There is a good deal of historical evidence to show that countries experiencing rapid economic growth also experience a pattern of uneven or distorted development manifested in heightened income inequalities. In this situation, an emerging middle and wealthy class of urban entrepreneurs, civil servants and military elites enjoy the benefits of development while the bulk of the rural population and those who migrate to the cities and live in the sprawling shanty towns are largely excluded. Although many economists believe that the problem will eventually be resolved as the process of development proceeds, government social security policies and programmes can contribute to the reduction of inequality and mitigate its negative effects. However, there is evidence to show that these programmes have not only failed to address the problem but have actually exacerbated inequalities. Research into this question goes back many decades (Midgley, Reference Midgley1984), but subsequent enquiry has been impeded by the reluctance of social policy scholars to address the challenge of inequality directly. By examining the way social security policies have heightened inequalities and contributed to a process of uneven development in China, Frazier has made a major contribution to understanding the issues. His account also has relevance for the formulation of policies that can resolve the problem.
The book examines the evolution of social security retirement pensions in China since the 1990s when the previous state-owned enterprise-based social security system has gradually been replaced with a social insurance model managed by urban local governments under the direction of the national government. This has been a huge transition involving major economic, managerial and other challenges but it has generally resulted in the creation of a pension system that has the potential to provide adequate income protection for older people. It also has the potential to redistribute resources and mitigate the serious inequalities that fosters social disharmony and poses a significant challenge to the Communist Party leadership. As Frazier reveals, the reform of the old system has not only failed to achieve this goal, but has actually contributed to greater inequality. He deftly analyzes a number of reasons for this state of affairs. For example, as in many other developing countries, the social security system is urban based and it excludes the rural population, reinforcing urban–rural inequality. Even though a rural social security system has recently been introduced to replace earlier ineffectual efforts, the country's huge rural population enjoys limited retirement protection. Migrants from the rural areas who have become a major part of the urban labour force are also excluded from the system. Another factor is that contribution avoidance is widespread and he points out that many enterprises have classified their employees as temporary workers in order to avoid paying into the system. The result is that only about a third of the country's population is currently protected. Another problem is mismanagement and corruption which has resulted in a number of major scandals in which social security administrators have been convicted for diverting accumulated pension funds to developers and entrepreneurs, often in return for favours. The decentralisation of the system to local urban authorities is yet another reason for the programme's failure to contribute to the reduction of inequalities. The central government's role is largely confined to formulating policies and guidelines while actual implementation is in the hands of city and municipal governments. This arrangement effectively impedes the system's ability to redistribute between wealthier and poorer regions of the country and between workers of different income levels. By locating the administration of the system at the local level, wide variations in implementation, concessions to employers and ad hoc rule-making have become common. Variations in implementation are revealed in the way some parts of the country have adopted a dual insurance and mandatory savings system, while others rely on insurance alone. Similar differences in coverage and benefit and contribution rates can be observed.
In addition to providing an incisive account of the issues of inequality, social policy and uneven development, Frazier has meticulously documented the recent history of retirement social security policy in China. Making appropriate use of theory to frame his analysis, he has extensively analyzed the workings of the system. His study is also enhanced by a survey of public opinion about the current system. Although this research is limited to the Beijing area, it reveals, perhaps surprisingly, that there is a high degree of confidence in the government's ability to provide income protection to older citizens. While the author's conclusion about the social security system's role in fostering inequality is disheartening, it also reveals its complexity and its unintended as well as positive effects. The book makes a helpful contribution to understanding social security policy in China today, but its central theme will be of particular interest to those working in the fields of social policy and social development in the Global South. Hopefully, it will foster more research into the way social policy in the developing world can be redesigned to promote a style of development that reduces inequality and ensures that the population as a whole benefits equitably from social security policies and programmes.
