The emergence of the Perestroika movement in U.S. political science was an important moment in the contemporary history of our discipline, and as we approach the 10-year anniversary of this movement, it is fitting that PS should publish a retrospective symposium on its origins and significance.
It was with particular pleasure that I read Greg Kasza's contribution to this symposium, because he is not simply a leader of the Perestroika movement, but also a personal friend and Indiana University colleague. Greg's short piece focuses on one of the central concerns that motivated Perestroika at its inception: the inclusiveness and representativeness of the top political science journals. Its point is simple: while the movement emerged to contest the hegemony of quantitative and formal approaches in the discipline's key journals—the American Political Science Review (APSR), the American Journal of Political Science (AJPS), and the Journal of Politics (JOP)—and while it has had an impact in promoting an appreciation of more qualitative methods, no substantial change in the inclusiveness of the discipline's top journals has resulted. These journals continue to publish a very high percentage of statistical and formal scholarship and almost no qualitative-empirical work.
Although Greg offers no systematic evidence for this claim, he does present some suggestive evidence. Indeed, the APSR's own data, furnished in its annual reports, support Greg's point, and this issue has been a topic of concern in recent APSA Council discussions.
Greg no doubt speaks for many when he asks: “How is it that so many years of protest have produced such negligible results?” And he answers: “Political action, not sound arguments, governs the academy, and qualitative scholars have been out-politicked.” Furthermore, he explains: “When the editorship of a major journal opens up, hard scientists band together and present a viable proposal for assuming the task. Qualitative scholars do not. So guess who ends up editing our journals?” (734)
I share the concern about intellectual pluralism in our discipline. Yet I am honestly stunned by a strange and glaring silence that attends much of this discussion and that marks Greg's well-intended piece, a silence about the journal that I happen to edit—Perspectives on Politics.
Perspectives is approaching its ninth year of operation under its third editorial team. Housed at Indiana University, a few feet from the stairway leading to Greg's office, Perspectives is a quarterly journal that publishes over twelve hundred large pages of political science research articles, essays, and book reviews every year. Generously supported by the APSA and by a midwestern public university with impeccable credentials as a bastion of social scientific empiricism, the journal occupies three offices and employs an editorial staff of seven. It is a very substantial enterprise and a major commitment of time, space, money, and intellectual resources.
The story of Perspectives' origins is no doubt complicated and has many versions. Yet although there is much room for disagreement about narratives and causalities, it is hard to deny three things: Perspectives is a substantial journal; its creation by the APSA coincided with important arguments posed by the Perestroika movement and at least partly sought to address these arguments; and its stated mission is to promote a broad, inclusive, and integrative approach to political science research and writing.
Perspectives, in short, exists to address many of the concerns raised by Perestroika and reiterated in Greg's piece. And, indeed, it does precisely this. No analysis of its pages—whether quantitative or qualitative, whether focused on the past four years or the past eight years—would produce anything like the profile Greg presents of the APSR or AJPS or JOP. Perspectives insistently seeks to publish work that reaches a broad audience and that is generally readable at the same time that it is theoretical and scholarly.
It is striking that Greg's piece omits mention of Perspectives, just as it is striking that when many critics of the APSR treat the profile of what it publishes as a sign of the exclusiveness of the discipline, they also omit the fact that Perspectives too is a journal financed and published by the APSA. In short, the APSA of 2010 is not the APSA of 2000, and one of the reasons for this shift is because, partly in response to the noble efforts of Perestroika, in 2002, the APSA created a new journal, endowed it with substantial resources, and designated it as an additional “flagship journal” of the discipline (or at least of its 14,000-strong professional association).
Greg's failure to take account of this journal in his piece is strange, partly because this acknowledgment would testify to the effectiveness of his efforts as a Perestroikan. And yet there is a method to this madness that centers around a key concept in Greg's piece—the notion of what a “major” journal is. Greg's piece focuses on profiling the major journals of the discipline. He does not unpack this notion of “major” in the article, but the phrase clearly implicates some interesting and potentially contentious conceptions of the distribution of power in the profession and equally contestable senses of current trends and future probabilities. But what constitutes a “major” journal, and why does Greg's piece focus on “the big three”? In short, what makes the APSR, AJPS, and JOP “the big three”?
One possibility, the most plausible, is that the three are reputed by the leadership of the profession, as well as many of its members, to be the “best” or “most important” journals—in other words, these journals have the most “prestige.” There is much truth to this. But such designations are also complicated, and there are increasingly large numbers of colleagues who question them and really believe that a wider range of journals ought to be regarded as major—and who act on this belief through their work on hiring and promotion committees, in their practices of article submission, and in the way they read and write. Indeed, an increasingly large number of our colleagues view the “big three” as major journals of only one particular kind of political science and, indeed, view two of these three as basically journals of the statistical and formal study of American politics. The reputational hegemony of the so-called “big three” can thus no longer be taken for granted by their partisans or their critics—an outcome partly due to the efforts of Perestroikans.
A second possibility for the classification of these journals as “major” is that they are the official journals of official disciplinary associations, whether national or regional. This explanation is also plausible, with one key flaw, noted previously—the APSA, the primus inter pares, if not the emperor, of disciplinary associations in U.S. political science, now supports not one but two “flagship” journals (PS has also undergone some important improvements, though I will leave those aside for the moment). The Perspectives editor-in-chief—currently me—serves ex officio on the APSA Council, just as the APSR editor does; Perspectives enjoys a similar measure of APSA financial support; and, indeed, in the past year, Perspectives has used much more than its third of the total space allotted to APSA journals by Cambridge (count the pages in our journal and compare the number to the pages filled by the other two APSA journals). In short, by any measure, Perspectives is just as “official” as the APSR. At least at the institutional level, the journal has arrived. Perhaps many Perestroikans are unaware of this fact. It is important, then, that they know it.
So, on the first two grounds—reputation or scholarly credibility and institutional standing—it is not at all clear that “the big three” are the only “major” journals, much less the commonly acknowledged big three.
This brings me to the third possible meaning of “major,” a purely qualitative meaning. Perhaps in implicitly accepting a widespread view that the so-called big three are the three major journals, Greg means to imply that they are the best journals, that they publish the best work, the work that is most worthy of scholarly attention and, in some sense, most intellectually important. It seems unlikely that this is his meaning, since his very point is to criticize the exclusiveness of these journals on the grounds that their status is politically and not intellectually secured.
The epistemic aspects of Greg's argument are not clear, and this lack of clarity has characterized much of the Perestroika movement from its inception, which has wavered between the claim that broader and more relevant work is better work—or at least equally excellent work—and the claim that “justice” requires that a wider range of professionals have the chance to see their names in print. At one point, Greg claims that it is “silly” to imagine that anyone could possibly judge the diversity of work in political science and suggests that the best and “fairest” way to manage this problem would be to create a truly representative, collective editorship, under which scholars would be judged by those who share their approach and editorial space would presumably be shared equally among the various approaches. As Greg points out, this structure is the current APSR editorial model. His objection to the current APSR, it would seem, is that although the journal claims to be inclusive, it is not as inclusive as it claims to be. On this reading, Greg's piece is a call not for a broader conception of what counts as good work, but simply for a more inclusive conception of who gets to judge what. In this view, the question of what constitutes excellent work, much less the best work, is unanswerable and beside the point, except by adherents of the many (and constantly multiplying) specialties and subspecialties in the discipline, each judging in their own cases.
It is thus unclear to me why Greg insists on a rhetorical frame that implicitly concedes the common sense belief of mainstream political science circa 1995 that “the big three” are the big three, for on no basis—whether prestige or official recognition or intellectual merit—is it obvious that these three journals are the most important journals in political science.
Of course, my real point is that the question of “importance” condenses a range of contestable and contested conceptions of intellectual quality, ethical and practical relevance, and aesthetics. I do not wish to argue that the so-called big three are unimportant, or that arguments about them and their policies and records ought to be avoided. I simply mean to insist that these three journals really ought to be dethroned from their hegemony, and that the first step is to stop talking about them as if they are the publications that matter most. Had Greg's piece been entitled “Perestroika and those Journals,” that would be one thing. But “the” journals?
Indeed, I would actually go further: it is silly to imagine that the most esoteric and specialized languages and methods employed by our colleagues can be widely understood, even within the discipline. But it is equally silly to think that the best we can do is to make editorial boards more “representative” and to more “fairly” allocate space to the range of legitimate perspectives (should all 38 organized sections of the APSA have representation?). We can formulate far better solutions than these. We can improve our discipline by promoting a better idea of what it means to practice political science, emphasizing that while specialized inquiries have their place in political science, work that is more integrative and that reaches across specialties and subfields is no less, and perhaps even more, important. In this view, the primary goal is not to concede mutual incomprehension or advance the cause of proportional representation in our discipline—a version of academic interest group liberalism—but instead to foster a broader, more inclusive, and more pluralistic public sphere within political science itself.
Political myths are an important and motivational feature of all political activism. Perhaps the mobilization of Perestroikan energy—and critique is never a bad thing—requires a belief that things really have not changed all that much. I am certain that my own efforts as editor of Perspectives require me to truly believe that the hegemony of the big three is an important historical-institutional fact that is now in question at the highest levels of the profession, and that Perspectives on Politics is not simply an institutionally prescribed “flagship journal” of the APSA—a bureaucratic status—but a major journal with a track record of publishing excellence and great, as-yet untapped potential. I do believe these things. I also believe that I am right to believe this, and that a serious account of the intellectual and institutional history of U.S. political science over the past 10 years would support the perspective that Perspectives matters. How much the journal matters or should matter are, of course, questions that admit honest disagreement. But Perspectives has arrived, and it is here, and I would submit that it ought to figure in discussions about how major journals are organized and oriented, and how a political science public sphere can best be promoted.
It is true that contemporary political science in the United States is highly balkanized, and that the development of highly specialized vocabularies—which are productive and ought to be welcomed, in their proper place—make the fostering of a disciplinary core difficult. The APSR used to serve such a unifying purpose. The APSR circa 1980 could not simply be read by almost any professional political scientist; it could be engaged by any political scientist, who was able not simply to understand the introductions and conclusions of articles, but to read entire articles, understand them, and participate in a common scientific discourse about them. This is no longer the case. The APSR is trying, valiantly, to be broad and responsive. But it has apparently concluded that the best way—and perhaps the only way—to achieve this goal is to have a collective editorship in which major perspectives are represented, so that all potential authors feel fairly treated and each issue of the journal contains something for everyone. This model is indeed not far from Greg Kasza's model; he simply wants a broader collective editorship and perhaps more pages in the journal to feature a broader range of authors. This is a valid goal to be sure. Yet such a move is a huge concession to hyperspecialization and mutual incomprehension in our discipline.
Such a concession might be unavoidable for the APSR. But Perspectives on Politics seeks to do something else, something as important and, arguably, perhaps even better—to foster broad and integrative political science research that is serious, excellent, relevant, and well written, and to demonstrate that it is possible, even in this highly specialized age, for a disciplinary core and a shared public sphere within political science to exist. Perspectives is both an experiment and a work in progress (what isn't a work in progress?). The journal does not wish to clear the field of alternative approaches to scholarly publishing in political science, but merely to exemplify a new approach that is actually an old approach that was long-embodied in the best work of the APSR. Perspectives aspires to publish excellent work and to be and be regarded as a major journal of political science.
If this be special pleading, then make the most of it!
