What happens when scientists conduct research in dangerous, unpredictable places? Do extreme conditions leave their mark on the knowledge produced? Is this knowledge universal? Continuing the ‘spatial turn’ in science studies, Philip W. Clements, a historian at California State University, marshals the dramatic events of the 1963 American Mount Everest Expedition (AMEE) into a convincing case study of the power of place in the planning, practice and products of science.
Occurring a decade after the famous first summit by Tenzing Norgay and Edmund Hillary in 1953, the AMEE will be of particular interest to historians of science because of the significant research programme attached to the expedition, and the harrowing attempts to carry out this work in one of the most remote and hazardous field sites imaginable. AMEE's science team was selected by expedition leader Norman Dyhrenfurth, and included biophysicist Will Siri, glaciologist Maynard M. Miller, sociologist Richard Emerson, psychologist James Lester and another glaciologist, Barry Bishop, who also worked as assistant photo editor for expedition funders National Geographic. Only Bishop expected to be part of a summit team, but the other scientists still planned weeks of work at freezing low-pressure altitudes well above 20,000 feet.
As historian Vanessa Heggie points out in Higher and Colder: A History of Extreme Physiology and Exploration (2019, p. 4), Clements’s monograph is ‘the first book-length study of a single high-altitude expedition focusing on its relevance to the history of science and environmental history’. To Heggie's point, historians of science and scholars in science and technology studies (STS) have tended to overlook field science in favour of laboratory-centred studies. Heggie challenges this simplistic binary demarking sterile, hypercontrolled laboratories from distant, less domesticated field sites, which highlights the need for exactly this type of focused, in-depth case study of how science works in the wild.
Charting a new route up the archetypical mountaineering story, Clements offers the term ‘locale’ to describe the specific combination of physical and cultural attributes of any given place that bear on the work of scientists. For Clements it's not only the where, but also the when and why that give places unique agency in science. So when he analyses the locale AMEE scientists encountered on Everest, he includes the thin air, frigid temperatures and treacherous terrain, but also cultural understandings of the Himalaya, and the Cold War geopolitical urgency framing the mission. Clements's main objective is to sink an ice axe into the widespread view of scientific knowledge as universal and placeless, and this extreme episode provides a trove of empirical examples of the mechanisms – the exact moments of causation – where an uncontrollable locale's specificity comes to matter.
Clements begins the book by defining locale and offering a contextualizing overview of European mountaineering with a focus on mountain science going back to Irish physicist John Tyndall's pioneering studies of glaciers in the Alps starting in the mid-1850s, before covering the twentieth-century shift in focus to the Himalaya. Next, he introduces Dyhrenfurth and the origins of the AMEE, before turning to three of the expedition's scientists, Emerson, Lester and Siri, to show how their preconceptions of Everest's extremity – or ‘environmental imaginary’ – shaped their research programmes before they even departed. For instance, to pre-empt sceptics predicting that harsh conditions would put science and climbing objectives in conflict, social scientists Emerson and Lester developed a clever approach to bring these two facets into alignment. For their studies of stress in small-group dynamics, they promoted ‘reality testing’, collecting data in unsimulated ‘real’ situations as opposed to contrived groups and problems in laboratories, so the more their subjects focused on climbing, the better.
The next chapter recounts how Dyhrenfurth's uphill battle to secure interest and funding in Kennedy's Washington, DC only succeeded after he placed Everest at the centre of America's Cold War concerns. After initially attempting to sell potential backers on the older image of Everest as a theatre for athleticism and national prestige, Dyhrenfurth hit on the idea to rebrand the mountain as a Cold War proving ground for science and technology, as well as for human performance in extreme environments. Dyhrenfurth explicitly linked Everest – which had just been summited in 1960 by a team of Chinese climbers looking to shore up claims to Tibet – to other newly strategic extreme environments including the deep seas, polar regions and especially outer space. Clements highlights the many parallels Dyhrenfurth drew between his expedition team and America's newest paragons of bravery, masculinity and mastery of marginal conditions, NASA's Project Mercury astronauts.
Once on the mountain, Clements follows the mixed fortunes of the scientific and climbing teams as they finally face the punishing physical realities of Everest. Even with the spotlight on scientists, readers will still find plenty of the life-and-death drama they have come to expect from the mountaineering genre, and Clements proves skilful at shifting between building narrative tension and deploying cogent scholarly analysis. Most valuably, he closely examines instances when science was severely impeded or failed altogether. In these moments when unforeseen circumstances – including but certainly not limited to the volatile environment – forced researchers to deviate from standardized practices and disciplinary norms, ‘instruments froze; mundane routines were always laborious, and often impossible; men and material scattered across the mountainside; researchers were injured … precise measurements became imperfect, [and] detached objectivity dwindled’ (xvi).
Situated at the nexus of history of science, science studies, environmental history, and history of the Cold War, Science in an Extreme Environment joins the range of important mountain studies including John B. West's classics Everest: The Testing Place (1985) and High Life: A History of High-Altitude Physiology and Medicine (1998), as well as Robert MacFarlane's Mountains of the Mind: Adventures in Reaching the Summit (2004) and Heggie's previously mentioned work Higher and Colder (2019). Clements's pairing of a straightforward yet important argument about place and epistemology with a compelling mountain saga replete with triumphs and tragedies (no spoilers here!) makes this an easy book to recommend to scholars in these areas and for relevant graduate seminars, perhaps paired with historical geographer Matthew Farish's The Contours of America's Cold War (2010), or anthropologist of science Valerie Olson's Into the Extreme: U.S. Environmental Systems and Politics beyond Earth (2019).
