Our understanding of the lives of working people in the colonial and early national periods has undergone a revolution in recent years. Gender, ethnicity, and race have taken center stage in historical studies, adding richness and complexity to notions of class. Ellen Hartigan-O'Connor brings this newer literature to bear as she focuses on the productive activities of women in the port cities of Newport, Rhode Island and Charleston, South Carolina. Hitherto, historians interested in gender in America's preindustrial past have tended to concentrate on rural areas, whereas those debating the timing and course of the transition to capitalism overlook women entirely. The Ties That Buy seeks to fill these gaps and to stake a claim for the centrality of urban women to the early Atlantic economy.
The largest cities of Britain's continental colonies were located along the Atlantic coast. Hartigan-O'Connor chose Newport and Charleston as her research foci because they were less studied than the bigger ports of Boston, Philadelphia, and New York and because both had significant numbers of enslaved inhabitants as well as merchants, artisans, sailors, and the usual array of service providers typical of maritime communities. In emphasizing their similarities, moreover, she makes much of the trade and communication between the two cities, especially the striking annual migration northwards of South Carolina's elite families fleeing their steamy homes in summer to vacation in the Rhode Island seaport. The economic organization of the two cities differed markedly, however. Charleston served a rich agricultural hinterland where many thousands of enslaved black laborers produced two prized export staples, rice and indigo. Newport, on the other hand, had neither hinterland nor staples. Instead, its businessmen built ships and traded up and down the coast and with West Africa, whence they obtained slaves in return for rum they distilled from molasses procured in the West Indies in exchange for their cargoes of slaves. Charleston continued to rely on London for credit and marketing until well into the nineteenth century. Newport's businessmen were self-financed and opportunistic, proving nimble in finding ways to turn a shilling. Newport and Charleston both suffered heavily at the hands of the British in the Revolutionary War, but Newport never recovered its prewar levels of commerce whereas foreign demand for rice in the post-Revolutionary era ensured that Charleston would long reign as the largest port in the United States south of Baltimore.
Unsurprisingly, the social structure of the two towns also differed. According to the 1790 Federal Census, half of Charleston's population was non-white, almost all of whom were enslaved. At its height on the eve of the revolution, Newport's colored residents numbered fewer than one out of seven. At the other end of the social scale, Charleston was home to a large group of wealthy plantation owners who preferred life in the city. No one in Newport enjoyed such lifestyles. Despite their differences, Hartigan-O'Connor does us a considerable service in pursuing the traces of women, poor and not-so-poor, through the public and private records in both places. She brings them to life as she tracks their activities and renders their words. Her useful street maps evoke the neighborhoods where they lived, worked, traded, and shopped.
Black, white, free and slave, women of the port cities made their livings in a variety of ways, from laundresses to boarding-house keepers to street hawkers and she-merchants. It is clear that the maritime economy depended on the services of women. They all handled money, even slaves did so, and all engaged in borrowing and lending as necessity required and trust permitted. Some women of property used more complex instruments such as bills of exchange, according to Hartigan-O'Connor, but the reader wonders how many women could cast accounts and calculate interest as well as to read and write?
The author's title, The Ties That Buy, refers to her argument that economists and historians have overlooked an important truth: that decisions relating to buying and selling, borrowing and lending, were not the isolated acts of autonomous individuals but products of collaborative behavior among kin, friends, neighbors, employers, even servants. Mutual dependence, intermediation, and the exchange of information were central to urban life, she insists, just as it was to farm communities. For those readers inclined to shrug and say, “Sure, so what?” her response is that the scholarly literature is filled with debates over such matters as the nature and timing of the transition to capitalism, or the motivation behind the so-called consumer revolution and its role in economic development, yet these events are all assumed to pivot on the decisions of free white men acting for themselves or as heads of obedient households. Such an approach simply misses too much by too many.
Introducing women into the story and showing them both as workers acting for themselves and as agents and intermediaries for others, greatly enriches our understanding of how early port cities functioned, but doing so does not suffice in fulfilling our task as historians—that is, to explain outcomes. Hartigan-O'Connor has simply added more variables to a model that she hasn't fully specified. She hasn't told us what her questions are, nor has she showed how her findings might bring us to some resolution of those questions. Critical as she is of shallow-minded practitioners of neoclassical economics, they, at least, customarily define their terms carefully and use them consistently. She has not done so. Her chapter on money, for instance, should have begun by defining what money is and what economic functions it serves before plunging into a description of its cultural and psychological uses. Had she placed such a chapter before the one on credit, she could also have avoided a great deal of confusing repetition.
The Ties That Buy is a courageous attempt to provide a wider and deeper understanding of a major sector of the early American economy. The author's heroic engagement with recent scholarship earned my admiration; time and again her references drove me to look up items I'd ignored or never heard of. I am very glad to have had the opportunity to read this book—much of it is learned, intelligent, and informative. Despite its shortcomings, economic historians cannot afford to ignore it.
