As the political documentary has experienced a new flowering in recent years, it is a pleasure to look back at the venerable documentary films of the 1930s to see what they can teach us about their time and about our own. Although their image tracks remain potent today, their soundtracks—degraded or poorly recorded in the first place—have not fared so well. We can therefore greet with gratitude the efforts of Joseph Horowitz, the Post-Classical Ensemble, and Naxos to give these films new life by releasing them with fresh performances of the original scores. Building on an earlier success—the restoration of The River and The Plow that Broke the Plains (directed by Pare Lorentz, with soundtracks by Virgil Thomson)—this newer DVD makes available another classic documentary of the 1930s, The City, a landmark in urban planning and the first film to feature music by Aaron Copland.
Most of Thomson's music for The Plow and The River was easy to find via recordings of his orchestral suites; in the case of The City, however, Copland excerpted only two short sequences from the nearly thirty-five minutes of music he wrote for the forty-three minute film, including them in the suite Music for Movies (1942).Footnote 1 This DVD thus makes both Copland's music and the film itself commercially available essentially for the first time since its twice-daily screenings at the 1939 World's Fair in New York City, which pamphlets advertised as a herald to “The World of Tomorrow.” Commissioned by the American Institute of Planners, with financial support from the Carnegie Foundation, and created by leftist filmmakers Ralph Steiner and Willard Van Dyke, The City elaborates a basic idea conceived by Pare Lorentz using a scenario by Henwar Rodakiewicz and poetic commentary written by Lewis Mumford. As Elizabeth Bergman Crist has shown, that basic idea—the need for cooperative planning to conquer modern urban ills—suited Copland's personal beliefs as a figure in the Popular Front of progressive culture in the United States.Footnote 2 The film was deeply collaborative from the start (including some orchestration contributed by Henry Brant), and that spirit of collaboration continues in the present restoration.
The City portrays, in biographer Howard Pollack's words, “four different types of American society: an old New England village, an industrial factory town and its slums, a metropolitan center, and a ‘new city’ of the sort built by the Resettlement Administration in the late 1930s (the so-called Greenbelt towns).”Footnote 3 This sequence of scenes allowed Copland's underscoring (which rarely overlaps with the spoken narration) to demonstrate both the “urban” idiom of Music for the Theatre (1925) and the emerging “pastoral” tone that would characterize the film Our Town (1940) and the ballet Appalachian Spring (1944). Under the baton of Angel Gil-Ordóñez, the Post-Classical Ensemble adeptly banishes the balance problems, wavering pitches, and occasional distortion that distract from the beauty of Copland's writing in the 1939 recording. Those who nonetheless appreciate the aural patina of the original will be glad to hear and compare this new rendering with the original, monaural soundtrack and narration, thoughtfully included among the DVD's special features.
If there is a controversial element in this otherwise unobjectionable project, it lies in the handling of the narration, performed with great fluency and range by Francis Guinan, an actor with considerable experience in Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre Ensemble.Footnote 4 As Joseph Horowitz explains in his expert liner notes, “contradicting Hollywood common practice, Virgil Thomson once advised that when film music is mixed with the human voice, voices should be no louder than is required for words to be understood. The present DVD endeavors to follow this ‘sound’ advice. We feel that we have honored the contrapuntal density of a rare transaction between word, music, and image–and that otherwise Copland's score could not project with full weight.” Copland himself recognized (often with chagrin) that a good film score was usually destined to go “unheard” in the movie theater, especially in a film as rich as The City in sound effects: bells, whistles, car horns, breaking glass, and general business bustle, including the hubbub of a corps of stenographers. At the same time, Guinan's performance provides a fascinating opportunity to contrast the typical “voice-of-God” narration style characteristic of the 1930s with something distinctly more intimate and consciously artful. No matter who is narrating, the script requires a deft mixture of stentorian oration and rapid-fire delivery, especially in the urban sequences; being able to hear Guinan's realization side by side with the original narration of Morris Carnovsky is both thought provoking and instructive for anyone interested in media and the arts of persuasion.
Two other special features (in addition to the original film) add enormous value to this DVD, solidifying its status as a scholarly resource as well as a restoration. The first is Horowitz's half-hour interview with eminent documentary film director and historian George Stoney (presented in several tracks with helpful subtitles). Among many interesting points, Stoney observes that The City is quite rare among 1930s documentaries for its sense of humor—an attribute directed at the original “mass audiences” of the World's Fair, but also one well suited to Copland's own penchant for irony. Stoney's scholarly perspective is complemented by the inclusion on this DVD of the short feature “Which Playground for Your Child: Greenbelt or Gutter,” completed in 2000 by the Greenbelt Museum in Maryland. Introduced by Museum director Katie Scott-Childress, four Greenbelt “pioneers” and one new resident share their impressions of growing up in this planned community and, in some cases, their experiences when the lengthy final sequence of the film was being shot on location from July to September of 1938.
For those of us who teach or study the music and culture of interwar America, it can be difficult to recapture the peculiar mix of optimism and world-weariness that characterized the 1930s. Simply as an artifact of New Deal propaganda for the Resettlement Administration, The City runs the risk of seeming hollow: a utopian dream for which contemporary suburban living offers only a poor substitute. Yet the Greenbelt “pioneers” whose voices are captured here, together with the immensely enlivening influence of Copland's scoring heard at last to full advantage, ensure that we can reconsider “The World of Tomorrow” with fresh eyes and ears.
