This book makes important contributions to the continuing academic debates concerning the character of slavery in precolonial Africa and the significance of elite slavery in the Islamic world. Stilwell's study focuses on the royal slavery in Kano, one of the leading emirates of the Sokoto Caliphate. Located in what is today northern Nigeria, the caliphate was established by the jihad led by the Islamic cleric and political reformer Usman dan Fodio in the early 19th century. In subsequent decades, slavery became a central social, economic, and political institution in the caliphate. The author argues that Kano's royal slaves (whom he chooses for comparative purposes to call “Mamluks,” although they were never known by that term in Kano) were indeed slaves; nonetheless, they came to exercise considerable political and administrative power, and they developed a largely autonomous slave community and an extensive network of kin groups. These apparent contradictions are what lead Stilwell to use the phrase “paradoxes of power” in the title of his book. The book's arguments are based on a careful study of colonial-era documents found principally in the Nigerian National Archives and on an impressive array of oral interviews, conducted by the author and others, among present-day holders of titled offices in Kano.
In the introductory chapter, Stilwell describes the emergence of the Sokoto Caliphate as a unified empire created from the ancient, disparate Hausa city-states of the west-central Sudan. He situates his work in the comparative context of studies of slavery in Africa and the Islamic world. Following the path-breaking work of Orlando Patterson and M.I. Finley, Stilwell defines his subjects, Kano's royal slaves, as natally alienated, kinless, owned outsiders who lacked honor; not for him the “assimilationist” model of African slavery was developed by Suzanne Miers and Igor Kopytoff. He also follows Paul Lovejoy and others in categorizing Kano (and the Sokoto Caliphate more generally) as a genuine slave society, although it should be noted that his is not a study of Kano slavery per se, but only of royal slavery in Kano. Indeed, his work focuses almost exclusively on the historical trajectory of a group of titled men who numbered only 150 in the mid-19th century.
Subsequent chapters describe and analyze in a more or less chronological manner the development of Kano's slave offices and royal slave community from the reign of the first post-jihad emir to the conquest of the Sokoto Caliphate by the British in the early 20th century. In the first chapter, Stilwell discusses the origins of royal slavery in Kano. He rejects the idea associated with Patricia Crone and Daniel Pipes that Islam was at the root of the institution, arguing instead that royal slavery developed “as a political strategy” and grew out of pre-jihad Hausa household-style government (pp. 38, 44). Nevertheless, the institution came to be shaped by Islamic law and values. Royal slavery served to enhance the power of the emir over both the free, titled aristocracy and the ulama. The first post-jihad emir appears to have avoided making much use of slaves in his government, perhaps viewing the institution as an unsavory legacy of the displaced Hausa rulers. However, his successor, Emir Dabo, who came to power in 1819, had no such qualms and, with the endorsement of the caliph, recreated several pre-jihad titled slave offices in an effort to consolidate his power. Dabo was in effect the author of the system of royal slavery in Kano.
The next chapter takes a more thematic look at the operation of royal slavery under Dabo and a few of his successors. Stilwell focuses here (and in much of the remainder of the book) on the three major slave offices of Shamaki, Sallama, and Dan Rimi. Although the relationship between the emir and his slave officeholders was nominally governed by the principle of amana (“trust,” denoting the reciprocal, yet asymmetric obligations of patron and client), successive emirs curtailed the power of slave officeholders by removing those appointed by his predecessor and raising his own. Nevertheless, the political roles of royal slaves expanded as they became the mediators between the increasingly “sacred” realm of the court and the “profane” world outside. In the following chapter—which strikes this reviewer as the most innovative—Stilwell shows how the emirs' crucial reliance on their political roles gave the slave officeholders the opportunity to create households and kinship networks among themselves and links with the free elite through the practice of concubinage. This compelling historical analysis of the emergence of a royal slave community constitutes a major contribution to the study of slavery in precolonial Africa.
Stilwell then examines a different, but equally interesting, aspect of the royal slaves' growing centrality to Kano government: their appropriation of specialized administrative knowledge. Royal slaves acquired expertise in military matters, the recording of history, administration of the rural areas, and the management of royal plantations. Although this knowledge (the slaves' “cultural capital”) served to enhance the power of the emir vis-à-vis the free aristocracy, it also increased the dependence of the emirs on the skills of their elite slaves. Even more revealing of this dependence was the fact that the sons and possible heirs of emirs were themselves trained in the households of slave officials. Thus, by the end of the 19th century, royal slaves were at the peak of their power in Kano. This finding was amply demonstrated by the crucial role they played in the civil war that broke out in 1893 over succession to the position of emir. The ultimate victory of Emir Aliyu Babba over his opponent (who was initially backed by the caliphate government) was ensured by the support of key segments of Kano's royal slave community.
Paradoxes of Power retains some of the character of its origins as Ph.D. dissertation. It is a very focused study, in some respects too focused, and consequently sometimes gives short shrift to critical analytical issues that transcend slavery and yet are relevant to the analysis at hand. For example, a key concept that is used in every chapter is that of “patrimonialism,” yet the author never deals explicitly with the theoretical underpinnings of the term. A careful examination of Weber's seminal writings would have helped refine the analysis of formal and informal power of Kano's slave officials and the broader hierarchy of authority. The extent to which his study of Kano is relevant to the historical experiences of the other emirates, and even the caliphal government at Sokoto, is addressed in barely two pages, rather awkwardly attached to a chapter with a different theme. Stilwell uses quotation marks around certain terms so inconsistently that it is unclear what these are meant to flag. This is particularly the case with the term “free,” which he nowhere defines in the Kano context. Nevertheless, these criticisms do not detract from the fact that this is an important work that deserves to be read by all scholars of comparative slavery, particularly in the African and the Islamic worlds.
