This volume is the second of four thematic monographs to emerge from the Trans-SAHARA research project headed by David Mattingly and funded by the European Research Council.Footnote 1 This research builds in turn on the Desert Migrations Project (2007–11) and the Fazzan Project (1997–2002). The concept is both elegantly simple and ambitiously broad: to examine the vast Sahara Desert as a common space and connector for all the people living within or around it. The project explores the sand sea of the Sahara as a zone of connectivity, like the Mediterranean Sea. The organization of the volume puts the Sahara in the center. Of the 17 chapters, 9 present burial data from Trans-Saharan regions, opening with Garamantian sites in the center of the desert, then moving counterclockwise around the region. Three chapters on isotopic analysis of skeletons, three on linguistics, and the meaty introduction and conclusion by the editors round out the volume.
Although few individuals will be familiar with all the regions discussed here, big ideas in the book will stimulate thought and testing in many areas. I begin with a tour of the regions covered in the book, then draw attention to the Saharan burial koine, the approaches to mobility, and the use of linguistic evidence.
Touring the sand sea
Just enumerating the regions covered in the book with a rough sketch of each divulges the panoptic view. Two different teams present work at Garamantian sites. D. Mattingly, M. Sterry, and N. Ray offer burial evidence from the Wadi al-Ajal, the prosperous oasis at the heart of the Garamantian kingdom (Chapter 2). They present a distribution and typology of tomb types and show how these diversified, monumentalized, and drew in imported goods and materials during the height of Garamantian sway, in the Classic Garamantian period, ca. 1–300 CE. Moreover, their projects have excavated 134 graves (69), providing focused information that complements the broader mapping of grave distribution for ca. 11,000 tombs (54).
M. C. Gatto, L. Mori, and A. Zerboni bring us to the region of Wadi Tanzzuft/Tadrart Akakus, southwest of Jarma, asking what relationship the inhabitants of this region had with the Garamantians, as seen through material culture and entanglement theory (Chapter 3). They concentrate on the necropolis of Fewet, where they have recorded 1,329 funerary structures, dug 24, and found the remains of 33 individuals (112). For the most part, the burials of this region are similar to Garamantian ones but have a more limited repertoire and are less wealthy than those of Jarma and the Wadi al-Ajal (128–29). In the Wadi Tanzzuft, Roman imports only appear in a few wealthy graves located near caravan routes, such as a large Garamantian-style tumulus at In-Aghelachem (112, 128). They conclude that as a “peripheral part of this [Garamantian] polity” the Wadi Tanzzuft/Akakus region retained more traditional elements and was not as much influenced by trade and competition with the outside as was the Garamantian capital. There are two chapters on stable isotope analysis from Garamantian sites (Chapters 4 and 5; see below).
The tour of the edges of the Sahara begins at the east with D. N. Edwards's discussion of the Middle Nile, a region he describes as “an ‘extended, linear’ oasis” (197) with a long history of interaction between settlements and pastoralists. He cautions that rich graves should not automatically be interpreted as evidence for hierarchy and social elites without further evidence, and makes suggestions for recognizing “the clearly widespread … subject and unfree populations, variously defined” (202–3). Given the long tradition of cemetery archaeology in this region, E. argues that archaeologists do not need to acquire more data so much as to aim new kinds of inquiry at the data they have. A chapter on stable isotope analysis enriches the discussion on this region (Chapter 7; see below).
The volume moves next to lands bordering the Mediterranean. Numidia is another region with a rich tradition of funerary archaeology (including work at autochthonous sites), as exemplified in the work of G. Camps.Footnote 2 J. Sanmartí et al. provide a funerary typology based on formal characteristics such as the presence or absence of an architectural monument. They note that cemeteries do not concentrate around settlements so much as they do in most Mediterranean cultures, and propose that the distribution patterns reflect tribal groupings instead (261). They discuss primary and secondary burials, possible evidence for excarnation (262), artefacts, and rituals. The striking degree of diversity and complexity of the funerary practices documented in Numidian territory is similar to that of the Garamantian homelands (see discussion, 529). In Roman and Late Roman times, some autochthonous funerary monuments continued in use (275–76), a phenomenon meriting further study.
E. Papi presents tombs of the first millennium BCE in northwest Morocco, emphasizing the importance of local and African traditions (Chapter 9). He focuses particularly on the well-recorded cemeteries at Aïn Dahlia Kébira (84 graves) and Djebila 1 (107 graves). These cemeteries use rectangular cists and there are usually local grave goods within them. Both the rectangularity and the presence of grave goods reflect regional practices that are different from the broad Saharan practices. There are also round tumuli in the area (289–93).
Y. Bokbot addresses protohistoric funerary archaeology in the Moroccan pre-Sahara, discussing a series of tumulus cemeteries (Chapter 10). This chapter combines detailed results from excavations of individual tombs with mapping of cemeteries in a broader landscape. The tumulus cemeteries are often located close to metal deposits (333). B. emphasizes the role of the Tafilalat, Wadi Draa, and Wadi Noun as major travel axes and “intermediaries between northern Morocco and the Sahara during protohistory” (333). He laments how little radiocarbon dating has been done on Saharan sites and provides a valuable list of examples for Moroccan tumuli (333).
For Western Sahara, J. Clarke and N. Brooks have developed a typology of 32 types of tombs, many of which have parallels in the western and central parts of the Sahara (Chapter 11). They argue that some features on the monuments (such as use of contrasting colors [362] in the monument design or orienting monuments to landscape features) do not correspond well with Saharan traditions and may be linked instead to “Atlantic Europe” (363, 366).
The section on “Looking south” turns to Sub-Saharan Africa. Here (spoiler alert) most aspects of burial traditions are quite different from the commonalities found in much of the rest of the Trans-Sahara region (531). S. Magnavita presents burial and society at Kissi in the eastern Niger bend (Burkina Faso), a site occupied from the 3rd c. BCE to the 12th c. CE (Chapter 12). Cemetery sites were placed close to living areas. Narrow stone stelae marked some graves and appeared sometimes to be reused, but many graves were without a marker. Most graves included some sort of weapons or jewelry worn on the body, but there were no vessels and there did not appear to be food offerings. Cadavers were wrapped in textiles and mats.
The southern Lake Chad basin is the other Sub-Saharan zone investigated in the volume (S. MacEachern, Chapter 13). The three millennia covered in the chapter (1500 BCE–1500 CE) include a period of environmental change as Lake Chad shrank in size (800 BCE–300 CE), changing subsistence strategies and access to the area by outside traders or raiders. There are several different culture groups in the area, with different burial traditions that mostly also differ from Saharan traditions. Pot graves in the Sao region are an example (412–14). The occasional appearance of flexed skeletons and the use of matting to wrap bodies constitute a slender link with Saharan traditions, along with sporadic presence of goods that come from the Sahara. Artifactual evidence for contact with the Sahara during the Garamantian period (1000 BCE–700 CE) is quite slight, however (407, 417). It is possible that slaves were traded in return; in medieval times and later, settlements in the southern Lake Chad basin were frequently raided for slaves (407).
In short, the panoptic view provided in these nine chapters is breathtaking and brings a Roman archaeologist to unfamiliar lands and new questions. Notwithstanding the wide range in geographic regions and archaeological traditions encompassed by the book, however, the chapters do achieve a broad uniformity in that authors follow an assigned rubric of topics and address burials, migration, and identity for their region. Each chapter also provides a typology of grave types. This consistency of approach makes the chapters easier to compare, even in the face of significant unevenness of data (raw quantity, methods, preservation issues, cultural differences, etc.). Some organizers might have found that inconsistency insurmountable, but pushing these datasets together creates a current baseline of information over a wide area. The editors allow for contradictory opinions between authors and in the concluding section they themselves sometimes offer interpretations different from those found in the chapters. The impressive geographical range is matched by a vast methodological range that draws on archaeological survey and excavation, isotopic analysis, and linguistics.
A suite of Saharan burial practices
An extremely valuable outcome from the common rubric followed in each chapter is that the editors are able to propose a series of funerary practices stemming from Saharan cultural traditions, including circular monuments, tightly flexed bodies laid on the side, use of red ochre (on body, stele, or tomb), extra attention to the east side of the monument, and rarity of grave goods (see 528 for the full list). Although others have observed some of these features in the past,Footnote 3 the package of information in this volume forcefully confirms these patterns. With such a broad array of sites under review, one can see the wide catchment of Saharan traits, but also how regional practices contribute (for instance, in Morocco and Western Sahara). In the Numidian burial typology, diversity and complexity are the main constants (275), a situation reflecting interaction with multiple cultural traditions and a society developing increased internal hierarchy (529). Likewise, during the Classic Garamantian period, increased wealth and social stratification led to wealthier monumental tombs in new styles, new types of graves, and imported grave goods and materials in some of the wealthiest tombs. Comprehending a Saharan koine enables us to see the uniqueness of these phases better.
Not all regions participated as strongly in the Saharan pattern. For the most part, influence from Egypt to the north was more evident than influence from the Sahara to the west for Nubia (530). The two sub-Saharan regions participate very little in the Saharan koine (531). It is useful to demonstrate differences as well as commonalities.
Exploring mobility
The emphasis on migration in the title and the rubric of common topics for each chapter keeps authors attentive for ways to identify migration in many formats, including seasonal (transhumance), temporary (trade), permanent (settlement), and non-voluntary (slavery). Slavery and trafficking are discussed frequently. Throughout, contributors are alert for evidence that could point to the presence of enslaved people or the influence of the slave trade, thinking particularly of traffic in enslaved people from Sub-Saharan regions toward the Mediterranean, as is well attested in Medieval times and later. D. Edwards points out that the Classical term “Nubian” does not so much describe an ethnicity but acts as a “generic (external) categorisation, designating peripheral and potentially enslavable peoples” (201). In the southern Lake Chad basin, the presence of fortified sites starting about 500 BCE must reflect raiding, possibly including enslavement (417). Traditions of handmade pottery with rouletted decoration (found in Jarma and elsewhere in the Trans-Saharan region) resemble Sub-Saharan practices and could have traveled because of the skills of enslaved people (91, 419; unfortunately, there are no illustrations of this type of pot).
How visible are enslaved people and slavery in the archaeological record, including graves? Enslaved people quite probably did not have the freedom or materials to bury one another with the practices of their homelands, particularly when those practices were different from the Saharan koine, as in the southern Lake Chad basin (419). It is probable that there was a significant enslaved population at Garamantian sites, especially Jarma, during the Classic Garamantian period; perhaps dense cemeteries of shaft graves result from burials of the enslaved (60, 542). This tomb type only emerged at the apex of Garamantian power and it is also one of the lowest-status grave types in that area. In the Wadi al-Ajal, there was a female skeleton with a lip-plug and Sub-Saharan physiognomy (91, 155).Footnote 4 Evidently, this woman was an outsider; was she also enslaved?
A suite of strong chapters adds isotopic analysis to examination of skeletal remains and tomb types for Fazzan and the Nile. Studies of the stable isotopes preserved in human remains are a particularly tantalizing avenue for identifying individuals who grew up in a different environment from their place of burial. Isotopic evidence is strongest when integrated with osteological and archaeological data from the grave and the site (540). The different studies all used a different suite of tests, so the data are not completely comparable, but the package of results within the book comprises significant new data for the region.Footnote 5
Two chapters examine skeletal data and isotopic evidence in the Garamantian center of power (the Wadi al-Ajal, where Jarma was located) and in a smaller, outlying location (Fewet). R. K. Power et al. examine skeletal features and isotopic samples from Garamantian cemeteries (Chapter 4). Sampling the carbon and oxygen isotopes of 63 teeth, they found 19 that were quite different from the rest of the population, indicating that these people spent their childhood (when teeth form) in a different environment from the one in which they died (145). Overall, they conclude that “Garamantian society included individuals of diverse geographical origin” (155).
Studying skeletons from Fewet, an outlying Garamantian site, F. Ricci et al. (Chapter 5) point to greater diversity of metric features and strontium readings on female skeletons as opposed to male ones (168, 172). Moreover, certain metric features on skeletons may point to women originating further south in Africa. This may reflect endogamy (168), with women having more mobility in marriage, though it could also reflect enslavement. They conclude that Fewet was a “rather homogeneous group” with some “gene-flow” from the south (183). In spite of the small sample size, features such as the absence of older adults, short stature, and other indicators of malnutrition create an enduring impression that life at ancient Fewet was hard in every way.
M. R. Buzon et al. investigate Egyptian and Nubian interaction through skeletal remains from Tombos and other sites in the Nile valley (Chapter 7). This study has the benefit of comparatively large sample sizes: they tested levels of oxygen isotopes in teeth from 101 samples from several sites in the valley (234, table 7.1) and evaluated strontium isotopes in 49 samples from two time periods (235–36; table 7.4). Combining archaeological and isotopic data from the Nubian site of Tombos on the third cataract of the Nile (in modern Sudan), they found that all the graves with higher-than-normal strontium readings used Egyptian rites (240). There were also 31 graves where the strontium levels matched the local strontium levels but used Egyptian grave rituals; they may have been the children of Egyptian colonists, or Nubians who adopted Egyptian burial practices (240).
Linguistic evidence and broad interpretations
Three chapters at the end of the volume bring in linguistic evidence as a tool. Prioritizing different linguistic methods, two eminent scholars offer differing reconstructions of how and when Berber languages spread across the Trans-Saharan region. R. Blench proposes that Berber may have spread with pastoralists around 6000 BCE and that its “low internal diversity” may be the result of an important episode of “language-levelling” around 100–200 CE (Chapter 14; 31, 456). B. looks at the substrate lexicon of words related to subsistence strategies and animals and also at loan-words from Punic and Latin. C. Ehret argues for an important expansion of Berber languages with proto-Amazigh around 1000 BCE (Chapter 15; 31, 493). He proposes approximate dates for changes in the family of languages based on the fact that “the patterns of cognate loss over the long term among a group of equidistantly related languages tend to a normal distribution” (466). Both chapters comprise technical and detailed arguments; comparing them is difficult for an outsider.
In the final chapter of the linguistic section, E. Fentress seeks archaeological and genetic correlates for the linguistic chronology proposed by Ehret (Chapter 16). She points to evidence for three broad “pulses” of cultural packages from east to west: the first around 1000 BCE (with oasis settlements and spread of rock art of horses and pastoral animals); the rising power of the Garamantians from 500 BCE on; and widespread invasions over Rome's desert frontier shortly before the Vandal invasion of 429 CE.Footnote 6 Ancient textual sources refer to the Late Antique invasions, and Saharan-style tombs are found on top of Roman ruins. These three waves of expansion correspond quite well with Ehret's proposed dates for broad language spreads. Reading this chapter as an archaeologist, I found the archaeological components very convincing, but it is more difficult to assess the linguistic arguments.
Broad themes for Roman archaeologists and historians
This book is a standout accomplishment in integrating far-flung data. Imposing a set rubric of topics for each region makes the data more comparable and opens avenues for further research. Indeed, most of the authors propose desirable directions for research within their chapters. The conclusion puts a new perspective on widely separated sites by emphasizing possible unities and connections. Here the authors refine the suite of Saharan burial traits and propose a timeline of interactions, changes, and migrations around the Sahara. They stress the need to collect more radiocarbon dates and do more isotopic analysis on skeletons at cemetery sites, and this book already acts as a valuable collection of existing data in one place (see “radiocarbon/AMS dating” and “isotopic analysis” in the index).
For Roman archaeologists and historians this book provides a valuable broad perspective on the desert world beside the Roman frontier.Footnote 7 The coherent suite of Saharan traits is a good tool to think with and opens deeper levels of interpretation for burial archaeology. The desert-focused study of mobility and identity opens new ways to envisage experiences and events on the desert frontier, and the timeline of migrations proposed by Fentress and in the last chapter are particularly useful.
Researchers write a book and interpret results in a particular intellectual climate or historical circumstance. The outbreak of civil war in Libya in 2011 interrupted research at Garamantian sites (139). There are humanitarian crises in several other areas covered in the volume (including Chapters 11–13). Readers read a book in a particular historic moment as well, in my case during the cessation of mobility during the COVID-19 pandemic and the galvanizing protests under the banner of Black Lives Matter in the summer of 2020. This book investigates a vast scale of past mobility and puts ancient Black lives at its heart.
