Then the revelation occurred: Marino saw the rose as Adam might have seen it in Paradise, and he thought that the rose was to be found in its own eternity and not in his words; and that we may mention or allude to a thing, but not express it; and that the tall, proud volumes casting a golden shadow in a corner were not—as his vanity had dreamed—a mirror of the world, but rather one thing more added to the world.
Jorge Luis Borges, ‘The Yellow Rose’ (Dreamtigers)Footnote 1Ausonius' Mosella is probably the most remarkable, studied and beloved poem of late antiquity.Footnote 2 This essay aims to examine it from a new perspective, by reinterpreting it as a complex and many-layered depiction of a sui generis epiphanic experience, ultimately triggered by an unmediated encounter with nature. This sudden ‘revelation’, be it real or merely an artful literary device, did not only provide Ausonius with a deeper insight into the world around him, but also raised many epistemological issues on the limits of human knowledge and the (in)ability of language to convey reality. Both aspects—the poetical rendering of a non-discursive quasi-mystical experience and the epistemological and philosophical reflections it brings about—pervade the whole of the poem and are absolutely central to an in-depth understanding of its very raison d’être.
The river Moselle is, on the one hand, the vehicle and the trigger for this sudden revelation—a non-discursive experience that might well be called a kenshō, in terms of Japanese Zen tradition.Footnote 3 On the other hand, it embodies a whole set of epistemological, aesthetic and even political metaphors aimed at elucidating the nature of this newly acquired knowledge and the role of human language in its desperate attempt to grasp and express reality. This novel approach to the poem will help us to explain some of its most outstanding features, thus opening the way for a richer apprehension of its many intricacies.
1. Ausonius' Initiation Path: Finding the Way out of Plato's Cave
The poem begins quite abruptly with a gloomy depiction of Ausonius' overland journey from Bingen on the Rhine to Neumagen on the Moselle:
I had crossed over swift-flowing Nava's cloudy stream, and gazed with awe upon the ramparts lately thrown round ancient Vingum, where Gaul once matched the Roman rout at Cannae, and where her slaughtered hordes lay scattered over the countryside untended and unwept. Thence onward I began a lonely journey through pathless forest, nor did my eyes rest on any trace of human inhabitants. I passed Dumnissus, sweltering amid its parched fields, and Tabernae, watered by its unfailing spring, and the lands lately parcelled out to Sarmatian settlers.
(tr. Evelyn White)The abrupt and highly unconventional presence of the pluperfect transieram (‘I had crossed over’) at the very opening of the poem has frequently puzzled scholars,Footnote 4 who have even attempted to explain it as a result of an unlikely scribal omission.Footnote 5 The answer, however, is much simpler. Following a long-established convention in both Greek and Latin literature, the poem's first word—transieram (‘I had crossed over’)—reveals and synthesises the gist of its content:Footnote 6 the Mosella is all about crossing over boundaries, about passing from darkness into light, about going over into a different consciousness by means of a process of internal transformation.Footnote 7 The voice of the enlightened poet is thus speaking from the present of this newly acquired condition, remembering the stages which he had to undergo in order to complete his exacting initiation journey. Hence the striking use of the past perfect instead of the expected simple past at the very beginning of his narrative.
The starting point of this initiation passage is consistently characterised with unequivocally sombre brushstrokes: nebuloso (‘cloudy’, 1), moenia (‘ramparts’, 2), infletae (‘unwept’, 4), iacent (‘lay scattered’, 4), inopes (‘untended’, 4), cateruae (‘slaughtered hordes’, 4), iter…solum (‘lonely journey’, 5), nemorosa per auia (‘through pathless forest’, 5), nulla humani…uestigia cultus (‘no trace of human inhabitants’, 6), arentem (‘sweltering’, 7), sitientibus (‘parched’, 7), Sauromatum…colonis (‘Sarmatian settlers’, 9). Ausonius finds himself surrounded by darkness, mist and death, unable to perceive the stunning beauty of the world around him. The scant references to the idea of vision are always negative, underlying the absence of a real object to be seen: et nulla humani spectans uestigia cultus (‘nor did my eyes rest on any trace of human inhabitants’, 6). Quite surprisingly, Ausonius describes a potentially quaint and charming environment in terms of infernal landscape: the Nava River (today's Nahe) crossed by the poet in line 1 is deliberately transformed into the underworld river Styx by means of an intelligent use of the literarily connoted adjective nebuloso (‘cloudy’, 1),Footnote 8 as proved by Görler.Footnote 9 Similarly, the idyllic Hunsrück mountains are represented with Vergilian diction as littered with unburied corpses (3f.), hostile to civilisation (5f.) and eerily gloomy. These first nine lines have indeed been proved to be a deliberate reworking of the topic of the travel to Hell or katabasis as depicted by Vergil in the sixth book of his Aeneid, many of whose passages are here intertextually borrowed.Footnote 10 In Martin's words:Footnote 11
L'exorde du poème pourrait se lire comme le récit d'une cérémonie initiatique consistant, selon la tradition que rappelle Apulée au livre XI des Métamorphoses, en une plongée au royaume des morts suivie d'un retour à la lumière et pour ainsi dire une résurrection: Ausone apparaît ici comme un myste qui, à l'issue de cette catabase agonissante mais illuminante, reçoit la révelation de la Verité, qui jusque-là lui était demeurée cachée.
And this hidden Truth does not only consist in revealing ‘la “gréco-romanité” fondamentale de la région trévire’—as Martin suggestsFootnote 12 —but also in a higher degree of awareness in his knowledge of reality, what Western mystics would call a sudden illumination and Zen practitioners a kenshō.
Therefore, the beginning of the Mosella clearly underlines the global quality of ‘prise de conscience et/ou d'un révélation’Footnote 13 that prevails in the whole composition. In fact, we are constantly told that there is a secret which Ausonius is going to reveal to us after his own initiation process,Footnote 14 a concealed understanding that is about to be disclosed: sic demersa procul durante per intima uisu / cernimus arcani patet penetrale profundi (‘so, if our gaze penetrates thy gulfs, we behold things whelmed far below, and the recesses of thy secret depth lie open’, 59f.), spectaris uitreo per leuia terga profundo, / secreti nihil amnis habens (‘through thy smooth surface showest all the treasures of thy crystal depths—a river keeping naught concealed’, 55f.). But Ausonius is not allowed to reveal to the reader's non-initiated eyes the secret knowledge provided by his direct contemplation of the river waters: sed non haec spectata ulli nec cognita uisu / fas mihi sit pro parte loqui: secreta tegatur / et commissa suis lateat reuerentia riuis (‘but of these things which no man has looked upon and no eye beheld, be it no sin for me to speak in part: let Reverence be covered in her seclusion, and let her dwell unspied upon, in the safe-keeping of her native streams’, 186-88).Footnote 15 The ultimate reality is never utterable: it must be directly experienced.
Lines 10-22 represent a second stage in that initiation journey through the darkness of barbarian territories into the blinding light of the civilising force of the Moselle:
And at length on the very verge of Belgic territory I descry Noiomagus, the famed camp of sainted Constantine. Clearer the air which here invests the plains, and Phoebus, cloudless now, discloses glowing heaven with his untroubled light. No longer is the sky to seek, shut out by the green gloom of branches intertwined: but the free breath of transparent day withholds not sight of the sun's pure rays and of the aether, dazzling to the eyes. Nay more, the whole gracious prospect made me behold a picture of my own native land, the smiling and well-tended country of Bordeaux—the roofs of country-houses, perched high upon the overhanging river-banks, the hill-sides green with vines, and the pleasant stream of Moselle gliding below with subdued murmuring.
(tr. Evelyn White)Meaningfully, the adverb tandem (‘at length’, 10), implying the end of a long delay or expectation, introduces the first verb of sight with an openly positive connotation to be found in the poem: conspicor (‘I descry’, 10). After a hard travel through darkness and death, Ausonius is finally able to see. The air is suddenly much purerFootnote 16 (purior hic…aer, 12) and the sky is not covered any longer by a tangle of menacing branches (14f.) or a thick mantle of fog (13). Everything is luminous,Footnote 17 transparent,Footnote 18 calm,Footnote 19 and open to the sight.Footnote 20 Once again it is the sixth book of Vergil's Aeneid that intertextually shapes the whole passage. This time, however, Ausonius takes his readers away from the gloomy depths of Hades to the much sunnier second stage of Aeneas' journey through the Underworld: the Elysian Fields, a Greco-Roman paradise for the blessed souls of the virtuous. Lines 12f. are indeed a direct evocation of Verg. Aen. 6.640f.,Footnote 21 depicting Aeneas' first impression of that heavenly resting place: largior hic campos aether et lumine uestit / purpureo… (‘a more generously lustrous brightness of sky dresses meadows here with a colourful brilliance’).Footnote 22 Curiously enough, what Aeneas finds at the very heart of Elysium is precisely a river: the LetheFootnote 23 . In the Aeneid the river Lethe is deprived of any negative connotation. It is the river of resurrection, not of death.Footnote 24 Only the souls who have attained to the highest degree of purification are allowed to drink of its blissful waters of oblivion and reincarnate.Footnote 25 If the Nava in line 1 has been proved to be the Styx, would it not be tempting to interpret the Moselle as the embodiment of the Lethe—the river which, according to a time-honoured Vergilian, Platonic and Pythagorean tradition, affords access to a new life? The parallels of the Mosella with the sixth book of the Aeneid are indeed striking and go far beyond what has been usually accepted. A clear example is provided by Ausonius' celebrated though much scorned catalogue of fish (82-149), immediately following his moving encounter with the transparent secrets of the Moselle (23-81). This catalogue could be easily reinterpreted as a playful homage to the famous scene following Aeneas' vision of the river Lethe (Aen. 6.678-751): the catalogue of illustrious Romans waiting their turn to be (re)born at the river's edge (Aen. 6.752-892).Footnote 26
The revelation experienced by the poet in his sudden encounter with the Moselle River makes him feel more at home than anywhere else, including his native town. That explains the moving evocation of Bordeaux triggered by this very experience (18-22), a recurrent theme throughout the poem.Footnote 27 Ausonius feels no more in exile. He is finally at home, like wandering Aeneas enjoying once again the company of his deceased father Anchises by the banks of the river Lethe. Meaningfully enough, the poem's last word is Garunnae (483), the river that runs through Ausonius' much yearned-for home town. The Moselle has become all rivers (omnia solus habes, ‘one, thou hast all’, 31)—it is thus the new metaphorical homeland of enlightened humankind.
As we have seen, the privileged approach to the reality of things as provided by the transparent waters of the Moselle implies a whole process of gradual awakening or ‘illumination’, a kind of mystical revelation only available for ‘initiates’.Footnote 28 The passage from darkness to light—from a Vergilian hell of blindness to a mystical heaven of pure vision—as enacted in this calculated exordium seems to be deliberately modelled on Plato's celebrated myth of the Cave (Resp. 7.514a-521b), a text enthusiastically vindicated by late antique Neo-Platonism.Footnote 29 It is no coincidence that in both Plato's myth and Vergil's account of Aeneas' katabasis the initiation trip takes place inside a cave,Footnote 30 while in opposite directions. Despite the differences, the result is the very much same: a final revelation in the realm of light and knowledge.
2. Ausonius' Unmediated Encounter with Nature
As already pointed out, it was the unexpected sight of the River Moselle, Ausonius' own private Lethe, that provided him with a superior/expanded apprehension of the surrounding world, so far invisible to his eyes. The poet repeatedly stresses the autoptical nature of this experience, which is consistently represented as primarily personal: ‘I myself have seen’ (uidi egomet, 270; uidi ego, 341). Even Ausonius' name is explicitly mentioned in the poem's epilogueFootnote 31 , which contributes in no small measure to the almost intimate flavour characterising the whole composition. In fact, one of the most outstanding features of the way in which Ausonius depicts his face-to-face encounter with the Moselle (the third and last stage of his initiation journey, running from line 23 onwards) is undoubtedly its almost ‘dialogic’ character, as expressed by his extensive use of the first and the second person. The presence of these two communicative entities is obsessively underlined throughout the poem—an ubiquitous You (salue amnis, 23; omnia solus habes, 31; tu, 33; habes, 37; tu, 39; ipse tuos…miraris…putas, 43f.; tu, 45; i nunc, 48; te…te…te…te…te…te…te, 477-83; etc.) facing a very powerful Ego (ast ego, 50; hic ego, 170; uidi ego, 341; uerum ego, 389; haec ego, 438; etc.). Such an unexpected profusion of subject pronouns, extremely rare in a pro-drop language like Latin, goes beyond any imaginable literary conventionFootnote 32 and shows very clearly Ausonius' interest in bestowing a peculiar ‘statut communicatif’ on his poem. Borrowing the insightful classification of the Russian semiologist Yuri Levin,Footnote 33 we can say that we are dealing with an ‘égotique-appellatif’ text, i.e., a text in which the poetical me and you are explicitly (and even lavishly) represented. According to this, we can say that we are witnesses to a real initiatic dialogue—that is, a direct communication, without any intermediary entity—between the poet (me) and the river (you).Footnote 34 But how should this textual evidence be understood?
Literarily speaking, such a non-mediated encounter with the Moselle—explicitly depicted as an enlightening experience—is primarily to be seen in what, according to Jacques Fontaine, can be considered the predominant genre of the piece: the hymn, a time-honoured form of literature with undisguised religious connotations.Footnote 35 In fact, Ausonius constantly addresses the river as a sacred and numinous entity, most particularly in the poem's epilogue: fas mihi sacrum / perstrinxisse amnem tenui libamine Musae (‘be it no sin for me to have touched lightly on thy holy stream with the poor offering my Muse affords', 443f.).Footnote 36 There is no need to go any deeper into the many ‘affinités liturgiques’Footnote 37 of the poem, pretty apparent to any sensitive reader. In a broader historic and cultural context, this ‘unmediatedness’ can be considered a genuine expression of a new late antique episteme,Footnote 38 whose remote origins date back to the early Imperial period. Traina already detected in Seneca's style the first traces of a novel cultural situation—that of the ancient man feeling for the first time in front of the cosmos without any external mediation.Footnote 39 Sure enough, classical man felt that there was a supreme hierarchical order in the world and—by extension—in the word, its alleged verbal ‘reflection’. His relationship with outer instances was entirely filtered by an active participation in public life through the republican political apparatus and its profoundly hierarchical system (as expressed in its perfectly graduated cursus honorum). When a new imperial system deleted the sociopolitical dimension of man, erasing the individual's possibility of getting involved in public business, the intermediation of society was no longer real, and therefore—for the first time in the ancient world—the individual and the cosmos met each other face to face. ‘La realtà politica passa in secondo piano,’ explains Traina,Footnote 40 ‘e individuo e cosmo si trovano di fronte…. Il contraccolpo stilistico di questo mutamento di valori è una prosa esasperata e irrelata che ha tanti centri e tante pause quante sono le frasi’.Footnote 41
The cultural change described by Traina becomes much more noticeable and extreme in late antiquity. Ausonius' generation had seen how the pagan deities, ultimate guarantors of the validity of the classical world order, had been overthrown by the newcomer Christian God, accepted by many fourth-century intellectuals rather as an imposition of the Roman administration than as a personal belief. In this context, the poet's unmediated contact with the River Moselle without any ‘diaframma fra di essi e la natura’Footnote 42 has to be ultimately understood as a manifestation of the widespread crisis of language and representation which characterised late antique culture as a whole, thus giving birth to what I have proposed calling a ‘poetics of silence’.Footnote 43 This collective distrust of language as a valid means to convey and grasp reality resulted in an unprecedented flowering of all kind of mystical trends (from pagan Neo-Platonism to Christian apophatic theology), basically aimed at attaining to a non-discursive knowledge of the ultimate essence of things by means of a direct non-mediated contemplation.Footnote 44 It is precisely in this breeding ground that a work like Ausonius' Mosella should be culturally contextualised and understood.
Speaking of a ‘direct’ reunion between individual and nature does not mean at all that the resulting poem should be entirely exempt from all literary, rhetorical or cultural mediation, as though we could ever deal with a piece of true ‘natural’ poetry. Nothing could be farther from the way in which art really works than those ‘pseudo-romantic’ myths—authenticity, creation ex nihilo, originality, etc. It was perhaps a real mystical experience of a direct unmediated contact with the Divinity that inspired Saint John of the Cross to compose some of his best poems; but what is certain is that they are a highly culturalised product full of intertextual recalls and modelled on the rhetorical precedent of the Song of Songs.Footnote 45 The same could be said of Ausonius' Mosella: after all, we are dealing with a complex hyper-culturalised poem aimed at facing all previous literature—both Greek and Latin—through a continuous intertextual dialogue, with an unusual mixture of tones and genresFootnote 46 and a political spirit transcending any automatic reading. Ternes has shown indeed how far is Ausonius' literary attitude towards nature from a simple realistic description.Footnote 47 Nature appears by no means ‘natural’ or unbiasedFootnote 48 —in fact, as we shall see in section 4 below, it is rather depicted as a highly culturalised entity, a real imago Imperii. Late antique literature always claims to be made of literature, and Ausonius can be considered a pioneer in such a self-conscious metaliterary ironical trend. But what he is depicting in this poem through all these sophisticated rhetorical devices is nonetheless a ‘revelation’, by definition a non-mediated experience.
Ausonius himself sums up his poetical procedure as a transformation of a previous visual experience—in this case a revelation—to the nonsense of words: mirandi stuporem transtuli ad ineptiam poetandi (‘I translated my amazed admiration [sc. produced by the vision of a picture] into insipid versification’, Auson. Cup. pref.). The question now is: what did Ausonius actually see in this face-to-face encounter with the river?
3. Ausonius' Autoptical Revelation: The Exhaustion of Gaze
The Mosella is in many senses a poem about vision. Fontaine has felicitously described it as a ‘kaléidoscope de “visions”’,Footnote 49 a sudden bombardment of visual stimuli able to exhaust the poet's gaze.Footnote 50 This multisensory experience, ultimately triggered by a direct contact with nature, is vividly expressed by the poem's lexicon: its careful selection, its sensory—and even sensuousFootnote 51 —connotations (particularly visual and chromatic), its extreme density and its combination within synaesthetic formulae point to an expanded perception of reality, bringing about a deeper insight into its secret underlying nature—what might be simply called a revelation. Let us consider the ecstasy of this wordless epiphany—the passage in which the poet, having passed though the many toils and uncertainties of the initiation journey described in section 1 above, enjoys for the first time a face-to-face encounter with the river (23-81). It is in that very moment that Ausonius finally penetrates the secrets hidden under the Moselle's transparent waters, suddenly disclosed to his once blind gaze. The poet manages to evoke the exhausting rapture of his senses over the overwhelming spectacle of nature—always made of an unutterable plethora of separate stimuli—by laying out a real lexical flood, as organised in the following schema:

This brief outline in the form of related semantic fields will be enough to demonstrate Ausonius' aesthetic concern for the visual and plastic character of his poetry.Footnote 52 The Mosella could indeed be described as a poem about vision and—metaphorically—about knowledge: uidi ego (‘I myself have seen’, 341) proudly declares Ausonius with regard to this enlightening autoptical experience. Let us consider now, at least briefly, the way in which these terms are significantly interwoven inside the poetic construct.
The words he uses do rarely have a chromatic sense by themselves, but they acquire it either by taking part of a visually connoted context (tu neque limigenis ripam praetexeris uluis, ‘thou with no mud-grown sedge fringest thy banks', 45) or by joining other terms specifically referring to colours or shades (lucetque latetque / calculus et uiridem distinguit glarea muscum, ‘pebbles gleam and are hid, and gravel picks out patches of green moss', 66f.). The usage of common words chromatically resemanticised as little colour brushstrokes must have been inherited mostly from Vergil's Eclogues, a constant source of intertextual borrowings and conscious recalls throughout the poem. In fact, line 45 echoes a passage of this very work—hic uiridis tenera praetexit harundine ripas / Mincius (‘here [the river] Mincius fringes his verdant banks with tender reeds', Verg. Ecl. 7.12f.)Footnote 53 —by stretching the already mentioned rhetorical resources to the limit: Ausonius dares indeed to delete every trace of chromatic terms, letting the implicit reader imagine by himself the alternating picture of green and sienna shades, whose rhythmical interval is vividly evoked by the subtle strategy of word order: limigenis ripam praetexeris uluis, ‘thou with no mud-grown sedge fringest thy banks' = sienna (limigenis) + green (ripam) + sienna (uluis). The permanence of Vergil's elided uiridis (sc. ripas) in the reader's mind guarantees the effectiveness of such an audacious colour depiction in absentia.
As for the other instance cited above (lucetque latetque / calculus et uiridem distinguit glarea muscum, ‘pebbles gleam and are hid, and gravel picks out patches of green moss', 66f.), it must be considered one of those rare non-intertextual displays of Ausonius' poetic skills. Let us set aside for the moment the alliterative polysyndetic oxymoron lucetque latetque (‘gleam and are hid’) in line 66, with which I shall deal later. Suffice it to remark in this context that the strong opposition of these two phonetically similar verbs within such a short phrase suggests a rhythmical alternation between light and shadow—in other words: chromatism. In line 67 we recognise one of the most felicitous examples of Ausonius' impressionistic brushstrokes: the adjective uiridis (‘green’) leads us to a chromatic reading of the originally non-chromatic nouns calculus (‘pebbles’), glarea (‘gravel’) and muscum (‘moss’), following the poetic technique described above. Ausonius creates a real mosaic in the river bed by putting together the infinite range of colours of the water pebbles on the green background of the bottom. What is more significant, he is able to paint such a gorgeous image by means of three simple rhetorical devices: in the first place, the alternating arrangement of the four chromatically connoted terms in a single line, carefully separating the semantically related couples (calculus-glarea, ‘pebbles-gravel’, as many-coloured tesserae; uiridem-muscum, ‘green-moss’, as a monochromatic mossy background); then, the semantic value of the verb itself (distinguit, ‘picks out, distinguishes’); last, the retinal permanence of the Phrygiae crustae (‘Phrygian slabs’) from line 48.
Ausonius is frequently quite audacious in elaborating those verbal pictures from intertextual sources, mostly by an extensive use of unexpected hypallages or surprising metaphors. Thus, resorting to well-known Vergilian material (Verg. G. 3.144: uiridissima gramine ripa, ‘where the banks are greenest with grass’), Ausonius manages to depict the reflection of the green banks on the water surface, by twisting the base text with an eloquent hypallage: consite gramineas, amnis uiridissime, ripas (‘o'ergrown, river most verdant, thy banks with turf’, 26). The colour adjective that should agree with ripas (‘banks’) according to the Vergilian model is now transferred to the syntagma of amnis (‘river’), which clearly works as a formal expression of an entirely visual content: the reproduction on the water surface of the chromatic qualities of the riversides as a result of their reflection. Once again we are driven to detect a highly iconic value in the word order. It does not appear to be a coincidence that the nominal group of the river is embraced by that of its banks (gramineas, amnis uiridissime, ripas) and is metrically announced by the penthemimeral caesura, a clear boundary between the outer and the inner (or reflected) world.
As already mentioned, the seductive and almost inebriating goal of such a sensuous vocabulary makes especially suitable resources like synaesthesia, broadly promoted by Vergil in his Eclogues, and frequently based on connotative values of the terms. Line 25 (amnis odorifero iuga uitea consite Baccho, ‘river, whose hills are o'ergrown with Bacchus' fragrant vines’) can be regarded as a perfect sample of that poetic procedure: amnis (coolness, humidity, tactile sensations) odorifero (scent, aroma) iuga (roughness of the arable land, sienna, ground elevation) uitea (greenness) consite (image of dissemination, dispersal) Baccho (burgundy shade, bouquet, taste). Note also the accusatiuus Graecus in iuga uitea, a clear symptom of Ausonius' contrived style and of the—often ironic—epic resonance of the piece.Footnote 54
Also metaphors are frequently used to lend more plasticity to the descriptions. And one of Ausonius' favourite metaphorical fields is—as listed above—that of Fine Arts. He considers the world before his eyes a naturae opus (‘handiwork of Nature’, 51) or a pictura (‘picture’, 68). The artistic lexis allows him to give form to the dichotomy between nature and artifice, which, according to Michael Roberts, constitutes a real leitmotiv in this poem.Footnote 55 This conceptual opposition, as eloquently expressed by the stunning oxymoron marmoreum…campum (‘an expanse [literally ‘field’] of marble’, 49), seems to be eventually resolved in favour of nature: thus is at least suggested by Ausonius' explicit statement in lines 50f. (ast ego despectis quae census opesque dederunt / naturae mirabor opus, ‘but I, scorning what wealth and riches have bestowed, will marvel at Nature's handiwork’), as well as in several other passages—the episode of fishing (240-82), the description of the riverside villas (283-348), etc. Nevertheless, that alleged ‘superiority’ of nature—as radically defended by NewlandsFootnote 56 —should be seriously reconsidered, provided that the Moselle works to some extent as a highly culturalised entity foreshadowing Rome, as I shall explain in the following section. It is not nature tout court that must be considered superior, but the Moselle River, both as a metaphor of Rome and as an enlightening principle for initiands.
That superiority of the Moselle over both naturalFootnote 57 and artificial realities—whatever the river itself is taken to mean—is precisely expressed by means of artistic lexis. The river, for instance, is often depicted in terms of an artist imitating—and superseding—not only nature (lacus imitate…riuos…potis aequiperare…fontes praecellere , ‘imitator of lakes…able to match brooks in flow…and to surpass springs’, 28-30) but also human artistry ( assimulant nostros imitata monilia cultus, ‘mimic necklaces counterfeit our fashions’, 72). With this implicit comparison Ausonius seems to be bringing back for his own purposes the old Aristotelian concept of mimesis, considerably enriched by the fitting connotations of water reflection.Footnote 58 There is no need to say our all-embracing river always wins the battle: omnia solus habes (‘one, thou hast all’, 31). Its many-coloured palette surpasses by far that of the artist—at least, that is what the singular chromatic enumeration in lines 69f. seems to be proudly proclaiming (uirides algas et rubra corallia…et albentes…bacas, ‘green seaweed and red coral and whitening pearls’). Not even the grass on the bottom of the river can remain monochromatic (non concolor, ‘of different hue’, 74).
This swift bombardment of painfully sharp close-ups, brought about by an unmediated perception of nature's synaesthetical spectacle, has the undesired effect of overwhelming the poet's senses, suddenly intoxicated with a joyful fatigue: intentos tamen usque oculos errore fatigant / interludentes, examina lubrica, pisces (‘though fixed upon the depths, the eyes grow weary with straying after fishes who in slippery shoals sport midway between’, 75f.).Footnote 59 A similar, though much more sombre, statement can be found in the fifth-century poet Rutilius Namatianus, who, echoing this very passage, faces the flimsiness of the then menaced Roman world with an exhausted gaze: defessis oculis (‘straining eyes’, Rut. Namat. 1.434).Footnote 60 If, according to my interpretation, the Mosella should be defined as a poem about vision, Rutilius Namatianus’ De Reditu is basically ‘a poem about blindness’, as I have proposed elsewhere.Footnote 61 Thus, the apparent coincidence of both late antique masterpieces in the metaphor of an exhausted gaze only confirms the enormous differences which separate them. But that is another question.
4. omnia solus habes: The World in a River's Disguise
In order to grasp the depth of the philosophical and literary stance underlying Ausonius' Mosella, we should begin by considering some of the richest metaphorical implications of the subject of the river, simultaneously conceived as imago Imperii (i.e., in its political dimension) and as speculum mundi (i.e., in its epistemological one, generally neglected by scholars).
The political dimension of the poem has been long discussed in the last decades, reaching sometimes conclusions that may seem quite contradictory. A good synthesis of such a burning question can be found in René Martin's Reference Martin1985 article, whose well-founded point of view I gladly assume—at least partially—in the next lines. To sum it up, Martin states that there is no convincing reason to deny the obvious political implications of the piece, although they could well be quite different from those traditionally proposed by Ternes in the slipstream of Marx.Footnote 62 Ternes tended to look at this poem as a direct and highly censored propagandistic carmen commendaticium aimed at promoting the Romanisation of the right side of the Rhine according to a hypothetical goal of Valentinian's agenda. Martin, on the contrary, suggests that the strong and unquestionable political implications of the piece seem to fit much better Ausonius' own point of view regarding the Empire and its coming challenges—as they were about to be faced up to by his pupil Gratianus, under the poet's direct inspiration.Footnote 63 Nowadays there is no reasonable doubt about the political spirit of the poem, whatever its real extent and its exact proposals may have been.Footnote 64 The Moselle was after all the river that bathed the walls of Trier, at that time capital of the Western world and permanent residence of the Emperor, a fact that would be enough by itself to prevent it from lacking political connotations.
These considerations lead us to a first and extremely relevant assumption: that the Moselle in Ausonius' work foreshadows the Empire itself and, as a logical extension, the whole of classical civilisation. Martin would probably agree with this assertion, since he himself points out that ‘de cette œuvre l'un des thèmes récurrents, le plus constant et le plus important peut-être, est que le pays trévire est en quelque sorte tout à la fois une Italie en miniature et une véritable synthèse du monde gréco-romain’.Footnote 65 Martin's paper lavishly proves and justifies this statement by bringing forth a plethora of textual instances taken from the poem.Footnote 66 One more could be added to his list, hopefully not less convincing: the eloquent expression omnia solus habes (‘one, thou hast all’, Auson. Mos. 31)Footnote 67 by which the Moselle is praised above all as a sum of the individual virtues of the fountain (fons), the stream (riuus), the river (amnis), the lake (lacus) and the ocean (pontus), that is to say, as a compendium of every comparable reality. This expression clearly echoes the almost identicalFootnote 68 omnia solus habens atque omnia dilargitus (‘alone holding all though he has all distributed’) that Ausonius himself had dedicated not so long agoFootnote 69 to the emperor Valentinian I in his Versus Paschales (Auson. Vers. pasch. 4.28 Green [Reference Green1991]). As is well known, that piece enacts a praise to the three members of the reigning house (Valentinian, his brother Valens and his son Gratianus) by means of an audacious comparison with the three persons of the Holy Trinity, foreshadowed on earth by this majestic dynasty. Valentinian, by sharing his all-embracing power with his brother and his son (omnia dilargitus, ‘he has all distributed’), does not divide his own might but increases it, achieving a real unity able to grasp the whole Empire in its natural diversity (omnia solus habens, ‘alone holding all’).Footnote 70 From this perspective it seems quite evident that the parallel expression omnia solus habes now addressed to the river tinges its waters with a clear political meaning: the Moselle can be seen in this sense as a powerful metaphor of Rome and its Government throughout the world as embodied in the person of the Emperor(s). As a symbol of a whole new way of understanding reality, the Moselle can put together the vast diversity of everything existing and reunite it under a deeper unifying power. Just like Rome, it contains everything, it makes all one.
A clear semantic parallel can be found at the very beginning of Rutilius Namatianus' De Reditu, the so-called Romae laus or praise of Rome: fecisti patriam diuersis gentibus unam (‘you have made a single fatherland out of various nations’, 1.63).Footnote 71 This text shares with Ausonius' work a clear hymnic toneFootnote 72 which reinforces my vision of the poem as symbolic praise of the Empire in its new geographical and psychological context.Footnote 73 But unlike Namatianus' pessimistic centralism (always attached to the materiality of the wounded urbs aeterna), Ausonius does not seem to perceive any symptom of a tragic blurring of Rome under that eloquent transfer of power to Trier, at the very heart of the barbarian world. On the contrary, he optimistically celebrates this new translatio Imperii as a sign of the survival and definitive universalisation of Rome's civilising power. The underlying idea is always the same: Rome—hidden in Ausonius' text under the appearance of a river—reunites under the same power the whole diversity of the world and thus it can be seen as a speculum mundi or as a way of depicting reality. In a more abstract approach to this unifying character of the Empire in a river's disguise, the Moselle can be taken as an eloquent image of a particular way of looking at reality, in fact, the only way in which reality could be grasped in late antiquity. Thus, according to my symbolic interpretation, knowledge and politics can be joined together under the same image: the river.
The Mosella is a political poem too in its continuous allusive play with the political poem par excellence, Vergil's Aeneid and the whole corpus of Vergilian poetry, particularly his Georgics. Vergil is indeed one of the most frequent intertextual sources throughout the poem,Footnote 74 a constant point of reference (either for agreement or rejection) in the construction of the new political ethos, whether it be considered the expression of Valentinian's actual programme or of Ausonius' wishful thinking. As he himself clearly suggests, Ausonius is meant to be for the Moselle (i.e., the late antique West) the poetical equivalent of Vergil for the Tiber (i.e., the Augustan Empire).Footnote 75 In fact, in his second and definitive salutatio to the river (Mos. 381) he appropriates the famous initial verses of Vergil's laus Italiae (Verg. G. 2.173f.): salue, magna parens frugum, Saturnia tellus, / magna uirum (‘hail, land of Saturn, mighty mother of earth's fruits, mighty mother of men’). This intertextual dialogue confirms the equivalence between the Moselle and the Roman world in its entirety that had been subtly traced throughout the poem: salue, magne parens frugumque uirumque Mosella (‘hail, mighty mother both of fruits and men, o Moselle’, Mos. 381). As Alvar Ezquerra points out in relation to this very passage, ‘si el Lacio fue grande por lo que tuvo y porque hubo un gran poeta que lo cantó, también el Mosela tiene un poeta que lo ensalza con palabras pariguales’.Footnote 76 Moreover, it does not seem to be sheer coincidence that Symmachus, in his well known letter to Ausonius complaining that he has not been sent a copy of his already worldwide spread Mosella (Symm. Epist. 1.14), dares openly to compare Ausonius' implicitly imperial river with the Tiber itself,Footnote 77 thus equating Vergil's Aeneid with Ausonius' work (ego hoc tuum carmen libris Maronis adiungo). Such authoritative reception of the political and symbolic meaning of Ausonius' poem seems to confirm the dialogic contrast between those two ways of understanding an imperial ‘epic’, and, to use a Bloomian term,Footnote 78 Ausonius' real anxiety of influence towards his Vergilian forebear.
But there is still an essential detail in that symbolic construction which has been generally overlooked by scholars: in a time when epic tout court was no longer a practicable genre Ausonius dares to enact a kind of post-Aeneid representing the most powerful empire worldwide under the unexpected image of a river. Rome in a river's disguise is not precisely what one would call an automatic metaphorical link. The river had already a long literary tradition in Ausonius' times as an image of the ever-changing, the fleetingness, the ungraspable, the slippery Heraclitean flowing of the always unstable reality. By no means could it be considered the ideal image to praise the intended stability and solidity of the Roman Empire and it could hardly fit a real imperial propaganda programme. These characteristics of the river are precisely the ones Ausonius underlines throughout his poem. As Carole Newlands points out, Ausonius challenges the ‘static picture’ of reflection traced by his model Statius and ‘emphasises the movement of the water’ with a rosary of specular images always ‘full of natural life’.Footnote 79 With his surprising choice of the image of a river and with his constant emphasis on its eternal movement and flimsiness, Ausonius seems to be problematising the identity of Rome as the highest ever ‘meta-narrative of legitimation’ (as the postmodern philosopher Jean-François Lyotard would call it).Footnote 80 The river actually functions as a questioning imago Imperii, a metaphor of late antique Rome—changing, unsure but not deprived of certain optimism. At the same time, in its capacity of containing all that exists (omnia solus habes, 31), it will allow us to reach some interesting conclusions of how reality as a whole was perceived in the late western world, thus gaining a privileged access to that time's underlying episteme.
5. The River as Epistemological Metaphor: Knowledge and Language in Ausonius' Poetics
The image of the river (or the fountain) as a vehicle of knowledge has a centuries-old tradition, both in Latin and Greek literature. It is found, for instance, in Callimachus' Hymns 5 and 6Footnote 81 and its presence is still attested well into the late Byzantine era.Footnote 82 This metaphorical association between water and wisdom did not diminish but was even strengthened with the arrival of Christianity, a key element in the forging of late antique culture.Footnote 83 Much in the same vein, that time's flowering Neo-Platonism made an extensive use of the image of the river both for philosophical and exegetical purposes.Footnote 84 Plotinus himself uses the river as a metaphor for the emanation of the multiple out of the One in Enn. 3.8.10. This Plotinian text implies that man's only mission is that of swimming upriver to reach the utmost depths of his own soul, i.e., the inexhaustible spring from which the river of reality continuously flows. It is worth mentioning that, like Ausonius' Moselle, Plotinus' river is taken to encompass the whole of the existing (omnia solus habes), that is, the kaleidoscopic multiplicity of everyday reality, which, quite paradoxically, makes possible the soul's ascent to the ultimate revelation: the underlying Oneness of all things.
In Ausonius' poem, the river is famously described according to two outstanding features, quite eloquent if considered from this novel perspective: its transparency (i.e., its capacity of revealing its inner deepness) and its reflectivity (i.e., its ability to reflect the outer world).Footnote 85 Only careful attention to these two metaphorical modalities of knowledge can lead us to a broader and more nuanced approach to the epistemological status of Ausonius' poetics. For the first one—the transparency or, in other words, our possibility of accessing an underlying reality—I shall briefly reexamine the passage describing Ausonius' autoptical revelation (Mos. 23-81). As for the second one—the reflexivity or the way in which that reality can be captured into the narrow frame of its verbal (or non verbal) representation—I shall consider three key texts: Mos. 186-88 (the poet's plea for speaking), 189-239 (the sailors deluded by their watery reflections)Footnote 86 and 438-83 (the poem's epilogue). Thus we shall be able to cover the Foucauldian abyss between words and things (les mots et les choses).Footnote 87
5.1 Transparency: A Doorway to Reality (les choses)
Let us consider again Mos. 23-81 (the peak of Ausonius' revelation) in search of the poem's underlying theory of vision/knowledge.
The loss of the feeling of stability and hierarchical order in the Universe—followed by a structural crisis of the anthropological model of Classical Antiquity, which conceived the virtuous man as a uir bonus dicendi peritus (‘a good man skilled in the art of speaking’),Footnote 88 thus binding together ethics and eloquence, reality and language—brought about a new way of facing reality. Now the particular prevails over the general, and therefore, the consciousness of the individuality, mutability and perishability of concrete entities (the only ones whose existence is not openly questioned)Footnote 89 becomes the lens through which the world is observed. Language and conceptual thinking, which necessarily entail generalisation, mediation and absence, are distrusted as effective means to grasp reality, while a new epistemological paradigm emerges with strength: that of wordless contemplation, sharp concreteness, immediate presence and bewildered awe.
Ausonius' felicitous pun lucetque latetque (‘gleam and are hid’, 66) does admirably and very synthetically condense—as expected of a man with his sound rhetorical background—this new way of looking at reality. To this end, he deliberately uses the rhetorical device of oxymoron (bringing to mind the mystics' coincidentia oppositorum), which brings opposite traces of reality face to face on the same level, in open contradiction with the classical notion of the continuity and stable permanence of being. This astonishing gathering of the opposite, of what is and what is no more, is successfully remarked by a significant alliteration of the sound [l] combined with plosive phonemes. The rhetorical mastery of Ausonius enables him to concentrate such a blurred concept into just a couple of orthographic words (the enclitic -que is never written separately) and to emphasise its meaning with other levelling devices such as isosyllaby, homoeoteleuton and polysyndeton. In this way, he increases the formal and phonetic similarities of both terms (only the vowel-consonant binomial u/a - c/t makes them different) in open contrast with their radical semantic opposition. This real display of eloquence enacts almost visually the underlying sense of a hidden epistemological metaphor: it hints that the most subtle variation in the conditions of a virtually stable reality produces deep changes in its ontological constitution. Therefore, everything that exists must be seen as discontinuous, unseizable and ultimately unutterable; there is no way to represent an ever-changing world, always new and always different, like Heraclitus' ever-flowing river.Footnote 90
The meaningful presence in the poem of that border zone within what is now but immediately fades away—namely, the Heraclitean stream of reality—can be clearly recognised in the wording discussed in section 3 and included in the table on p.241 above under the rubric ‘Terms related to sight and concealment’. The recurrent image of the ever-flowing water and the blowing windFootnote 91 helps to build up such a strong metaphor of flimsiness and—what is still more significant—of the way in which reality could be known in Ausonius' time. Knowledge indeed cannot consist in a mere extrapolation of universal truths any more, since these—like the firm sand of the Moselle's banks (solidae…harenae, 53)—are definitively unable to hold the irreducible specificity of each concrete being or figure: nec retinent memores uestigia pressa figuras (‘and the foot resting on them [the firm sands] leaves no recording print behind’, 54).Footnote 92 The real knowledge, the only kind still feasible at the end of the Empire, is that emanating from the pure contemplation of individual entities, always contingent, irreducible and mutable. This explains Ausonius' eagerness for catalogues (the quintessential ‘asyntactic’ structure) throughout the poem,Footnote 93 as well as his Mannerist thoroughness in describing and enumerating the most insignificant detailsFootnote 94 —that is in fact a general aesthetic trend of the whole late antique period, whose origin can be ultimately traced in the new epistemological principles that I am trying to identify in this article.Footnote 95
The most plastic metaphor for this new and unprecedented fragmentary model of knowledge is the transparency of the flowing waters of the Moselle,Footnote 96 which reveal every particular being as a distinctive, unique, separate entity, eschewing any intention of investing it with a global sense which it perhaps never had: liquidarum et lapsus aquarum / prodit caerulea dispersas luce figuras (‘and thy waters limpid-gliding reveal in azure light shapes scattered here and there’, 61f.). These dispersas figuras (‘shapes scattered here and there’) that the river so disjointedly reflects are listed in detail in the following lines, showing the specific features or ‘traces’ that make them unique and thus reinforcing their concreteness: sulcata leui…harena meatu (‘how the furrowed sand is rippled by the light current’, 63),Footnote 97 inclinata…uiridi…gramina fundo (‘how the bowed water-grasses quiver in thy green bed’, 64), agitatae fontibus herbae (‘the tossing plants endure the water's buffeting’, 65), lucetque latetque / calculus et uiridem distinguit Footnote 98 glarea muscum (‘pebbles gleam and are hid, and gravel picks out patches of green moss’, 66f.). Following our interpretation, the pronounced contrast between the semantic value of 54 (nec retinent memores uestigia pressa figuras, ‘and the foot resting on them [the firm sands] leaves no recording print behind’) and that of 62 (prodit caerulea dispersas luce figuras, ‘[thy waters] reveal in azure light shapes scattered here and there’) enacts a confrontation between two antithetical knowledge systems: the one of the general traces (uestigia pressa) or concepts (memores…figuras)—refused as already seen by the hard sands of the Moselle's bank (nec retinent)—, and the one of the isolated individual entities (dispersas figuras), which cannot be represented under the label of a single unifying word.Footnote 99 This strong opposition between these two conflicting Weltanschauungen is formally emphasised by the repetition of the word figuras at the end of both verses (aesthetically and rhythmically marked for the sake of the following pause and of the metrical cadence). The adjectives modifying these two conflicting figuras are revealingly distinctive: memores in 54 hints at the ideas of memory, absence, mediation, reproduction, conceptualisation and language, whereas dispersas in 62 evokes the notions of scatteredness, presence, immediacy, irreducibility and individual concreteness. In addition, this lexical recurrence at the very end of both verses plays with the iconic suggestion of the reflection on the river water (figuras in 54 reflected as figuras in 62), thus giving a foretaste of the poem's second major epistemological metaphor: that of reflection (i.e. mediated vision). Needless to say, the epistemological paradigm embodied in the memores figuras of 54 has no place in the realm of direct vision and wordless revelation described in this section of the poem (hence the negation nec). From this exegetical perspective, it will be easier to understand what Ausonius meant with that demersa …intima (‘things whelmed far below’, 59) and arcani…penetrale profundi (‘the recesses of thy secret depth’, 60), and to what extent, by means of the metaphor of a river which does not hide anything to our eager gaze (secreti nihil amnis habens, ‘a river keeping naught concealed’, 56), to us are openly revealed (aperto / panditur intuitu, ‘…lies clear and open to our gaze’, 56f.), without any shadow or delusion (patet, ‘lies open’, 60), the real nature of things, going far beyond any possible conceptualisation.
Ausonius' situation is quite similar to that of ‘Funes el memorioso’ in Jorge Luis Borges' homonymous tale—a man who was able to remember everything he saw, and therefore was
almost incapable of ideas of a general, Platonic sort. Not only was it difficult for him to comprehend that the generic symbol dog embraces so many unlike individuals of diverse size and form; it bothered him that the dog at three fourteen (seen from the side) should have the same name as the dog at three fifteen (seen from the front).Footnote 100
The shocking concreteness of the world destroys every possibility of building up any general reflection or theory on reality. It is only its irreducible multiplicity that prevails.Footnote 101 From that point, the poet cannot dream of creating an all-embracing, self-consistent representation of the whole: like Baudelaire's celebrated artiste chiffonnier or the carefree flâneur of Le Peintre de la vie moderne (1863), he is simply called to recollect some of the fragments or disiecta membra of the plethora of unconnected stimuli around him. That is in a sense Ausonius' initiatic revelation in this poem and one of the most characteristic features of the late antique aesthetics as a whole, always favouring the particular over the general, the fragmentary detail, the disjointed catalogue, the unending enumeration, the single word over the coherent period, and other similar phenomena.Footnote 102
Paradoxically enough, much in the same vein of Plotinus' philosophy and Anchises' all-embracing anima mundi (Verg. Aen. 6.725-29), the sharp awareness of the extreme concreteness, mutability and individuality of every single entity leads Ausonius to the joyful realisation of the ultimate unity of all things (omnia solus habes, ‘one, thou hast all’, 31), as if the radical immanence of all those details had brought him to the utmost form of epistemological transcendence. Both aspects are indeed inextricably interwoven in his watery revelation, thus turning a random collection of extremely detailed close-ups into a privileged intuition of the whole (or, in cinematic terms, a long shot). The poem itself is but the verbal celebration of that wordless realisation, a praise of the unutterable mystery pervading the irreducible multifariousness of the real. Thus, Ausonius' experience of transparency could be perfectly summarised in the following passage of Plotinus (Enn. 5.8.4.4-8):Footnote 103
All things are transparent, and there is nothing dark or resistant, but each thing is clear for all others right down to its innermost parts, for light is clear to light. Indeed, each has everything within it, and again sees all things in any other, so that all things are everywhere, everything is everything, each individual is all things, and the splendour is without end.
(tr. Chase, adapted)But what can we say about the way in which those disjointed ungraspable entities so graphically revealed by the Moselle waters can be ‘reflected’ or represented by means of human language?
5.2 Reflectivity: The (Im)possibility of Representation (les mots)
Let us briefly recapitulate to see exactly where we are. After a hard initiation journey through Plato's cave and Vergil's Underworld (1-22), the long-awaited revelation has finally happened (23-81). Like Aeneas, Ausonius has reached the hidden river which erases all secrets (the Moselle/Lethe): secreti nihil amnis habens (‘a river keeping naught concealed’, 56). There he feels suddenly at home;Footnote 104 there everything seems to make sense. For the first time in his life, he can really see (et tandem…conspicor, 10; spectaris, 55; durante…uisu / cernimus, 59f.; uidi egomet, 270; uidi ego, 341). The Roman heroes waiting to be (re)born by the banks of the river Lethe in Vergil's epic (Aen. 6.752-892) are half-mockingly transformed into the swift-swimming fish dwelling in the transparent depths of the Moselle (82-149). The landscape around the river has suddenly taken the shape of a big theatre, as if it had been deliberately designed to enhance the spectator's faculty of vision (150-68). River nymphs, Pans and other minor deities fill the atmosphere with an indescribable numinous sensation (169-85).
Following the story line of Plato's myth, the time has come for the enlightened poet to ‘return’ to his fellows, in order to reveal to them what he has seen outside the cave, what reality is all about. Ausonius aspires to become a new Er, the only mortal who, according to Plato's account (Resp. 10.614b-621b), was able to return from the Underworld without forgetting what he had seen (he had wisely avoided drinking of the waters of the river Lethe), thus becoming a privileged teacher of the unspeakable secrets of life and death. Like Aeneas (and Ulysses before him), Ausonius wants to be able to go safely out of the Underworld and transmit its ineffable mysteries to future generations of mystae. In his own words:
But of these things which no man has looked upon and no eye beheld, be it no sin for me to speak in part: let Reverence be covered in her seclusion, and let her dwell unspied upon, in the safe-keeping of her native streams.
(tr. Evelyn White)Not surprisingly, this passage is intertextually modelled on Book 6 of the Aeneid, which is probably the most crucial hypotext underlying the whole poem. The exact intertext in this case, corresponding to Vergil's invocation to the underworld deities as he prepares to relate Aeneas' katabasis, is Aen. 6.266f.: sit mihi fas audita loqui, sit numine uestro / pandere res alta terra et caligine mersas (‘say it's right to give voice to the things I have heard of, / grant your assent to disclose what's submerged in the earth's pit of darkness’).Footnote 105 The expression pro parte loqui (‘to speak in part’) would immediately remind any fourth-century Christian of Paul's famous assertion on the insurmountable limits of human knowledge and language (1 Cor. 13.9-10): ex parte enim cognoscimus et ex parte prophetamus: cum autem uenerit quod perfectum est, euacuabitur quod ex parte est (‘for we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when the perfect comes, the partial will pass away’).Footnote 106 Ausonius is asking for divine permission to relate to his readers what he (and he alone) has seen, even if the natural limitations of human language will only allow him to do it ‘in part’ (pro parte).
This short passage (186-88) serves as a transition to the second half of the poem, which will basically tackle the different ways in which human artifice (including language) vainly strives to reflect, emulate or appropriate the ineffable mysteries of the river: the transparency which once enabled a direct contemplation of the riverbed (23-81) is now threatened by the deceits of watery reflection (189-239), the swift-swimming fish (82-149) by the greedy fishermen (240-82), the natural landscape (150-68) by human architecture (283-348), and the mythological dwellers (159-85) by the simple peoples of the land (381-417). Thus the second part of the poem (from line 189 onwards) is conceived to a great extent as a problematic mirror image—full of playful conceptual and thematic correspondences—of the first one, which was entirely dominated by the idea of a non-mediated vision. The poem's structure can be summarised in the diagram on p.257 below. Meaningfully enough, the passage immediately following Ausonius' entreaty to put into words his ineffable revelation (186-88) already introduces the principal epistemological metaphor in this part of the poem: that of the river as a deceptive mirror (189-239).Footnote 107
The metaphor of reflection and its problematic way of grasping the outer world is a constant in late antique thinking, both pagan and Christian. The best example is again to be found in the 13th chapter of Paul's First Epistle to the Corinthians (1 Cor. 13.12-13), one of the biblical texts most frequently quoted by Augustine of Hippo: uidemus nunc per speculum in aenigmate, tunc autem facie ad faciem; nunc cognosco ex parte, tunc autem cognoscam sicut et cognitus sum (‘for now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face; now I know in part, but then I shall know fully, even as I have been fully known’). Reality as ordinarily (nunc) perceived through senses, emotions or conceptual thinking (i.e. as thought and expressed by language) is but a pale reflection of what things really are. Thus the knowledge provided by all those mediating entities, acting on reality as a distorting mirror (per speculum), is always partial (ex parte) and unreliable (in aenigmate). In order to gain an insight into how things really are (tunc autem cognoscam sicut et cognitus sum), it is necessary to attain to an extended unmediated (facie ad faciem) vision, much similar to the one attained by Ausonius in his river epiphany.Footnote 109 The problem is that such non-discursive knowledge cannot be committed to words, but merely hinted at or, in Ausonius' terms (pretty near to those of Paul), ‘spoken in part’ (pro parte loqui, 187).

As might be expected, Ausonius consistently depicts the water reflections as deceptive and distorting, in an implicit contrast with his direct unutterable look at the extreme concreteness of reality in the bottom of the river (as argued above). The lexis used to characterise such dubious ‘representations’ of the outer world is eloquent by itself: fallaces…figuras (‘illusive forms’, 229); ambiguis…ueri falsique figuris (‘shapes which waver between false and true’, 239); sese amni confundit imago (‘the pictured hill blends [lit. is confused] with the river’, 198); etc. It was almost in the same period that Augustine had to deal with the Platonic problem of the falsehood of art,Footnote 110 reaching quite a good understanding of the phenomenon of representation (explicitly equated with a mirror) and its intrinsic need to fake reality.Footnote 111 Many of his philosophical assertions are near to those of Ausonius as described here, though of course mutatis mutandis.
According to Ausonius, the greatest mistake (both of classical society and literature) is to consider reflection a reliable representation of the existing. Doing so implies the same naivety that can be found in a little girl trying to grasp her twin face at the other side of the mirror, acritically fascinated by its external likeness—that is precisely the comparison Ausonius proposes in lines 231-38. This is particularly apparent in line 234 (germanaeque putat formam spectare puellae, ‘deeming she gazes on the shape of a real girl [or “twin sister”]’), a whole theory of art on its own.Footnote 112 The risk of confusing reality and its representation, les mots et les choses, is always a threat to be seriously considered. It is not precisely a rare phenomenon, but something that does happen quite frequently: see for instance the derisus nauita (‘deluded boatman’, 196) trying to number the reflected vines, or the confused nautas (‘sailors’) of 222-39, deceived—and at the same time amused—by their images reflected on the river water, or, in a more abstract approach, the classical theory of sign and its psychological and cultural consequences. In this sense Ornella Fuoco has rightly suggested that the abrupt enjambment between imago (the reflection) and collis (its outer referent) in lines 198f. is rhetorically enacting the abyss between reality and its representation.Footnote 113 Once more, it is the rhetorical form that betrays Ausonius' most subtle underlying considerations, as one would expect from his undoubted stylistic mastery.
As rightly suggested by Fuoco and Taylor,Footnote 114 the whole passage seems to be implicitly evoking the Narcissus myth, most likely in its Ovidian rendition (Met. 3.339-510).Footnote 115 This unavoidable cultural reference is certainly far from innocent or unmotivated. Narcissus' delusion had indeed become a key epistemological metaphor in contemporary Neo-Platonism, as apparent from Plotinus himself (Enn. 1.6.8.8):Footnote 116
For if a man runs to the image and wants to seize it as if it was the reality (like a beautiful reflection playing on the water, which some story somewhere, I think, said riddlingly a man [Narcissus] wanted to catch and sank down into the stream and disappeared) then this man who clings to beautiful bodies and will not let them go, will, like the man in the story, but in soul, not in body, sink down into the dark depths where intellect has no delight, and stay blind in Hades, consorting with shadows there and here.
(tr. Armstrong)Much in the same vein, Pythagoreans explicitly warned against looking at oneself in the mirror or in any reflecting surface, most particularly in the waters of a river.Footnote 117 The risk is always the same: getting trapped in a world of illusion and appearance. The only way out of this labyrinth of false reflections is to follow the steps of Ulysses, who, like Aeneas in the sixth book of the Aeneid, managed to escape alive from the depths of the Underworld, as well as from the treacherous arms of the sensuous Circe and her deceiving fictions. Only thus will we be able to return where we belong—our spiritual homeland, our Anchises, our inner Bordeaux (Plot. Enn. 1.6.8.8):
This would be truer advice ‘Let us fly to our dear country’ [Hom. Il. 2.140]. What then is our way of escape, and how are we to find it? We shall pull out to sea, as Odysseus did, from the witch Circe or Calypso—as the poet says (I think with a hidden meaning)—and was not content to stay though he had delights of the eyes and lived among much beauty of sense. Our country from which we came is there, our Father is there.
(tr. Armstrong)It is precisely in order to avoid those frequent confusions between les mots et les choses, the illusory and the real, that Ausonius seems to be keen to emphasise the postmodern idea of the absence of a real referent under its alleged verbal ‘reflection’ (et tremit absens / pampinus, ‘here quivers the far-off [lit. absent] tendril of the vine’, 194f.). Reflections—and in consequence, the language and literature made of them—are autonomous images by themselves, without a necessary link with the outer world. Therefore, the sign is itself a problematic ‘other thing’ added to the ungraspable referential world, never its literal reflection: unda refert alios, simulacra umentia, nautas (‘the wave reflects “other” sailors—wet simulacra’, 227).Footnote 118 The inverted images on the water and on the surface of the child's mirror (inuersi corporis, ‘downward form’, 224) are by themselves an evident distortion of reality, never its faithful refection. The conclusion of such verifications seems to be quite obvious: literature and, generally speaking, the realm of the word and the representation are governed by their own rules, always unconcerned with the outer-world criterion of truth/falsehood.
That means that language and representation can allude—strictly speaking—just to themselves but not to an outer reality, as Derridean deconstruction would argue centuries later. ‘Through words’—Augustine of Hippo categorically states—‘we learn nothing but words, or I should rather say the sound and noise of words' (uerbis igitur nisi uerba non discimus, immo sonitum strepitumque uerborum).Footnote 119 Words are, in this sense, mere simulacra of simulacra:Footnote 120 simulacra umentia (228), simulamine (229),Footnote 121 signs without referents, words speaking of words. In this context, it is hardly surprising that Ausonius' most frequently used word should be precisely nomen (‘name’), as shown by Georgia Nugent.Footnote 122 Ausonius, the rhetor, is genuinely obsessed with words, maybe because he knows how unutterable reality is and how unreliable the idea itself of representation proves to be (always similar to an optical illusion on the ever-changing surface of the Moselle). Like almost all late antique authors, his works explicitly underline their own artificiality, their absolute lack of originality in the sense of an ideal creation ex nihilo. His works are always keen to betray themselves by showing to what extent they are just a sum of previous texts, dispassionately appropriated and often ironically recombined. An extreme example of this would be his irreverent Cento Nuptialis.Footnote 123 The starting point of such aesthetic behaviour is to be found in the profound scepticism towards representation that we are trying to depict here.
As one could easily infer, their absolute lack of connection with the real world disqualifies words from predicating any truth of the existing entities. More precisely, the criterion of truth/falsehood is itself irrelevant when dealing with representations (they have their own rules and laws, only valid for the conceptual—not for the real—realm). That is exactly what Ausonius is suggesting with his provocative ambiguis fruitur ueri falsique figuris (‘the lads afloat amuse themselves with shapes which waver between false and true’, 239). That is undoubtedly a great conceptual advance in the context of classical theory of fiction and art, a polemic verification with an enormous influence in the way late antique literature had to think itself henceforth. The deliberate cancellation of the classical dichotomy between true and false enacted by line 239 ultimately refers to the two portals found by Aeneas in his way out of the Underworld (Verg. Aen. 6.893-98): the gate of horn (described as the passageway of true visions) and the gate of ivory (whence pass false dreams). Like Aeneas, anyone who attempts to render such ineffable experience into words is bound to choose the gate of deluding reflections. Returning to everyday reality after having experienced a direct vision of what really is entails returning to the lies and distortions of appearance, to the world of false perceptions.Footnote 124
The only plausible attitude towards signs is to enjoy them precisely for what they are, and not as a blind pretention of capturing the always slippery reality or as a desperate attempt to reveal any transcendental truth. Ausonius indeed invites us just to enjoy (ambiguis fruitur ueri falsique figuris, ‘the lads afloat amuse themselves with shapes which waver between false and true’, 239; illa fruenda palam species, ‘yon is a sight that may be freely enjoyed’, 189) the sensory show that images (language) provide us with, forgetting all desire of embracing the ever absent reality, which is never to be told but to be non-discursively experienced.Footnote 125 That explains the often criticised playful attitude of many late antique authors and their ironic, irreverent, self-conscious and even frivolous approach to the phenomenon of literature.Footnote 126 Sure enough, late antiquity keeps an always healthy ironische Verfremdung towards the supposed transcendence of art and representation. This open vindication of the pure—almost sensuous—pleasure of forms led on occasions to an intransitive model of communication, without any actual ‘what’ to be transmitted.Footnote 127 That is obviously behind the frequently misunderstood aestheticism, in other words, the esprit précieux, so typical of late antique poetics. In this sense it would be also worth remarking the continuous presence throughout Ausonius' poem of lexis directly related to all kinds of visual and theatrical spectacles: inducant aliam spectacula uitea pompam (‘let show of vines lead on another pageant’, 152); naturalique theatro (‘natural theatre’, 156); haec quoque tam dulces celebrant spectacula pompas (‘how pleasing is the pageant which this sight affords!’, 200); etc. All in all, literature is made to be enjoyed as a sophisticated and always entertaining verbal show. If words do not lead to reality, let them be even greater. Art betrays art with a highly meta-literary device.
In short, what we are dealing with here is a most peculiar anti-myth of the Cave, where Platonic concepts (words, ideas, abstractions) have proved to be deceitful illusions, while the irreducible concreteness of the existing is definitively to be considered the only reality ever, always unutterable and ungraspable. Quite mysteriously, the ultimate oneness and sacredness of all things can only be discovered by a realisation of the distinct and well-defined individuality of every single entity, as revealed by the magnifying glass of the Moselle. Ausonius, having ‘initiatically’ received that epistemological revelation, has decided to share it with us through the culturally loaded and highly ambivalent metaphor of the river, and thus deliver art from the constricting chains of traditional ideas on reality and representation. The poet himself humbly declares his intentions in the poem's epilogue:
Such is my theme—I…, Ausonius…: great is my daring though my lute is small. Be it no sin for me to have touched lightly on thy holy stream with the poor offering my Muse affords. ’Tis not for praise I hanker: I sue for pardon. Many thou hast, o gentle stream, who use to trouble the rills of the Aonian maids and drain all Aganippe. But as for me, so far as the flow of my poetic vein shall serve,…I will pursue yet further the praises of thy Northern stream. I will tell also of cities below which with voiceless channel thou dost glide, of strongholds which look out on thee from ancient walls; I will tell also of fortresses raised for defence in times of peril, now not fortresses but granaries for the unmenaced Belgic folk; I will tell also of prosperous settlers upon either shore, and how thy waters lap their banks midway between the toils of men and oxen, parting the rich fields.
(tr. Evelyn White)This epilogue clearly states that the ultimate mission of the poet is trying to say the unsayable to make it accessible to all humankind.Footnote 128 As long as Ausonius lives, he will keep on praising the sacred waters of the Moselle (453), indefatigably challenging the limitations of human language: ‘I will tell… I will tell… I will tell…’ (454, 456, 458). Eloquently enough, the verb here thrice repeated is addam (literally ‘I will add’) instead of the more common dicam or loquar (‘I will say’). The poet, like Borges' character in the epigraph heading this article, has finally realised that language cannot say reality (that is, replace it as its perfect counterpart, re-present it), but only be added to it as just another thing in the world. Ausonius has merely thrown a small glass of water (his poem) into the ineffable waters of the Moselle (reality): fas mihi sacrum / perstrinxisse amnem tenui libamine Musae (‘be it no sin for me to have touched lightly on thy holy stream with the poor offering [literally, ‘libation’, i.e., a ritual pouring of a liquid as an offering to a god] my Muse affords', 443f.). The poet apologises for having poured a humble offering of words into the ineffable waters of the Moselle, that is, for having tried to carry out his impossible but necessary task.
The metaphor of the river, as reality itself, is intrinsically ambivalent: for the initiand, it is a vehicle of knowledge and enlightenment, a magnifying glass always ready to disclose its many secrets; for the lay Narcissus and the Moselle's simple sailors, it is a mortal trap of deceptive appearances and deluding reflections. It all depends on the attitude of the one who approaches its sacred waters, be it Ulysses, Aeneas, Er or the ill-fated Narcissus. The mission of humankind ultimately consists in going beyond reflections, transcending language, passing to the other side of the mirror (remember the transieram opening the poem), in order to turn it into a magnifying glass, that is, into an instrument capable of revealing what is hidden, invisible, latent, though always there: the profoundest essence of all things. Returning from such experience in the realm of the unsayable with the aim of committing it to words necessarily implies going out of the Underworld through the gate of ivory (that of false dreams),Footnote 129 since a trace of falsehood is inherent in any verbal representation of the Ultimate Reality. We can only speak ‘in part’, through the deceiving game of reflections in which human language ultimately consists. The task may seem impossible, but in Ausonius' opinion it is definitely worth a try.
