Ever since its discovery in 1506 the statue of the Trojan priest Laocoon and his two sons has been enlisted as an ally by a wide range of scholars in the Arts and Humanities, helping to throw into relief the powers of art, and its limitations; and serving as an icon for the lure of classical sculpture and, by the same token, the disenchantments it can bring to those who seek to unravel its secrets.
To take stock of the unrivalled impact of this figure on literature and art since antiquity, and with it to mark the quincentennial of the unearthing of Laocoon, Dorothee Gall and Anja Wolkenhauer organized the symposium Laokoon in Literatur und Kunst at Bonn University in November 2006. The ensuing volume deals with the two central pillars that make the Laocoon phenomenon, Virgil's description in the Aeneid and the Vatican statue; and it includes papers on the appeal of these two elements in antiquity alongside their Renaissance reception in literature, art and medicine (Anja Wolkenhauer, Christine Tauber, Christian Brockmann) and in Berlioz’ Les Troyens (Klaus Heinrich Kohrs). With its wide but equally stringent trajectory, tightly wrapped around the two sets of evidence, the volume complements successfully other publications celebrating the anniversary in the wake of the exhibition in the Vatican Museums in the winter of 2006/7, which focus primarily on the history of discovery and Laocoon's second lease of life as a collection item.
I shall consider here in more detail eight of the papers in four pairs, two pairs concentrating on Virgil's text, its precursors and followers, two on the statue and its reception. Studying potential antecedents for Virgil's explanation of Laocoon's charge, Heinz-Günther Nesselrath concludes that, while the post-Sophoclean versions of the myth had attempted to establish individual guilt on behalf of the priest as reason for his punishment, Virgil returns to Sophocles’ and, possibly, Arktinos’ reading, presenting it as a sign of Troy's imminent fate. Michael Erler pursues the signification value of the episode further, comparing more generally the relationship of divine intervention and human action — fata and mens laeva — in Virgil and Homer.
The following pair deals with the evidence of the Vatican statue, its stylistic relevance and its visual dimension: Christian Kunze consolidates what, on the basis of Pliny's text and the archaeological evidence, can be regarded as the art-historical context of the Laocoon. He starts with an overview of the rediscovery of the statue and then contextualizes Pliny's mentioning of it and its Rhodian artists. By connecting Laocoon with the Sperlonga sculptures, and using the recent argument that favours a date for the grotto's furnishing of 30/20 B.C., Kunze draws attention to the similarities in motif choice and style between the Sperlonga sculptures and Laocoon, all of which he regards as late Hellenistic originals. In his stylistic assessment, Kunze emphasizes the unusual combination of stylistic characteristics of late Hellenistic art, the calm arrangement of the figures and the dramatic action they convey; and he draws particular attention to the form of contemplative viewing the monument stimulates, and which, in his view, differs from the more demanding, even frustrating, arrangement of the multi-viewpoint groups so characteristic of Hellenistic art in the third century.
Susanne Muth's approach unlocks a different perspective of the statue's design and presents a compelling new answer to the question of how the heightened pathos of the Laocoon group should be explained: she draws attention to the peculiarities of the snake attack, not matched by other images of punishment and brutality so popular in Hellenistic art. Establishing the Laocoon as an inverted take on the iconography of the boy Herakles strangling the snakes, she explains the figures’ over-emphasized suffering, commented upon since the statue's discovery, as a device to show what otherwise cannot be visualized: the stealthy, yet irresistible approach of the reptiles, and their eventual success.
Exploring the impact of the statue from yet another angle are Otto Zwierlein and Balbina Bäbler: the former ascertains the assumption that Pliny refers to the Laocoon not just as an extraordinary piece in marble but quite simply as a highly acclaimed artwork, all material groups considered; the latter compares Johann Joachim Winckelmann's three different treatises on the statue, written between 1755 and 1764, before and after he had seen the actual monument, and she demonstrates how the immediate efficacy of the group interfered with Winckelmann's prefabricated ideational interpretation.
Roswitha Simons and Ursula Gärtner concentrate once more on Virgil's text, with Simons surveying later Latin literature and explaining Laocoon's rather remarkable absence from most post-Virgilian treatments; and with Gärtner discussing, and negating, the likelihood that Quintus Smyrnaeus and Virgil used the same older sources.
In sum, the volume fulfils admirably its stated aim of taking stock and of examining the Laocoon phenomenon across the two media that shape it: it provides a range of new and innovative approaches to the two types of evidence, while at the same time those readers interested in exploring individual aspects further will find this a useful companion to guide their way.
