This small volume details the intellectual relationship between Jacob Taubes (1923-1987), a rabbi, Gnostic, professor of Jewish studies, and philosopher; and Carl Schmitt (1888-1985), a political theorist, jurist, conservative Catholic, and admitted Nazi. The book reveals the unlikely relationship between the two men through their written correspondence and Taubes’ reflections and lectures upon that correspondence. Throughout the book, Taubes questions and examines his ‘friendship’ with Schmitt. Their communication originated with a letter that Taubes wrote to Armin Mohler in 1948 regarding the intersection of political philosophy and apocalyptic thought. Mike Grimshaw, in his introduction to the book, credits this letter with not only sparking the relationship between Schmitt and Taubes but also forcing a reconsideration of what is involved in and with political theology, a debate that still rages and divides scholars in the field of political philosophy and religious studies.
Political theology, as defined by Schmitt in pre-war Weirmarcht Germany in 1922, is the idea that all significant concepts of the modern theory of the state are secularized theological concepts. This implies that old religious concepts are the basis upon which the modern state operates and asserts its authority. The sovereignty of the state replaces the sovereignty of God; therefore, the state propagates a ruler with divine power. In order to maintain stability and legal order, the state requires an exception bearer or leader to whom no law applies. The exception bearer is always correct in his or her analysis of issues and his or her prescriptions are not to be questioned. The exception bearer, Schmitt says, is similar to the theological ‘miracle.’
Within this context, Taubes’ letter to Mohler marks one of the first times that Taubes referenced the Apostle Paul’s importance to political theology. Taubes believed that political theology was rooted in Paul’s ideas, particularly those recorded in Romans, Chapters 9-11. The two scholars often discussed Paul’s role in shaping Western political thought, particularly the notion of exceptionalism. Taubes’s letter also discussed his ideas concerning “the apocalypse of revolution” (11), which involved examining history in light of Christianity’s focus on the end of the world. Taubes and Schmitt shared an interest in the role of apocalyptic thought in shaping modern political thought, although they approached it from different perspectives. Both viewed history in rather Christianizing ways: as a finite term that will eventually give way to a new order. Taubes saw Schmitt (by virtue of his position as a jurist) as an embodiment of the katechon, which, in theology is the one that restrains the Antichrist and therefore postpones the end of the world. In political terms, the katechon is the entity that seeks to preserve the current order, to prevent the chaos that will result from a complete breakdown of society.
Both Taubes and Schmitt identified as anti-liberals, a fact that might confuse people whose knowledge of politics is limited to the American political landscape, in which ‘left’ and ‘liberal’ are generally taken to be synonymous. Because Taubes was a leftist, it might seem antithetical to call him ‘anti-liberal.’ When examined in the context of political systems around the world, however, both the left and the right in the United States fall under the umbrella of liberal democracy, near the middle of the political spectrum, a similar position to that which was occupied by Weimar Germany. For Taubes and Schmitt, the middle was undesirable, although they approached this view from opposite perspectives. Both scholars believed that liberal democracy was vulnerable to destruction and that it invited chaos in its wake. Where they differed was in their approach to the chaos itself. Schmitt, as a devotee of the law, saw it as something to be kept at bay. Taubes, on the other hand, saw the chaos (a manifestation of apocalypse) as an opportunity for a transition to a better state. Despite holding opposing viewpoints, the two shared both a disdain for liberalism and an interest in apocalyptic theory, which served as the foundation for their intellectual ‘love–hate’ relationship.
Initially, although Taubes caught Schmitt’s attention through the letter to Mohler, he declined to respond to the many signed books and notes that Schmitt sent him (though he always read them). He said that his lack of response was due to Schmitt’s active anti-Semitism. In 1967, however, Taubes heard that the Russian émigré French Hegelian philosopher Alexandre Kojève had named Schmitt “the only person in Germany worth talking to” (14), causing Taubes to reconsider his refusal to engage with Schmitt. The two had their first face-to-face meeting several years later, in Plettenberg, where they had, according to Taubes, a ‘violent’ discussion regarding myth and historiography. Their relationship continued, through discussion and correspondence, until Schmitt’s death.
Throughout the book, Taubes explains Schmitt’s influence on German political thought and argues that no scholar who discusses the relationship between religion and politics can deny the debt owed to Schmitt. Taubes addresses the contradictory nature of his relationship with Schmitt, knowing that they were opponents to the death, but they got along splendidly. The book focuses quite extensively on the peculiar relationship between the two scholars. It draws ontological parallels between two men’s friend-enemy dialectic and the self-other dialectic. In Letters, Taubes concludes about Schmitt: “Here was someone who posed substantive questions, just like Heidegger. That was the fascination” (57). Taubes’ allusion to Heidegger, another one-time Nazi affiliate, underscores this notion that the mutually antagonistic relationship between scholars who have opposing ideologies can give rise to questions and debates that could not exist between scholars who are in full ideological communion.
Although it is not the most transparent and fluid of letters and reflections, Taubes and Schmitt present their convictions with unwavering passion. Schmitt’s provocative perspective of his religion’s (Catholicism) political history grants readers an intimate vision of Christianity and Judaism in the modern world. Political scientists who are interested in the concept of political theology as a tool for re-thinking democracy will find here a more complex picture of Schmitt and of Taubes, who has shaped the work of the influential twentieth century political theorist Giorgio Agamben. Furthermore, critical analysis of political theory from the angle of theology will prove to be very rewarding in discerning the changing patterns of control and power in the study of religion and politics today.
