In the last twenty-five years, our understanding of the medieval European economy has altered greatly. Older versions of the medieval economy portrayed it as largely subsistence-based, dominated by a peasantry bent on self-reproduction, reluctant to involve itself with the risks of the marketplace, and subordinate to a ruling elite that largely supported itself through politically based, extra-economic means of extracting surplus from its peasants. This picture has been replaced by one in which the market and trade are seen as vitally important, with entrepreneurship of one sort or another flourishing at all levels of society. One of the most important contributions to this rethinking of the medieval economy was R. H. Britnell's The Commercialisation of English Society, 1000–1500 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993).
The essays in this festschrift can be read as reflections on the insights offered by Richard Britnell on the role of commerce in medieval England. John Hatcher argues that efforts to construct indices of real wages for the last seven hundred years have, at least for the medieval and early modern period, not accurately reflected either the incomes of wage laborers or the population at large. One result of this misreading of the data has been a great exaggeration of the standard of living in England in the century after the advent of the Black Death. John Langdon, in a study of building wages at the royal complex at Old Woodstock in Oxfordshire, claims that the data from this source can be used to measure varying levels of overall employment in the local economy. Two essays deal with the response of town authorities to periods of food shortage. Derek Keene maps the various ways in which London responded to three major periods of famine, in 1257–1260, 1315–1317, and 1438–1440. John Lee argues that during a grain shortage in 1520, the town authorities of Coventry sought to reassure the inhabitants that they were restricting the morally unacceptable behavior of hoarding and thus promoting social order by conducting a census of the town's inhabitants and available grain stores.
As Britnell has demonstrated, crucial to the development of a market economy in medieval England was the provision of a system of rules that guaranteed contracts and that provided national standards and common expectations about price, quality, weights, and measures. Several of the essays in this volume turn on this issue. James Masschaele discusses the role of the public charter in guaranteeing transactions, arguing that the integrity and reliability of these written instruments relied to a large extent on how they were integrated with other, non-written, social and legal practices. James Davis emphasizes that this provision of standards and common expectations was a multifaceted enterprise influenced by the king, government officials, town authorities, and the church. He illustrates this by showing how a fifteenth-century collection of common rules on marketing known as the “Statute of Winchester,” that probably originated in the royal household, found its way into the records of various towns. Mark Bailey addresses the question of the extent to which the small boroughs of medieval England, subject to nonroyal lordship and thus lacking formal corporate status, were able to govern themselves. He argues that the inhabitants of these were able to find various effective, informal ways in which to manage their affairs and, increasingly in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, secured formal control by means of leasing their towns from their lords. Christine M. Newman furthers the discussion of these mesne boroughs by examining the development of three boroughs granted charters by the Bishop of Durham.
If the market played a larger role in medieval people's lives than we thought a generation or two, the question of how people tried to take advantage of its opportunities arises. Three of the essays in this volume come at this question from different angles. Peter L. Larson looks at how peasants responded to the greater availability of land in fifteenth-century Durham. Although some individuals acquired larger holdings, there were still several important social mechanisms that inhibited accumulation of land. Simultaneously some communities increased their autonomy vis-à-vis their lords by leasing demesnes collectively. Maryanne Kowaleski provides an interesting article on the shipmaster, a figure who, although a salaried working man, also traded in his own right and exercised command over men and valuable cargo and ships. Examining entrepreneurship of a rather different kind, Martha Carlin provides an edition and translation of advice, taken from a thirteenth-century collection of model documents dealing with law and administration, on how a reeve, bailiff, or shepherd could embezzle from or defraud his master. She suggests that such embezzlement might have been significant enough to have an important impact on manorial revenues.
The volume concludes with an essay by Chris Dyer on the trade in luxury goods. Dyer argues that historians have tended to overemphasize the importance of the demand for luxury goods in the medieval economy. He argues instead that the commercial life of medieval Europe was based on a solid foundation of exchange of ordinary goods among a broad swath of the population. This is a fitting note on which to end a volume dedicated to a scholar whose work has demonstrated how “commercialization permeated the whole of medieval society” (p. 238).
