Public interest in the nature of childhood and the role of music in children's lives appears to be growing judged by recent broadcasts (see Cunningham, Reference Cunningham2006) and publications (McPherson, Reference McPherson2006). Musical Childhoods & the Cultures of Youth is a welcome contribution to the field. Its ten chapters span ten centuries and four continents, and view music through the multi-faceted lens of childhood. The book brings together an inter-disciplinary team of researchers drawing on historical and social-scientific approaches. The collection is divided into three parts: Ritual Performance; Identity Formation; Musical Socialisation. It concludes with an Afterword. In this review I shall focus particularly on those essays that may be of special relevance to music educators.
In ‘Ritual Performance’, the emphasis is on systems of belief and notions of childhood. Two of the papers focus upon the Church, which was an all-powerful force in medieval and early modern times; indeed music education derived its strength and privilege from its place in the liturgy and devotions. Susan Boynton and Isabelle Cochelin report on the sociomusical role of child oblates at the Abbey of Cluny in the 11th century, and detail the range of genres the children were required to sing. Whilst the child oblates generally sang the simpler chants of the liturgy, there is little doubt that on occasions they performed more complex material. Learning to sing and read occupied every free moment of the day, and generally the children learned to sing by listening, rather than from notations. Corporal punishment for making mistakes was common. Todd Borgerding's chapter on ‘Choirboys, their voices, and Corpus Christi in Early Modern Seville’ discusses the festival at which the boys not only sang but danced. Much of the discussion focuses on the ideas of the child-body in the Renaissance, compared with Counter-Reformation Spain. On a more mundane level we learn that the boys were trained in grammar and music including, by the 16th century, chant, counterpoint and polyphony. Inevitably in both these religious contexts the conceptions of childhood are filtered through the needs and concerns of adults – we find nothing about their own perceptions of the rituals. Nevertheless it appears that there was a more or less fixed order as far as the acquisition of musical skills was concerned which enabled the choristers to develop their musical competence as quickly as possible.
The second part of the book is called Identity Formation, and it asks how the self is formed during youth. I found Roe-Min Kok's ‘Music for a postcolonial child: theorizing Malaysian memories’ most compelling. The author sees herself as ‘the native informant’, and she describes a colonial music education, in which an arc of power extended from the Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music (ABRSM) to Malaysia. She points out that many of her parents’ peers associated Britishness with power, and economic and social success, furthermore ‘middle class Malaysians saw dazzling social potential in the piano’ (p. 92). This was particularly the case for females (reminiscent of 19th century attitudes in Europe and America). Roe-Min Kok then enquires whether the ABRSM had investigated Malaysian needs, but concludes that it transferred its methods directly in a postcolonial setting. She ‘participated willingly if unwittingly in an ideological process that ultimately reinforced the colonizers’ cultural subjugation of the colonized’ (p. 98). But life is never that straightforward. In her final footnote Kok admits that all who subscribed to the ABRSM were happy with it, and saw no reason to devise an alternative. Perhaps as she says, this is symptomatic of the complicated and compromised nature of the coloniser-colonised relationship. We need more such studies which locate music education within the wider parameters of power structures, including those of colonialism and nationalism.
In the book's third part, ‘Musical Socialisation’ we move from the individual to the collective. The powerful influence of nationalism on the policy and practice of music education is the theme of the essay by H. and M. Gottschewski who chart three stages of children's music in Japan since the Meiji era (1868–1912). They see this history as a struggle for ‘true national’ Japanese childhood. Following the advent of compulsory education in 1872, the new age was reflected in the choice of songs for schools, and the tension between cultural restoration and modernisation. In 1918 a truly new kind of children's song appeared, the beginning of the children's song movement (dôyô undô), very different from the westernised and colloquial shôka, popular in schools. All this was contrasted with the Warebe-uta, songs transmitted from Japanese mothers to their children, and from child to child. These came to be disseminated as ‘national songs’ in the 1930s. The Gottschewskis point out that these traditional arebe-uta songs formed a closed group representing a backward-looking identity based upon a romantic rural image of ‘true Japanese childhood’, in contrast to the forward-looking identity represented by western-style songs. The chapter is a useful contribution to studies of the relationships between music, national feeling and education.
For Judah Cohen's chapter ‘Song leading, Summer Camps and Identity among Reform Jewish teenagers’ in the USA, we move into music education outside school. These summer camps, as observed in the summer of 2000, attract high school students who gather more or less voluntarily in a specialised religious context devoted to developing stronger ties with their religious movement and heritage. The point is not only to develop song leading as a musical discourse, but also as a foundational part of a musical life trajectory. Song leading is regarded as an important part of the camping curriculum, giving rise to a special institute for the transmission of the Reform Jewish song-leading tradition, to which high school students from around the country would come. There are two categories of songs, liturgical and recreational. Interestingly, Cohen points out that the tradition is associated with youth, and consequently is often dismissed as ‘camp music’ or ‘children's music’ allied to developing but not mature identity, only useful as a preparation for adapting to the musical values of the adult world. He contests this, and relates it to the 19th century notion based on equating childhood with cultural primitivism. Essentially Cohen argues that much of what we see as musical tradition may gain its foothold before adulthood, and not because of it.
The book ends with an excellent Afterword by Amanda Minks. She points out that modern discourses on childhood are rooted in Enlightenment notions of childhood innocence, linked to sociocultural evolutionism. Western children in this view recapitulated the stages of human development from primitive to civilised, while non-Western others occupied a state of arrested development. Childhood was equated with cultural primitivism. But Minks emphasises that the marking of children and childhoods as different must be viewed in tandem with other forms of marking difference, ‘as raced, classed, ethnicised, and sexed/gendered’ (p. 217).
In addition to the essays specifically mentioned in this review, there are chapters on girls’ puberty rites in southeastern New Mexico, theoretical archetypes for children's development found in Ravel's L'Enfant et les Sortilèges, the construction of modern Griot identity in Senegal, the Coming of Age of a Korean P'ansori Performer, and New German Folk Songs for the Free German Youth (1950).
Musical Childhoods and the Cultures of Youth is ambitious in its scope, addressing Cohen's assertion that ‘young people are remarkably overlooked as practitioners and purveyors of musical traditions’ (p. 189) (although a notable exception is Patricia Shehan Campbell's groundbreaking Songs in their Heads (1988) which focuses on the process of children making music as children). Hopefully this book should encourage us as music education researchers to widen our horizons through problematising our common-sense understandings of what comprises musical childhoods and the cultures of youth, and challenging ourselves to probe more deeply and imaginatively in the notion of the child as musician.
