Guy Ben-Porat and Bryan Turner's edited volume, The Contradictions of Israeli Citizenship, succeeds in the difficult task of making a systematic contribution to theory that applies beyond the case studies it explores while broadening our understanding of the context in which the cases are located: modern Israeli society.
Ben-Porat and Turner's introduction to the volume, and Shmuel Eisenstadt's chapter that follows, do an admirable job of articulating clearly the theoretical framework tying the eleven subsequent chapters into a coherent unit. Ben-Porat and Turner begin by noting that citizenship is the instrument of inclusion and exclusion in modern societies and that in Israel citizenship is complicated by the tension between two competing principles: that of “preference” and that of “equality.” In the particular case of Israel, the preference is for a Jewish state; equality is embedded in the desire for this Jewish state to be a democracy. However, they note that in modern Israel, both preference and equality are complicated even further than in other states. Questions such as “who is a Jew?” and “who should be included in the social contract with the Jewish state?” serve as points of contestation and conflict. Eisenstadt's chapter builds on the editors’ introduction, highlighting key changes in the international scene in recent decades that have exacerbated these questions within Israel (and worldwide). The clarity of this chapter serves as a reminder of just how much Eisenstadt, who passed away in 2010, will be missed.
The concepts discussed in the first two chapters provide a nice extension of previous scholarship on contested citizenship by Turner and others. In the eleven chapters that follow, the contributors highlight how contestation over citizenship—who is included and who is excluded socially, politically, economically, and so forth—plays out in Israeli society. Detailed descriptions not only provide rich evidence for the importance of the theoretical frameworks laid out by the authors but also shed light on the particular complexities of Israeli society, thus making a double contribution. The chapters cover topics such as the breakdown of the “republican equation” after the 1973 war and how it led to various forms of protest and contestation in Israel; the genesis and effect on society of groups like Shas, Peace Now, Gush Emunim, and women's and gay activist groups; the challenges posed to traditional concepts of citizenship and participation by the Haredim (ultra-Orthodox); and the role of ethnic minority groups, including Palestinian citizens of Israel as well as relatively recent Jewish immigrant groups such as those from the former Soviet Union, in contesting inclusion and exclusion in Israel.
Some chapters also discuss the role of institutions in creating and furthering this contestation. In one of the more intriguing chapters, Zeev Resenhek discusses how the particular use of the institutions of the welfare state in Israel shapes the citizenship debate. In all cases, the authors build upon their past work on the subjects at hand and present compelling new analysis and data to push theory forward. As such, the key strength of this work lies in the combination of theory and thick description that marks each of the chapters.
The editors begin the volume with the claim that the concepts and case studies offered will shed light on contestation over citizenship in other countries and contexts. Nearly all the contributing authors attempt to make good on this claim, drawing, in true comparative fashion, from research on their respective topics in other contexts. In addition, some of the contributors explicitly discuss the ways in which the phenomena they highlight in Israel apply elsewhere, making the book a valuable read for comparativists who study citizenship and nationalism in other contexts but know little about Israel. However, the book could have benefited from a concluding chapter in which the editors explicitly highlighted contexts outside of Israel in which we might find forms of contestation over citizenship similar to those they describe.
In sum, I highly recommend this book both for those seeking an introduction to modern Israeli society and for those already familiar with some of its complexities. Written in engaging and accessible prose, it will be a nice addition to courses on the modern Middle East or Israeli politics. It will also be helpful to comparative scholars of citizenship and nationality and provides valuable new material for courses on these topics. This is particularly true not only of the excellent introduction written by Ben-Porat and Turner but also of many of the other chapters. For the serious scholar, the book provides new insights and an excellent starting point for further research on the topics raised herein.
