), is “exhausted” is difficult to sustain. To date there have been no detailed studies on the political impacts of granting non-citizens the right to vote in New Zealand. Rogers M. Smith explores tussles among the local, state, and federal governments in the United States over the right to make and implement immigration policy. Jenn Kinney and Elizabeth F. Cohen, also focusing on the United States, argue that variations between states in their approach to immigrant rights and enforcement have “constructed a multilevel hierarchy of semicitizenships based on legally assigned statuses and geographic location” (p. 84). Both of these American-focused chapters point to the inequality of treatment that can result from overlapping sovereignties, although here that inequality applies to immigrants, not citizens.
A second section, “Empires and Indigeneity,” considers three cases in which periods of transitional and contested sovereignties gave rise to ambiguity over rights and identity, in nondemocracies as well as democracies. Will Hanley’s chapter looks at Egypt’s incomplete transition from Ottoman imperialism to Egyptian nationalism during the early twentieth century, arguing that Western citizenship scholars’ focus on political citizenship has led them to ignore membership regimes, such as those present in the Middle East, that do not conform to the Western norm of national belonging. Elizabeth Dale examines the case of two Chinese revolutionaries, Zou Rong and Zhang Binglin, tried for seditious libel during the early twentieth century in what was known as the Su Bao case. Dale’s intention in exploring this particular case is to argue that the defendants’ calls for democracy, and their agile maneuvering through the overlapping jurisdictions of multiple sovereigns during the late Qing Dynasty, demonstrated that citizenship is something that can be enacted by subjects, as well as codified in law. Sheryl Lightfoot traces the development of Indigenous rights in international treaties and national practices, identifying North American practices of multilevel citizenship in relation to indigenous peoples as providing models, albeit imperfect ones, for ways in which national practices can “align with the emerging Indigenous rights discourse” (p. 46).
The third section of the book focuses explicitly on examples of local, multinational, and transnational forms of decision making and identity formation. Marc Helbling’s study seeks to explain why some Swiss municipalities, each of which decides its own naturalization policies, are less generous than others in granting naturalization to applicants. He finds that the relative strength of right-wing populist parties, and the opportunity for anonymous voting in cantonal decision-making processes, best explains the different outcomes. He further argues that the diversity evident among the Swiss cantons’ citizenship policies challenges the idea, exemplified in the work of Rogers Brubaker and Adrian Favell, that a country’s citizenship policy can be largely explained with reference to its historical traditions of politics and belonging. Eldar Sarajlić moves the focus to another European country, Bosnia and Herzogovina, where, he argues, the coexistence of national and subnational “entity” citizenships may help preserve the fragile peace created by the Dayton Peace Agreement of 1995 but, on account of the ethnic basis of entity membership, fail to protect human rights in the country. Entity citizenship is used, for example, as a basis on which to deny political rights to Bosnia and Herzogovinan citizens resident in a subnational entity for which they do not hold citizenship.
In what was for me the stand-out chapter, Türküler Isikel continues this theme of nonsalutary citizenship models with an examination of the way in which private economic actors have, through international economic institutions with binding dispute-settlement mechanisms, created for themselves a form of “market citizenship” (p. 184). She points to a future in which international economic institutions significantly undermine the capacity of democratic publics to exert effective decision-making authority, leading her to the sobering conclusion that “market citizenship is symptomatic of a creeping takeover of the possibilities for democratic politics by market logic” (p. 202). Sarajlić’s and Isikel’s contributions each illustrate how overlapping and incomplete sovereignties can work to the detriment of democratic citizenship.
In the final chapter, Catherine Neveu challenges scholars to look for “citizenship manufacturing processes” (p. 203) that occur in local and transnational spaces overlooked in the literature’s tight focus on nation-state citizenship. Drawing from an empirical case study of French migrants from the Senegal River valley (Mali, Senegal, and Mauritania), she argues that the migrants’ involvement in development projects in their home countries has both enhanced their political agency in France and created a “spiderweb” (p. 212) of cultural, social, and political connections between individuals and communities in France and those in the Senegal River valley.
In highlighting the rich and underexplored diversity of citizenship practices, Multilevel Citizenship makes an enormously valuable contribution to the empirical citizenship literature, and also to that which seeks to place European Union citizenship in historical, cultural, and geographic context. Inevitably in a volume that looks to contest a dominant theoretical construct without offering an alternative in its place, definitional questions arise. By what criteria ought we, if at all, distinguish between the multilevel citizenship developing in the European Union and the other forms of citizenship described here, not all of which appear to promote democratic politics? That, I would suggest, is the next step in what Maas identifies as a project motivated by the “urgent need to reflect on citizenship as a construction of political and legal practices and of territorial affiliations that are not limited by physical borders” (pp. 1–2).
