Karen Cox is hardly the first scholar to note that the section of continental North America conventionally referred to as “the South” is as much a product of imagination and performance as of geography, history and material circumstance. Her smart new book is a valuable addition to that literature, not least for reminding us how much notions of “southern-ness” and “southern identity” have been the creation of individuals and organizations, and of social, political and economic forces, located far beyond the region itself. Without neglecting the importance of indigenous southern artists, writers and performers, or of the southern tourist boards and chambers of commerce who worked hard to maximize the commercial benefits of popular fascination with their region, Cox introduces us to a wide range of non-southern actors and institutions that helped to create a potent southern imaginary: a set of images, stereotypes, understandings and misunderstandings about the region that became ubiquitous in American popular culture and consciousness during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. We encounter Tin Pan Alley songwriters Jack Yellen, George Gershwin and Irving Berlin, Jewish immigrants all, and their publishers, including Leo Feist and M. Witmark & Sons, extending the southern-themed traditions of minstrelsy and “coon songs” into the new age of recordings, radio and, eventually, talking pictures; we find publishing houses such as Macmillan in New York and J. B. Lippincott of Philadelphia promoting and profiting from best-selling popular southern literature by Thomas Nelson Page, Joel Chandler Harris, Thomas Dixon and Margaret Mitchell; we find northern-based advertising agencies such as J. Walter Thompson and Benton & Bowles working with network radio executives to ensure that southern acts like the Boswell Sisters and comedienne Judy Conova, and shows like the Maxwell House-sponsored Show Boat and the Grand Ol’ Opry, delivered southern entertainment and Dixie-drenched sales pitches to American homes; and we find Hollywood filmmakers producing a steady stream of successful “Deep South” movies long before the triumph of Gone With the Wind.
Much of the book focusses on describing the kinds of southern images that saturated national popular culture during a period when mass culture and the mass media became significantly more mass. Not surprisingly, perhaps, Cox finds that sentimental and romantic motifs, replete with images of an organic, often rural and always stable southern society, with fixed and intelligible gender and racial hierarchies that privileged whites, particularly white men, dominated much of the southern-inflected music, advertising, radio broadcasts, film and literature of the period. Similar “moonlight and magnolia” preoccupations with a genteel Old South, conveniently emptied of the brutality of slavery by clichéd depictions of happy-go-lucky blacks and their kindly masters and mistresses, also informed the tourist drives which, along with related initiatives to improve rail and road links to and within the region, brought increasing numbers of visitors to a region that most Americans already thought they knew thanks to its representation in popular culture.
But to her credit, Cox moves beyond merely identifying the main characteristics of this southern imaginary to try to explain why dreams of a bucolic South should be so potent at a moment when the South was itself in the midst of a clearly discernible, if uneven, process of modernization. Many Americans, she argues, were deeply unsettled by the flux and uncertainties of modern, increasingly urban, secular living and its perceived threats to traditional moral, religious, gender and racial codes. For many people, irrespective of region, the performed pastoral vernacular South offered a welcome, comforting glimpse of a certitude, orderliness, and authenticity which they found increasingly elusive in the modern world. While she might have paid even more attention to how and why particular groups of Americans were attracted to – or occasionally repelled by – these expressions of southern-ness, Cox's generalizations seem sound. A report of J. Walter Thompson indicating that an advertising campaign which stressed the southern provenance of Aunt Jemima's venerable old pancake flour recipe worked best among women in cities of 100,000 or more supports Cox's contention that southern nostalgia worked by counterposing ideas of regional authenticity and rootedness against the prefabricated, mass-produced, rapidly changing world of modern, urban-based consumer culture.
Dreaming of Dixie is a relatively short book. Consequently, there are places where Cox is necessarily more suggestive than definitive and where she alights upon promising avenues for future research without having scope to explore them fully. For example, there are tantalizing hints that the southern imaginary which captivated Americans also had an international currency: this was undoubtedly true and several non-Americans could have been added to the list of non-southerners who helped to create prevailing understandings of the South, among them Brits such as Art Satherley, who was instrumental in recording, classifying and selling southern country and blues music, and James Whale, who directed the iconic film version of Show Boat in 1936. And while we get good coverage of how African Americans, through organizations such as the NAACP, often challenged the demeaning portrayals of black life that punctuated much of this southern fare, more might have been said about how white New South boosters, eager to dispel stereotypes of the region's perennial backwardness, responded to the recurring deployment of hillbilly stereotypes. These minor caveats aside, Cox has written a thoughtful, engaging, clearly argued and eminently assignable book which treats popular culture seriously as a means to interrogate major issues in southern, indeed American, social history in the decades before the Second World War.
