This fine study shows how and why protest mobilisations against neoliberal globalisation surged in Central America in the 1990s and 2000s. Going beyond the ‘IMF riots’ literature that mainly considered South American countries still under authoritarian rule in the late 1970s and early 1980s, Almeida focuses on local responses to global restructuring in Central America (including Panama) during an era of political democratisation.
The book's introductory chapter locates Central American ‘protest campaigns’ of the 1980–2013 period in the context of global anti-neoliberal mobilisations, including recent waves of protest in Brazil, the Middle East/North Africa, anti-austerity protests in Southern Europe, Chilean student protests in defence of public education, and the Occupy Wall Street movement (pp. 2–3). Offering a counterpoint to the standard narrative of the ‘pacification’ of Central America by the 1990s, the author notes that nearly half the population remained near or below the poverty line when the wars ended (p. 4). These structural conditions, combined with political democratisation, created the conditions for broad-based popular mobilisation against the onslaught of austerity, free trade and privatisation policies.
Chapter 2 outlines the theoretical argument explaining grassroots responses to Central America's ‘double transition’ (borrowing from Polanyi, pp. 12 and 24) of political democratisation with economic liberalisation. Almeida distinguishes between initial austerity measures of the 1980s and early 1990s, and the second generation of neoliberal policies beginning in the mid-1990s involving free trade agreements, pension system reforms, labour flexibility laws, and privatisation of natural resources and public services. The latter in particular tend to generate widespread unrest and are therefore given special attention in the book. Employing resource mobilisation and political opportunity structure theories, the author also seeks to explain variation in protest mobilisation by examining 1) state and community ‘infrastructure’ in each case, 2) strategic capital, or political learning from past collective action, and 3) the ability to form multisectoral coalitions. By state infrastructure he means geographic distribution or concentration of government offices, transportation routes for protesters to assemble or blockade, and centralisation or dispersion of public university campuses which can serve as spaces for civil society to congregate and debate. His examination of community infrastructure focuses on the salience of non-governmental organisations (independent or cooped), labour groups (especially public sector unions), and movement-based political parties.
Chapter 3 examines the case of Costa Rica, where early democratisation, a long period of state-led development, robust civil society, and the experience of anti-austerity protests dating back to the 1980s set the backdrop for successful multisectoral mobilisations. A municipal-level disaggregation of protest data shows that administrative and community infrastructure were significant factors affecting the spread of protest. Chapter 4 focuses on El Salvador, arguing that early clashes over telecommunications privatisation provided political learning for the massive marchas blancas (white marches) against health care privatisation in 2002–2003. Strategic experience from the war years, as well as penetration by the FMLN and NGOs, also account for some of the regional intensity of protest. Yet Almeida argues that electoral politics dampened protest activity with the 2009 election of reformist FMLN candidate Mauricio Funes.
Chapter 5 examines the case of Panama, where the long period of military-populist rule from 1968–89 presented both challenges and opportunities for organising against neoliberal policies. Interestingly, although protests were difficult to sustain in the authoritarian 1980s, welfare state policies became a kind of touchstone for civil society groups later seeking to forge common fronts. Chapter 6 discusses Nicaragua and the struggles against what William Robinson (cited on p. 113) called ‘slow motion counter-revolution’. Labour and other organisations that had grown accustomed to a cosy relation with the state shifted gears to defend past gains, joined in the 2000s by new consumer-based NGOs. Not surprisingly, protest retained a significant political dimension. Chapter 7 considers Guatemala and Honduras, where increasingly intense conflicts over mining and mega-development schemes face powerful residual elements of authoritarianism, giving rise to new collective organising experience for continued struggles.
Chapter 8 offers comparative conclusions, highlighting the importance of multisectoral alliances and learning from strategic experience in opposing top-down imposition of the Washington Consensus. Past historical experience of repressive exclusion, as well as newly acquired experience within a more democratic framework, have shaped anti-neoliberal struggles, sometimes bolstering leftist parties. The author highlights the importance of preserving public space for critical debate, particularly public schools and universities and state employee associations.
For a short book, the data content is rich, drawing on original data on over 4,000 protest events. Country chapters include maps of the geographic concentration of protests, overlaid with the location of major highways, public universities and (for health sector protests) public hospitals, offering a palpable spatial sense of mobilisations; as well as graphs breaking down the composition of anti-privatisation protesters into the directly affected sector and ‘external allies’. Each country case is also introduced with a concise history of popular mobilisation, focusing on the interplay with democratic/authoritarian regimes, organising experience and ability to form multisectoral coalitions to oppose neoliberal policies, and the political opportunities presented by institutional dispersion or concentration. A complementary element one might wish for is the inclusion of more voices of the direct actors, drawing on the author's 40 interviews (p. 9) with movement leaders, which would be useful for evaluating the ideological framing of protests and the subjective motivations of participants. Also, given the intersection of the global and local dimensions of these mobilisations, more attention might be paid to the ability of protesters to tap into transnational social movement organising.
Scholars interested in social movements and in the political praxis of grassroots mobilisation against neoliberal policies in Central America would do well to read this book, together with the excellent study by Rose J. Spalding, Contesting Trade in Central America: Market Reform and Resistance (Austin: University of Texas Press, 2014).
