The multiple nature of Colombia's so-called armed conflict underlines the absurdity of the assumption that the demobilisation of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) could really be thought of as ushering in a lasting peace. The optimism of certain communities and social movements during the peace negotiations and the very real changes that took place on the ground have been unable to cover up the perverse dynamics of capital accumulation that continue to lead to so much bloodshed, as new actors, and old ones in new guises, fill the void left by the demobilisation of over 8,000 guerrilla fighters. Driven by an economic model that privileges extractive industry, agribusiness and the interests of large landowners, these dynamics obey global and national designs while having intensely local characteristics. The human stories they produce are tragic in nature, as rural communities struggle to build a viable life for themselves in the midst of conflict.
The continuing wave of violence against community leaders in Colombia makes Gwen Burnyeat's Chocolate, Politics and Peace Building all the more poignant as it tells the story of a paradigmatic case of community resistance against the interests of local and national elites. The experiences of the peace community of San José de Apartadó, Urabá, exemplify both the complexity and the brutality of the political struggles taking place in rural Colombia, in which the normalisation of violence coexists with institutional indifference and bureaucratic ineptitude. Burnyeat charts the community's attempts to break with these logics by rejecting the presence of armed actors in its territory and withdrawing all support from them. She deftly brings together the threads of existing scholarship in order to lead us through the labyrinth of local politics, and provides a wealth of ethnographic detail to weave a richly textured narrative that helps explain the peace community's beliefs and political strategies.
We are told in the introduction that the different sections are roughly equivalent to history, politics and culture, though all three perspectives inevitably overlap throughout the text. The book provides a well-researched historical overview of the colonisation and political economy of the region, explores the role played by NGOs, and pulls no punches in outlining the longstanding connivance between the Colombian security forces and right-wing paramilitary groups. Burnyeat also provides a discussion of the complexities of the feuds between organisations on the Left that contributed to the violence of the 1990s and 2000s. She adds a number of important ethnographic insights, especially when it comes to the exploration of the ways in which members of the peace community understand their relationship to their physical environment and in particular the cacao plant that helped them to maintain the local economy against tremendous odds. The representation of this crop as something like an independent agent in their struggle for survival reveals the community's deep emotional attachment to the rhythms of its cultivation, and the values that emerge from that process, not least community solidarity and a deeply rooted respect for the biodiverse environment in which this extraordinary plant thrives.
The ethnographic material is presented with considerable verve, and constitutes the most persuasive part of the book. Less satisfying is the handling of the overall political meaning of the story of this small community, which at its peak comprised around 1,500 people. The analysis follows the development of particular forms of political subjectivity and the construction of a sense of shared identity that emerged through local people's engagement with NGOs and the state. Here the essential claim is that the community's political identity coalesced around a ‘radical imaginary’ that interprets all of the state's overtures as part of a plot to undermine and destroy its livelihood, networks and sense of identity. Although Burnyeat is at pains to point out that she does not set out to argue for or against this vision, she nonetheless refers to ‘circular narratives that self-confirm individual and collective identities’ (p. 168) and regards continuing suspicion of the state during the peace process and its aftermath as ‘a narrative of interminable, tragic victimisation’ (p. 162). Similarly, she distances herself from Gloria Cuartas’ not unreasonable suggestion that, from the state's perspective, Urabá and areas like it ‘must be organised in order to develop the mega-projects which would be carried out in the future’ (p. 55; Gloria Cuartas was mayor of Apartadó during the founding years of the Peace Community).
In this, Burnyeat follows the position of academic liberals who had few reservations in defending President Juan Manuel Santos’ peace process (2012–16), in spite of the many reasons for supposing that much of the agreement was never going to be fulfilled. Subsequent events have made it clear that the murder of community leaders asking for the return of stolen land or impeding development projects, already under way before Santos left power, was and continues to be systematic. That the peace process has been accompanied by a genocidal campaign against community activists is characteristic of the strategies through which Colombia's national and local elites have habitually maintained their power, and helps us to understand why social movements with different notions of development are justified in rejecting the overtures of state institutions.
Indeed, amongst the thickets of detail one wishes at times for some integration of all of these atrocities, miscommunications and self-interested overtures into an analytical framework that might help us grasp both why and how things turned out this way. The challenge for political studies of Colombia is to account for the ways in which bureaucratic incompetence and inertia work alongside economic power, the use of violence and a clientelistic political culture to reproduce a remarkably stable social order. Here, one senses a missed opportunity to explore how these interrelated factors operate. That said, the book as a whole remains a fascinating and well-researched exploration of resistance against terrible odds. Thoughtful and well documented, it is an indispensable addition to the body of ethnographic work on political conflict in what continues to be a violent and deeply polarised polity.
