Literary scholar Kathleen Donegan analyzes the earliest English colonial writings, exploring the initial misery associated with colonization. She favors overlooked texts – such as George Percy's account of the catastrophe at Jamestown – but also considers highly influential sources, including William Bradford's Of Plymouth Plantation and Richard Ligon's A True and Exact History of the Island of Barbados. Most of these texts record early colonization attempts and present the horrors of widespread death, disease and deprivation. With an American-studies-inspired attention to colonial identity, the work recalls older studies. Donegan rejects the celebratory narrative of national origins, noting that suffering is usually remembered only in the context of the founders' heroism; but she accepts the idea of uniquely colonial writings forging a new identity.
Positing an ability “to find coloniality in crisis rather than in accretion” (12), Donegan rejects a teleological reading focussed on successful settlements. Known only as a grisly prelude to working colonies, accounts of horror get skipped over or, at most, cited as examples of valorous sufferings. Donegan argues that the very act of comprehending crisis created identity. The writings she explores are imbued with a “language of fear, uncanniness, bewilderment, entreaty, or grim visions,” and they “registered a rift between English ideals that were the basis of colonization and the fractured colonial experiences that were its outcome” (205). Seasons of Misery makes its case with close readings of sources drawn from three colonies and the West Indies, organized into four substantive chapters.
In both the Roanoke and Jamestown chapters, she makes good use of lesser-known authors, Ralph Lane and Percy. Each wrote messy stories that intrigue Donegan, who seeks out indeterminacy and uncertainty. In contrast to the highly valued descriptive writings of Thomas Harriot and the accompanying ethnographic images of John White, Lane wrote a narrative of events. Donegan notes many missteps anticipating the future (undocumented) end of the colony. She vividly depicts Lane traveling up a deathly silent river, realizing that the inhabitants have withdrawn from the hungry and demanding English intruders. In Donegan's hands, Roanoke's subsequent disappearance, leaving behind “colonial events both fateful and indecipherable,” was emblematic of the colonial project itself (68). Scholars know Jamestown largely through John Smith, but Donegan reconsiders that history from the perspective of Smith's much maligned nemesis. Percy led the colony through and produced a Trewe Relaycon of the worst year of its early history. For Donegan his abject account established a literature of colonial misery. Often culled for the most disturbing images – of starvation and cannibalism – Percy's text taken as a whole reveals the depths to which the English in Jamestown plunged and the incomprehensibility of that experience.
Of Plymouth Plantation, a text that was not published in its author's lifetime, guides the treatment of Plymouth, with the outsider Thomas Morton's relation serving as a counterpoint. This settlement too witnessed great suffering. In the most stunning image, the settlers propped dead and dying men against trees, holding their weapons, to deceive the local natives about their numbers and vitality. Donegan also provides an inspired reading of Bradford's brief demographic table, noting how his ledger occludes deaths (including of entire families) and emphasizes progeny.
Donegan finally turns to Caribbean writings, addressing texts that are arguably less apt. Until the invasion of Jamaica no literature of early settler suffering survives. John Nicholl's account of abandonment, danger and death represents not a settlement narrative but another case (akin to Miles Philips's) of men abandoned to their fates. Important as an early island ethnography, it conveys misery, certainly, but without the disorientation of settlement. In the second West Indian text, Ligon considers a period well beyond early struggles. Writing rather of bountiful dining tables amidst the terrible suffering of oppressed laborers, Ligon's experiences may have been as intense and indescribable as the earlier accounts. They nonetheless convey a very different colonial experience.
Whether or not readers are interested in colonial identity, Donegan's work commands attention. Treating writings that are routinely overlooked provides insights, while her analysis is often highly nuanced. Few discordant notes occur. Including Barbados despite a lack of works that sustain her thesis forces a focus on unsanitary public water supply, a phenomenon that plagued most early modern Europeans and had little to do with coloniality. Climate makes only a minor appearance despite looming large in fearful writings. The unreflexive adoption of “Pilgrims” (replete with capital P) departs from the commitment to interrogate mythic constructions. Such missteps are minor in a book bursting with engaging readings and vivid re-creations of the catastrophic history of England's earliest colonial endeavors.
