Is it Just Distance that Separates Boston from Savannah? The Historical Role of Education in Economic Growth
This study uses United States county-level data to assess the relative importance of institutions and human capital accumulation on economic growth. Specifically, I exploit the marked range in productivity levels as well as the variation in local government expenditures in developing public secondary school education in 1910, the start of the United States secondary school movement. Nonetheless, I argue that public education decisions are endogenous to a region's factor endowments—local features, such as climatic conditions and natural resources. In turn, these factor endowments gave rise to the extent to which a region developed an agricultural economy with extreme earnings inequality, a relatively less democratic political institution, smaller government expenditures, and a larger illiteracy rate. The intergenerational nature of human capital transfers implies that historical differences in education are persistent. Accordingly, I use factor endowments throughout the United States to instrument for the endogenous relationship between human capital and growth.
Jeffrey Greenbaum, University of California, Berkeley
Old Habits Die Hard (Sometimes): What Can Département Heterogeneity Tells Us about the French Fertility Decline?
This paper makes a contribution to the fertility decline debate by providing a quantitative analysis of factors explaining different levels of fertility within France. I collected and put together a panel of département level data for the last quarter of the nineteenth century (quinquennial data 1876–1896) and apply a random effects model to study the correlates of fertility. Preliminary results confirm the importance of some of the forces suggested by standard fertility choice models. Nevertheless, certain noneconomic factors (such as secularization) for which I provide new measurements also appear to play a considerable role in explaining the variation across département.
Tommy E. Murphy, Nuffield College, University of Oxford
Mothers, Wives and Workers: The Changing Roles of American Women at the Turn of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries
This paper seeks to investigate, both theoretically and empirically, the interconnections between marriage, fertility, and labor market decisions of American women at the turn of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Whereas fertility kept falling throughout the period, the marriage rate first declined, then in 1890s picked up again. At the same time, American women were a growing presence on the labor market: first as singles, then, after 1900, increasingly as married persons also. Single women's labor force participation is viewed as the prime cause. It changed women's bargaining position first on the marriage market (encouraging a delay in marriage and consequently a decline in fertility through postponement of child bearing), then inside marriage (leading to an increase in married women's labor force participation and a continued decline in fertility through time reallocation).
Tomas Cvrcek, Vanderbilt University
The Populists Had a Point
Though the late nineteenth century is considered by many to be a period when financial institutions rapidly expanded throughout the U.S. economic landscape, farmers of the day seem to have been unimpressed, believing that the financial sector was not performing nearly as well for them as for others. Whether addressing productivity (crop yields) of the Ohio agriculture sector or prevalence (acres planted), this paper finds the presence of banks at this time does not appear to have lent the helping hand we so often associate with financial intermediaries. Rather than lead activity in agriculture, we find evidence to suggest banks actually followed that activity. We do, however, find a causal relationship running from banks to a measure of manufacturing output per capita and capital inputs per capita in the industrial sector over the same period (1880–1900). Perhaps the grass really was greener on the industrial side of the fence.
Tamara L. Trafton, Vanderbilt University
Industrialization and Language Shift in India in the Mid-Twentieth Century
This paper explores the relationship between industrialization and the learning of new languages by speakers of minority mother tongues. A profound linguistic consolidation has been occurring worldwide during the past several hundred years. A small number of languages, such as Spanish, English, and Bengali, have increased their population share at the expense of others. I hypothesize that industrialization is an important driver of this process. Workers in industrial occupations must communicate with each other to access many scale economies, providing incentives to learn new languages. India was both a linguistically diverse and industrializing country in the mid-twentieth century. I construct a 1931–1961 panel of spoken languages in Indian districts. I show that a structural shift to communication-intensive industrial occupations induces bilingualism among minority language speakers. I also show that initial bilingualism among mother tongue speakers of a language is associated with a relative decline in the population speaking that language.
David Clingingsmith, Harvard University
The New York Banks in the Great Depression: New Evidence on Bank Behavior
The Great Depression was a challenging time for banks across the world. Serving the financial center of the United States as well as being directly influenced by international movements, banks in New York City would have been subject to a constant pressure during this period. However, a relatively small percentage of banks were forced to liquidate. Using a data set of quarterly balance sheets on all state banks and trust companies, I investigate the manner in which these intermediaries were managing their assets during this time while maintaining their liquidity. I find that there were distinct differences between state banks that were members of the Federal Reserve System and those that were not. Those differences also extend to banks in large cities versus those in rural areas. The results have important implications on how banks under different regulatory regimes manage their reserves and investments.
Patrick Van Horn, University of California, Irvine
Second-Best Solutions to the Samaritan's Dilemma: Interest Bans in Early Christianity
This paper argues that the early Christian interest ban can be understood as a second-best response to a “Samaritan's Dilemma” that the Church faced when it became sufficiently wealthy to provide a minimum welfare level for most of its constituents. The Church, viewed as an altruistic institution, could not commit to “punishing” individuals who borrowed too much and therefore imposed a ban on interest, stymieing the borrowing capabilities of its poorest constituents. A detailed analysis of the early Christian economy and concurrent interest dogma suggests that a commitment issue was in fact a driving reason behind the Church's interest ban. This study provides a context-specific historical application of the Samaritan's Dilemma, highlighting the crucial role that institutional elements, particularly the ability to establish norms, play in creating constraints faced by players attempting to contract around suboptimal equilibria.
Jared Rubin, Stanford University
Education, Experience and Earnings: Evidence from China's Sent-Down Youth
Amid the turmoil of the Cultural Revolution, China's “up to the mountains, down to the villages” program sent over 17 million urban youth to rural and frontier regions. How did this experience—which interrupted education and delayed urban employment but also promised preferential access to desirable jobs after return—affect the later earnings of those sent down? I use variation in rustication risk due to city of residence and year of graduation to estimate the causal impact on earnings, and find a large earnings penalty, particularly for men. If not all sent-down youth were able to return to cities, these estimates may understate the true loss of income associated with rustication. Findings that rustication raised incomes confound the true impact with a selection effect: parents with “bad” class backgrounds, who were on average better educated, often faced greater pressure to send their children to the countryside.
Cynthia Kinnan, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Leading by Nature or Design? Zaibatsu and Industrialization in Meiji, Japan
Large family-owned conglomerates known as zaibatsu have historically been credited with leading Japanese industrialization during the Meiji Period (1868–1912). Previous study of this period, however, has rested largely on case studies or macro-level analysis, and attempts to compare zaibatsu performance against independent firms have been stymied by a lack of quantitative data. Using a new dataset of firm entry dates collected from corporate genealogies, I test the hypothesis that zaibatsu-affiliated firms were more likely to be industry pioneers relative to independent firms. I reject this hypothesis and find that instead of firm affiliation, industry competitiveness is a better predictor of both first entry and earlier industry establishment over this period. Industry competitiveness may proxy for market power, fixed costs, access to resources, and deterrent behavior of incumbent firms. These results are robust and obtain across different industries and industry classifications.
John Tang, University of California, Berkeley
Institutions and Endowments: Income Taxation and State Credibility in Argentina and Australia, c.1880–1980
Argentina and Australia had comparable geographic environments for development, and yet took starkly different paths. After rapid convergence in the early twentieth century there was clear divergence in the latter twentieth century. This paper addresses this paradox of similar environments and conspicuously different outcomes. Divergence emanated from different institutional experiences due to contrasting experiences of state credibility: the faith a society has in the state to act collectively in society's interests. Fiscal institutions are a clear expression of state credibility. Without credibility the state struggles to erect lucrative fiscal institutions, as society is uncooperative. This is particularly true of income taxation, which emerges as the crux of divergence in Argentina and Australia. Income tax failed after considerable initial success in Argentina and consolidated in Australia. The different income tax trajectories were an important cause of postwar divergence in fiscal institutions, which translated into wider divergence in development.
Andrew Mitchell, London School of Economics
Forty Acres and (No) Mule: Evaluating the Impact of Free Land on the Outcomes of Former Slaves
At the end of the Civil War, most freed slaves possessed low levels of physical and human capital. While no comprehensive plan to give freedmen “forty acres and a mule” was adopted in the United States, Reconstruction played out differently in the Confederate Cherokee Nation. During postwar negotiations, the United States forced the Cherokees to grant full citizenship to their former slaves. As Cherokee citizens, freedmen could claim any land in the public domain—they did receive their “forty acres.” How did the availability of free land affect the Cherokee freedmen? Using the newly encoded 1880 Cherokee Census, I compare the conditions of the Cherokee freedmen to those of the Southern freedmen. Although free land was not a panacea that cured all ills, it did provide the Cherokee freedmen with certain benefits. They enjoyed an advantage in farm ownership rates, farm size, crop income, and self-sufficiency.
Mindy Miller, University of Michigan
Health and Economics Burden of Malaria in Nineteenth-Century America
Even if malaria had been eradicated from the United States by 1950s, it was once a prominent American disease especially before 1880s. Throughout the mid-nineteenth century, malaria severely damaged the health of population and the U.S. economy. The main purpose of the paper is to measure the health and economic burden of malaria in nineteenth-century America, primarily based on Union Army veterans' military, medical, and pension records. Due to lack of reliable malaria mortality or morbidity statistics before 1880, a risk prediction method is employed using U.S. fort sickness reports, weather records and GIS. Based on the county malaria risk prediction, the paper provides convincing evidence that early exposure to malarial environment deteriorated Union Army veterans' height as a proxy of nutritional status in childhood, made them more susceptible to other infections during the Civil War, accelerated the development of chronic conditions, and consequently shortened their longevity. In addition, the paper presents that people living in malarial counties had much lower levels of labor force participation and wealth accumulation in those periods. Much attention is paid to revealing the “long-term” impacts of living under a malarial environment, which has been less explored, and thus supporting why malaria control should be the global priority in the aspects of public health, economic development, and growth.
Sok Chul Hong, University of Chicago
