From Heinrich Wölfflin's epochal Renaissance und Barock (1888) onward, the baroque style has been linked to notions of becoming, dynamism, and change, as well as to a sense of theatricality. Thus, an edited volume on the relationship between performance and the arts of baroque Rome may seem a rather predictable prospect. The foregrounding of performativity in the title of Peter Gillgren and Mårten Snickare's collection, however, immediately suggests that their project has ambitions beyond the affirmation of scholarly consensus. Though David Carrier remarks in his postscript that “John Austin's ordinary language philosophy is the most unlikely source imaginable for a theory of Baroque visual art” (220), Gillgren and Snickare's volume strives to apply Austin's concepts and those of his followers not only to visual art narrowly defined, but also to theatre, architecture, music, and sacred and secular ritual. As much for its ability to bring together such a wide range of material as for the new light it sheds on the baroque, the volume's emphasis on performativity proves highly productive. The attractive resulting publication, inspired by a 2006 workshop at the Swedish Institute in Rome, should appeal to scholars and teachers in a range of fields as diverse as those it covers.
In their introduction, Gillgren and Snickare note that they “have deliberately chosen not to fix the meaning of [their] conceptual tools, performance and performativity” (10, original emphasis), hoping that their book will instead explore the “fruitful plurality of the concepts” (10). The volume's contributors appeal to many definitions of the terms; Peter Burke treats them almost as synonyms, whereas Margaretha Rossholm Lagerlöf distinguishes sharply between performance, which she associates with “[t]he spectacle of a drama actualized on stage” (185), and performativity, which she understands in terms of speech-acts that cause “real changes (of behaviour, state of affairs and belief)” (186). All the selected essays, however, view baroque performativity as a process in which the artwork or performer shapes a viewer's identity and is reshaped in turn by the viewer's gaze.
The collection begins with a series of essays that examine the broad social implications of such performative exchanges. Burke sets the scene for the contributions that follow by considering the power of performance both as tool and as metaphor in baroque Rome. The “‘performative turn’” (15) in contemporary historical studies, he suggests, was presaged by such a turn in the early modern eternal city. Martin Olin's essay, “Diplomatic Performances and the Applied Arts in Seventeenth-Century Europe,” offers strong examples of this turn, considering how both the behavior of high-ranking diplomats and the settings in which they accomplished their missions—from resplendent coaches to carefully selected rooms in palazzi—were highly coded to affirm and create political identities. In this performative culture, Olin argues, “the outward signs of rank and the acceptance by others of a claim to precedence . . . was, at least to some extent, what constituted rank” (26, original emphasis). This claim is convincingly supported by Camilla Kandare's analysis of the “CorpoReality” of Queen Christina of Sweden, especially as she appeared in Rome after her abdication from the Swedish throne. Kandare shows how Christina's active and often unconventional use of her own body worked to assert her rank and to manage her unstable place in Roman society. Touching upon performance theory, dance history, gender theory, and religious ritual, among other topics, Kandare's essay offers a model of interdisciplinary inquiry that will engage anyone interested in the nuances of performative identity formation.
For scholars of theatre and performance, the book's second part, “Performances and Audiences,” will be a particular attraction. Erika Fischer-Lichte's essay, “Transforming Spectators into Viri Perculsi,” begins Part II by showing how many aspects of baroque theatre—from machinery and lighting to acting and singing—created powerful performative effects that often contradicted the overt lessons of plays and operas. Even as these works' texts instructed spectators to restrain their passions, the phenomenological experience of theatre proved affectively overwhelming, moving spectators to extreme demonstrations of emotion. Lars Berglund finds similar contradictions at work in the performance of baroque sacred music, particularly in the Jesuit churches of Rome. Here, exquisite scores and their singers (especially the famed castrati) could serve either to ravish the listeners' souls into an encounter with the divine or to snare them in the toils of profane pleasure. If such works performed and shaped their own audiences, these authors demonstrate how multivalent and complex were the identities thus produced.
Part III, “Performativity and Interpretation,” effectively demonstrates that spectators performed and shaped the artworks they saw as well as vice versa. Genevieve Warwick reads Caravaggio's paintings of sensual young men as “tableaux remaining from a lost drama of aristocratic reflection on love” (147); Margaretha Rossholm Lagerlöf shows how Bernini's Ecstasy of Saint Teresa interacts with its spectator in situ to display “existential conditions of utmost risks and promises” (189); Giovanni Careri rethinks the viewer's journey through the Sistine Chapel in terms of his or her relationship to the judging of Christ's gestures of blessing and condemnation. In all of these essays, the work's interaction with its audience emerges, as Gillgren puts it in his excellent essay on Barocci's Visitation, as “something that reaches out and takes hold both of the observer and the observed” (161).
One might say something similar of Gillgren and Snickare's book as a whole. Lavishly illustrated with well-produced images, it draws its reader into the visual world of the Roman baroque and invites a revision of many of that world's most familiar works. As in any edited collection, the quality of writing is somewhat variable; and some essays will be of less interest than others to students of theatre and performance. Nevertheless, anyone studying or teaching the baroque will enjoy and be stimulated by the volume, which outlines fruitful new directions for interdisciplinary study of the baroque.
