The reference to human rights has become an increasingly global phenomenon, found not only among governments, international bodies and non-governmental organisations, but also among poor and illiterate indigenous peoples and other marginalised groups. While the different actors appear to agree on the importance of protecting human rights, they employ converging, sometimes even colliding, definitions and modes for implementation. Clearly, the rights discourse has become an important, highly contested political arena for actors with diverse interests. In this important monograph, Christine Kovic lets us partake of the notions of human rights among a group of poor, Catholic Maya in the highlands of Chiapas, Mexico, and how these perceptions guide their work to defend what they define as their central rights, and to demand political change.
The book is centred on a group of Catholic believers in a poor Maya neighbourhood, called ‘Guadalupe’ in the book, in the outskirts of San Cristóbal de Las Casas. Like many other Maya newcomers of Catholic or different Protestant denominations to the town, they have been expelled from their rural home communities after they converted, accused of having abandoned the faith and traditions of their ancestors. The Catholics in Guadalupe have been expelled from the Tzotzil-speaking municipality San Juan Chamula, infamous for its history of mass expulsions of converts. Through her attentive ethnographic analysis, Kovic explores how the expelled are creating new forms of community in this semi-urban context and the reasons behind their expulsions, which she emphasises have political and economic motivations. Kovic bases her study on eighteen months of anthropological fieldwork between 1994 and 2001. During the first years of her study she was affiliated with the Centre of Human Rights ‘Fray Bartolomé de las Casas’, initiated by the Catholic diocese of San Cristóbal.
Kovic interlinks the stories of the Guadalupe Catholics and the Chamula expulsions with that of the Catholic diocese. She shows how the Guadalupe Catholics are highly influenced by their affiliation with the diocese both in their interpretation of the Bible and in their perception of human rights. Conversely, she shows that the diocesan clergy have also been profoundly influenced by their indigenous members and argues that the direction of the diocesan mission has changed over the years because of this influence. Kovic has a thorough knowledge of the diocese, its work, and the various dilemmas with which it has grappled, and provides a complex and insightful description of this process.
A central contribution of Kovic's book is her exploration of how the notion of rights held by Guadalupe Catholics fuses Catholic beliefs with the global discourse on human rights and local notions of reciprocal responsibilities, solidarity and respect. She shows how the expelled claim both collective and individual rights, and that they emphasise the importance of what are commonly called social and economic rights. With their interpretation of the Bible following the liberation theology line of the diocese, Guadalupe Catholics state that they have the right to live without poverty and exploitation. This right is, they hold, granted by God but also established in international accords. Kovic shows the powerful confidence that this perception provides to the believers, providing the strength by which they condemn their life conditions and demand change from state authorities, principally through demonstrations and mass diocesan pilgrimages.
Furthermore, the believers refer to rights when condemning their expulsions from their homes by the indigenous leaders of Chamula, and the passivity of state authorities. They emphasise that the expulsions violate their constitutional right to choose religion freely, but also the right to be treated with respect as community members of Chamula. Instead of solving the problems with proscribed temperance and dialogue, converts hold, the Chamula leaders are resorting to aggressions and violence. Since the converts have been accused by Chamula authorities and state officials of propagating ‘Western’, individual rights over traditional community rights, Kovic's analysis shows the forceful counter-argument of the expelled.
Kovic discusses the anthropological debate on whether to regard the notion of human rights as universal or culturally relative, but not the increasing anthropological discussions on the human rights discourse itself and its modernist history. This involves examinations of how the widespread change from ‘needs-based’ to ‘rights-based’ demands affects political agency, and how it may speak of a broader change of the relation between state and citizens. I believe that such an approach would have made clearer the novelty and impact of the rights perspective for Guadalupe Catholics, and allowed Kovic to describe more clearly the ways in which the believers have appropriated and transformed this globalised discourse. It is now not always clear whether the translation of local norms to ‘rights’ is made by Guadalupe Catholics or the author herself.
Another significant theme of the book is the way Guadalupe Catholics strive to construct a Catholic neighbourhood community in the semi-urban setting. Kovic shows the continuous importance of the community for the expelled Catholics, who have been accused of destroying community ties. To the contrary, Kovic says, ‘the expelled do not reject the concept of community cohesion – they embrace it’ (p. 129). She does not address the rather obvious question, however, on how the conversions affected the sense of cohesion and reciprocal duties in the home communities of the expelled. If she wanted to avoid providing fuel to the fire, she could refer to other Maya municipalities where conversions that initially created conflict have led not to expulsions but agreements on mutual respect. Kovic convincingly shows the continuing emphasis among the expelled on unity, mutual responsibilities and respect. At the same time, she argues, there are important changes taking place, as the expelled are reassessing the value of certain traditions of their communities of origin, such as the use of alcohol, which is banned, and gender roles.
Importantly, the community of Guadalupe Catholics has formed networks with other Mayas, mostly within the broader community of the Catholic diocese but also with expelled Protestants. Kovic shows how these networks give political and social strength to the community members and help them navigate within the urban and national arena, constituting themselves as active and demanding participants.
With this ethnography, Kovic provides valuable knowledge for the more general understanding of how indigenous men and women emigrating to cities throughout Latin America create new forms of communities and networks which to some extent build on rural community models but are trans-local and often trans-ethnic and even ‘trans-religious’. The construction of these urban indigenous communities is highly powerful in San Cristóbal, which has received a vast number of Mayas looking for means to support themselves during the last few decades. These Maya newcomers and their various religious, political and economic associations are playing an increasing role not only for the migrants but for town life as a whole.
In conclusion, this is a fine monograph, providing a powerful demonstration of the great potentiality of the rights concept and of communal organisation among indigenous migrants. The book is written with sensitive and nuanced descriptions of the lives and concerns of Guadalupe Catholics, who come to life, both as individual men and women and as a group of marginalised poor, struggling for change.
