Writing on corruption in any country is fraught with challenges. And Cuba is not just any country. As the authors of this volume make clear there was, for many years, a culture of corruption on the island which prospered under Spain, the US administration of 1898–1902 (although this book says little of that period), and what Cubans term the ‘pseudo-republic’ of 1902–1958. Much of this corruption was successfully tackled in the early years of the Revolution after 1959, only to return again with a vengeance in the Special Period, the years since 1990 characterised by the end of favourable terms of trade and assistance from the other COMECON nations that had helped sustain Cuban successes from the 1960s to the 1980s.
The authors are Cuban-Americans who have written a good deal on the island in the past. Regrettably, it is of course very difficult for such people to do work on the island, and time on the ground is among the most essential features of effective research on this complex society, the mere mention of which stirs so much passion. US regulations make such research virtually impossible and Cuban suspicions of studies of this kind, especially if made by US citizens of Cuban extraction, do not help either.
This book has many good points to it and most of them stem from a masterly overview of the literature on corruption, much of which is little known to many academically inclined persons writing on closely connected subjects such as sustainable democracy, and political and economic transitions from authoritarian systems to more open ones. The first chapters on corruption more widely are truly excellent and invite reading.
It is in the sections on Cuba itself that one is forced to pause for more than a moment, and wonder why the authors chose an academic press such as the University of Texas to publish their findings. While, of course, it is acknowledged that working in this field is difficult, the almost total dependence on US and even Cuban-American sources for this work seriously undermines whatever balance the study might have had. Over and over again one finds that the source for quite important assertions is Miami's The New Herald, or sources close to the extremist Cuban-American National Foundation. While such voices have every right to be heard of course, an academic study must be more balanced, especially again in discussions of these overheated subjects.
In addition, the constant reference to Cuba's government merely as its regime, the inevitable use of ‘socialist’ as equating with inefficient or even dishonest government, and the assumption of the end of the current order as a natural and inevitable result of logic applied to context, are very annoying indeed to those interested in analysis and facts on an immensely important subject, on which little indeed has been written and where a study of this kind is both needed and awaited with interest.
It is true that this book was written before the illness of Fidel Castro was announced in July 2006 and at a time where it was taken as a given within the Cuban-American community that Fidel's fall was imminent and that political, social and economic transitions would necessarily follow. And while few would be so bold as to assume any such thing now that the sustainability of the Cuban state is much clearer to serious observers than before, the authors wrote their work when another set of ideas of what has proven to be wishful thinking was dominant in Miami and in much of the United States.
Thus they cannot be entirely blamed for what is now clearly a work unfortunately well short of the mark. Well written and interesting on the whole, the inability to find and keep to facts is striking. For example, there is only one mention of the embargo/blockade of the island by the United States in the lengthy analysis of the shortages that impinge so seriously on any attempt to resolve the problems of current corruption. It is all somehow the fault of ‘socialism’. There is no proof offered for this. It is taken as a given. Any US role in the creation of Cuba's difficulties is entirely left aside here.
There is likewise virtually no mention of the very real efforts made by the Cuban state to fight what it clearly sees as a serious scourge. Indeed, the authors curiously pour scorn on such efforts, while referring to their extent and priority. There is no mention of the end to impunity that has sent many very highly placed figures to jail for long periods. Astoundingly, for an academic study, there is no reference to the praise heaped on Cuba in the corruption-ridden anti-drugs field internationally and at home, not only by the United Nations, Interpol, the European Union (especially the United Kingdom), but also by the US's own Drug Enforcement Agency, Coast Guard and Pentagon. Likewise one searches in vain for mention of how Cuba's medical and educational systems, mentioned as classic cases for the problem, not only combat difficult contexts for corruption, but maintain an unmatched record for assistance to many of the world's poorer nations in those central fields of human endeavour.
Instead one finds that if the supporting sources are not from Miami-based institutions, they tend to be from right-wing organisations such as the Heritage Foundation or the US government, whose job is to undermine the Cuban revolution. It makes for interesting reading but academically balanced and supported it is not.
Cuba has a very serious problem of corruption at all levels of the state. The nature and extent of this corruption is important to understand, as the authors suggest, in order to assist Cuba in its future course. But a study based to all intents and purposes on US and Cuban-American sources, as well as ‘exile’ surveys, simply does not have academic legitimacy. There are literally dozens of books, articles in reviews and newspapers, and internet discussions on the subject, written by respected academics and journalists on the island who know the subject and have no axe to grind. These sources are necessary for a serious and balanced academic study which will truly help us understand the phenomenon. They are lacking here, and the results unfortunately diminish enormously the usefulness of this volume.
