Eyal Chowers has written a book which seeks to explore the political philosophy of Jewish nationalism but hides beneath it a much more sweeping thesis about the nature of Jewish history, if not even a far more ambitious attempt to devise an absent Zionist political ethos that would provide the frail Israeli democracy the philosophical foundation it currently lacks. The book depicts Zionism as a sui generis national movement that had radically transformed Jews materially and spiritually, marking not only their entry into “modernity” or “the world of politics,” but also a deep-seated “shift in the way Jews began to experience time” (9), combining “two contradictory aspects of modernity: a project-like logic involving rational planning and premeditated shaping of the future, as well as valorization of ancient images and aesthetic existence” (14). Chowers's greater concern, however, is that a flourishing public sphere did not emerge in Israel. The central cause for this, he argues, has to do with the characteristics of the modern Hebrew language and the Zionist project itself, which, although successful in turning Hebrew into a vernacular, did not offer a new political vocabulary and foundational texts, but focused instead on the actual, physical building of the land, and subsequently hindered Hebrew speakers from performing the “unveiling role” that language has in a democratic public sphere.
The book is committed to four main propositions, two causal-historical, two philosophical-linguistic: First, that Zionism is a “revolution.” Zionism emerged as a reaction to a “crisis” that occurred when an optimistic Enlightenment worldview that made Jews the most enthusiastic supporters of “the creed of progress and especially the political principles of liberalism” had failed. Second, that Zionism also marks an internal revolution disrupting Jews' continual dialogue with their own tradition and historical memory. Thus Jews not only became disenchanted with some aspects of the Enlightenment's belief in progress but were forced to divorce themselves from a perennial Jewish theological vision that governed their social life up to that point, an entrenched traditionalism that “did not allow [Jews] collective action” (73) or to “believe in politics as a means for restoring their unity and communal life” (78). The third, more philosophical proposition is that the Zionist political philosophy offers a unique kind of “semicyclical temporal imagination” that has one foot grounded in a primordial, monumental past which it recovers in order to make the land the single meaningful site of Jewish political existence. In that sense, this was a philosophy that “celebrated the human capacity to begin something absolutely new” (75), standing in contrast to both the Jewish diasporic condition of dispersion and inability of individuals to make time a “sphere subject to choice and responsive human crafting” (70) as well as to the modern conception of home and place that generated aloofness from specific locations and community (64–66). The fourth, “linguistic” proposition, suggests that language not only predicates the way in which individuals relate to the world and experience it but also is intimately linked to their ability to think and operate as democratic political actors, capable of critical thinking and discourse.
“One cannot review a bad book without showing off,” W. H. Auden commented once. And yet: under such a heavy bombardment of dismayingly superficial clichés and pretentious style of presentation one is propelled to react. First are the book's historical arguments, most of which range between the shaky and the fictitious. Readers are dragged through essentialist sermons about Jews being “the people most immersed in time” and most skeptical “toward the vista of modernity,” through a melodramatic, lachrymose presentation of two millennia of Jewish disaporic life as being nothing but “saturated with disasters,” with Diaspora Jews unable “to establish vibrant and cohesive communities,” to a grotesque presentation of all pre-Zionist Jews as passive, apolitical creatures, incapable of shaping their collective action and human means (3, 6, 78, 78n8). The history of the Jews of modern Europe—a story of deep, bitter internal divisions between Hasidim and mitnagdim, between Westjuden and Ostjuden, between Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and secular versions of Judaism, between Yiddishists, Hebraists, and assimilationists—must be airbrushed to make room for a thesis that can see political Zionism as the only possible type of Jewish politics.
Second comes Chowers's highly creative reading of theoretical texts. I was surprised, for instance, to learn that the philosophy of a pious Lutheran like Immanuel Kant “hinges upon a disenchantment with tradition” and that his philosophy “transports Adam Smith's argument from the economic sphere to the historical and phenomenal one” (32, 29); that Walter Benjamin's “Theses on the Philosophy of History”—a paradigmatic example of radicalism rooted in a messianic conception of Judaism—are in fact based on a “true import of historical, non-Messianic time” (53); or that Adrian Hastings, the professor of theology who became the main advocate of recurrent perennialism in the study of nationalism, is actually an “ethno-symbolist” like Anthony Smith (55), and that the theories of both can be mobilized to support Chowers's radically modernist thesis that Zionism was born on a “moment of void” (76).
Far more disturbing is the hidden political agenda the book promotes. Chowers considers himself an Arendtian democrat, alarmed by the improvised public sphere in Israel. He calls on Israelis to manufacture a shared vocabulary, civic discourse, and political vision, and at the same time to divorce themselves from any blood-and-soil attachment to the specific geographical space marked by the term Eretz Israel. In other words, instead of focusing obsessively on building and settlement, Israelis must search for “shared, elevated and taken-for-granted texts and vocabulary” and to find their own Gettysburg Addresses and Periclean speeches in formidable rhetorical orations they should uncover from their short but eventful history. The contemporary bewilderment of Israel's progressive intellectuals, not willing to subscribe to the post-Zionist agenda yet frustrated by the continual success of a zealous settlers' movement, no doubt provides the context to Chowers's ideas. When read against this background, the political message of the book becomes surprisingly simple: instead of confusing Zionism with settlement, attachment to geographical territory, and the building of the land, Israelis should dissociate themselves once and for all from the clannish landedness and reinvent Zionism as a patriotic and civic discourse, similar to a degree to the type of national—but not nationalistic—discourse Charles Blautberg offers the Canadians to absorb (240n33).
However noble the normative motivation of such an argument may be, there are two fundamental problems with this kind of proposition. First, historically, resurrection of such a miraculous “aterritorial” Zionism requires Chowers to commit violence to the historical record, since the lost continent he describes never existed as an actual historical phenomenon. Ironically, the very texts he puts on the table as possible canonical texts that will forge a democratic sense of Israeliness—Yitzhak Rabin's triumphal June 1967 speech in Mount Scopus, Menachem Begin's 1952 speech in protest against the Reparations Agreement between Israel and West Germany, or Moshe Dayan's 1956 eulogy of Ro'i Rotberg, who was killed at the gates of Gaza (148–59, 236–37, and passim)—are texts that regard building, conquest, and settlement as the quintessence of Jewish ethnonationalism. Careful enough to leave this cardinal point opaque, Chowers does not quote a single word from these controversial speeches. Take for example Dayan's obituary, stating:
We are the generation of settlers, and without the steel helmet and the cannon maw we will be unable to plant a tree or build a home. Our children will have no life if we do not dig shelters, and without barbed wire and a machine gun we will not be able to pave roads or drill for water. Millions of Jews who were annihilated without having had a country look at us from the ashes of Israeli history, commanding us to settle and build the land for our people (quoted in Mordechai Bar-On, Moshe Dayan: Israel's Controversial Hero [Yale University Press, 2012], 75–76).
For Dayan, writing this militaristic sermon in 1956, this was the “decree of our generation.” The normative conception of the text rests on a Carl Schmittian view of politics. For Chowers, writing in Tel Aviv of 2013, this is the ethos we need to bestow on the next generations of Israelis: that the Jewish-Arab conflict is inevitable, unsolvable, and thus also eternal, that the destruction of European Jewry is part of an “Israeli history” and serves as a moral imperative justifying Israeli militarism, and that those who yearn for peace too eagerly are dangerously naive and blind, risking themselves together with their community. Here lies one of the paramount ironies of the book, for the lofty philosophical foundations it searches for are nothing less than the guiding principles of the Israeli Nouvelle Droit. Chowers is not simply offering us a “post-post-Zionist” affirmation of the basic tenets of Zionism but celebrating a highly contentious type of nationalistic creed masquerading as secular and democratic.
Like Chowers's previous book, The Modern Self in the Labyrinth (Harvard University Press, 2005), this is also a book that emerges from the 1990s melancholic ruminations on the postmodern predicament. The post-Oslo pessimism in Israel, the frustration from recurring failures to check the mounting settler movement or contain the dark antidemocratic currents in contemporary Israeli society no doubt added another dimension to the book. They lead the author to fantasize about a philosophical Zionism untainted by any building, landedness, or physical attachment to territory, and at the same time divorced from the canonical texts of ancient Judaism and modern Hebrew culture alike. What we get at the end of the day, therefore, is a highly subjective, often cranky and pretentious meditation about the Zionist “postmodern” condition, and very little of what the book promises to deliver—an explanation of the novelty of Zionism through analysis of its context (242). Unfortunately, those who wish to understand the political philosophy of Zionism—if such thing exists—will have to find it somewhere else.
