Philip Roth: Fiction and Power is a thorough exploration of the work of one of America's most eminent contemporary writers, and its critical perspective enables it to contribute to a broader discussion in the field of literary criticism and the humanities in general – that of the value of literature. This new monograph describes a writer's lifelong struggle to establish ways to conceive fiction both as a means of thinking about life and its moral intricacies and as a powerful affective medium. Indeed, Patrick Hayes's new book appears at a time when the humanities are under huge pressure to justify their own public value. In the course of 236 pages, the critic shows Roth's ambivalence towards the inheritance he had received from the literary establishment of his formative years – mainly the New York intellectuals, including Philip Rahv, Irving Howe, Alfred Kazin and, above all, Lionel Trilling. The line of thought that connects the work of Henry James to Trilling and Nussbaum, which in the book assumes the role of Roth's dialectical counterpart, is labelled by Hayes “the Culture of Redemption” (borrowing Leo Bersani's term): an understanding of literature as an occasion for moral elevation, a sort of aid to the discourse of moral philosophy at the service of liberal democratic values. This book sheds new light on Roth's intense negotiation between these values and a distinctively post-Nietzschean approach to literature – one which regards literature as a purely affective experience and expression of the will to power, unbound by any moral restriction. Aesthetics exceeds ethics – even though, in Roth's interpretation of Nietzschean thought, the two do not constitute two different realms, but are constantly intertwined in both life and literature.
Hayes's forte is his ability to reconstruct the intellectual environment of a certain time and place and account for the intensity of the clash between the opposing ideas that were contributing to it. The cultural period foregrounded in the chapter on Roth's youth is the occasion to contextualize opposing ways of valuing literature that are still relevant today, but have their roots back in the Hegelian critique of modernity (which Hayes reads through the work of Habermas, a major theoretical influence here, as in his previous book). Accordingly, each of the six chapters that follow deals with a particular theme that was central not only to Roth's work, but to the entire literary establishment of his time, and it does so by revolving around two or more novels from disparate periods in Roth's chronology. The nature of the writer's career itself, made of books that often recursively revisit themes already discussed in previous work, makes Hayes's approach both solid and intriguing. Thus “Tragedy” investigates the author's evolving redefinition of the genre from Letting Go, his first novel, to Nemesis, his last; “Experience” revisits an important debate in American letters by discussing how the subjective perception of art and history is depicted in Portnoy's Complaint and American Pastoral; “Life as Literature” deals with the relationship between art and real life (and therefore, to some extent, ethics) as it is explored in The Counterlife, Deception and The Humbling; “The Author” brings to light the implications of a novel such as The Ghost Writer in the context of the “death-of-the-author” debate; “The Unconscious” establishes connections between Operation Shylock and The Plot against America by virtue of their treatment of politics and psychoanalysis; and the final chapter, “The Canon,” describes the ironical representation of the canon wars of the 1990s given by Roth in The Human Stain.
These analyses are carried out by way of brilliant and revealing close readings of passages in the novels – many of which are informed by a comparison between the final texts and the drafts included in the Philip Roth Papers, which Hayes had the opportunity to consult at the Library of Congress. Hayes's genetic criticism of The Ghost Writer, for example, allows him to infer conclusions about authorial intentions and preoccupations, this critical approach being perfectly coherent with his (and Roth's) implicit critique of the Barthesian death of the author. It is precisely this constant movement back and forth between different phases of Roth's career that enables Hayes to write such a nuanced and complex portrait of this author and the evolution of his poetics. Indeed, this book demonstrates how Roth has always maintained a balanced perspective on the issue of the value of literature – one that does not set for any of the schools of thought taken into consideration, and yet gains critical insights from them all.
