Yates has produced a fascinating and richly detailed book on both the causes and consequences of Africa's ‘oil curse’. Each of nine different substantive chapters highlights different dimensions of the curse and illustrates them with an extended case study. One great challenge of the study is that Yates seeks to understand at least three dimensions of the curse, including lack of development, brutal authoritarianism and socio-political conflict. In turn, a wide variety of causes of this multi-dimensional curse are explored in the book. Rather than ending with an analytical conclusion, the study culminates with a thought-provoking set of five ‘solutions’ to Africa's oil curse.
Yates' analysis of the causes of Africa's oil curse ends up being a (quite rich) ‘thick description’. Yates identifies three major causes for the failure of oil-rich African states to benefit from the natural endowment that should intuitively have promoted their development. First, he shows that many of Africa's petro-states have been the victims of neo-colonial interference by outside powers that have little interest in African development. The contemporary challenge of this argument is to show how China's recently escalating involvement in the economies of Africa's oil states has not changed this pattern, and Yates is up to the test, illustrating his argument with the case of Franco–Gabonese relations. Second, he argues that foreign multinational oil companies have exploited Africa's oil wealth at the expense of the citizens of the petro-states; here, Yates illustrates his argument by reference to the experience of Chevron–Texaco (formerly Gulf) Oil in Angola's Cabinda region. Third, he argues that the ‘rentier’ political economy of Africa's oil states actually drives out other forms of productive economic activity, and leaves the oil states dependent on fluctuating oil revenues. This chapter, illustrated with the case of Equatorial Guinea, displays Yates' excellent politico-economic analytical skills. A further chapter tries to draw a connection between praetorianism and oil wealth, but does not quite succeed since, as the author admits, many military regimes do not depend on oil, and not all petro-states suffer military rule.
Three other chapters essentially show how forces that might ameliorate the ‘oil curse’ have not done so. One of these shows how (though not why) the well-intentioned anti-corruption efforts of the World Bank, Transparency International, the Extractive Industries Transparency and Global Witness have failed. His chapter entitled ‘Journalists and Intellectuals’, poignantly illustrated with a biography of Cameroonian writer Mongo Beti, shows how investigative journals and intellectuals have been dissuaded through bribery, intimidation and terror. And a chapter on multiparty democracy shows how freely elected leaders and institutions have been easily corrupted by the power of oil money and foreign influence in the case of São Tomé e Principe.
A major flaw of the book is that it does not pursue its master question – why have Africa's oil states not developed – systematically enough. One wonders, for instance, which variable is ‘at the centre’ of Yates' thick description? Perhaps African populations are not able to overcome their exploitation by former colonisers, greedy oil executives, and their own feckless rulers due to their political culture, which in that case must change. Alas, Yates does not make this (or any other) argument on his major question explicit, as he might have done in a proper conclusion. The book could also benefit by being more comparative, an approach that the author embraces at the outset. For instance, how has Botswana been able to avoid the resource curse with its diamonds, while none of Africa's oil states has? Third, Yates sometimes overreaches in trying to connect too many of Africa's ills on the oil curse. This is evident in his chapter on Sudan, analysing South Sudan's war of secession, as well as in the chapter on the military. Finally, the volume suffers from a few too many minor editorial and factual errors (such as references to the ‘coastal Lari’ of Congo-Brazzaville and the ‘Lekouma’ region). Despite these flaws, students of Africa's oil states will find Yates' work informative, and a broad audience will be stimulated by its excellent critical analyses.
