This book aims to further investigate tribe-state relations in most of the states in the Arab Middle East by focusing on their political, social, and tribal histories. The aim here is to “understand the complexities and particular patterns of state formation in regions where tribes have exercised significant influence” (2). The study of tribes and their relation to nation-states in the Middle East is a relatively unexplored topic given the importance of tribal identity to contemporary politics. In a changing Middle East, tribes possess substantial social and political power through informal influence over ruling families, and formal influence in the parliaments. Indeed, this book also seeks to address debates about the so-called Arab Spring and its aftermath.
As the book's introduction discusses, with the major exceptions of Syria and Yemen, tribes have played a large role in nation-state formations. In almost all Arab states, royal families seek to include local tribes in the national ethos to penetrate the state into tribal and territorial enclaves, and thus weaken tribal identity (9). The book categorizes interactions between tribes and states according to two types: a mutually beneficial alliance, and tribal antagonism toward state formation. Yet, there are a few countries that do not fit those categories (e.g., Iraq and Bahrain) (4).
In the first chapter, Yoav Alon focuses on tribe-state relations in Jordan between 1920 and 2012. Alon posits a relatively strong interdependence stemming from a mutually beneficial alliance between the royal family and tribal elites that reaches back to Jordan's establishment as a modern state. Jill Cyrstal argues, in the second chapter, that although Qatar's ruling families attempt to thwart tribal power, they are always only partially successful. This is mainly because of ruling family weakness and tribal autonomy, hence, tribe-state relations take the shape of “accommodation” (55). In the third chapter, Andrea Rugh covers tribe-state relations in the UAE. She argues that national identity has grown to suppress tribalism as an organizing force in social life (57). With distributive power of oil wealth and relative stability, the UAE has little need for tribal institutions. The fourth chapter by Uzi Rabi showcases the ruling families’ efforts to create a national identity that would neutralize tribal power. He argues that the policies of Sultan Qabus, who has modernized and unified Oman since he came to power in 1970, have reduced the political influence of Omani tribes with the help of Oman's Ibhadi heritage (80). Sarah Yizraeli's chapter on the House of Sa‘ud depicts how a ruling family secured its political authority over tribes by strategically disbursing oil revenues and allying with religious establishments (96). In chapter 6, J.E. Peterson argues that despite the decreasing influence of Yemeni tribes in the country's social and political life since the ouster of Ali Abdullah Saleh in 2012, tribes might still have a key role to play in Yemen's future (142). In chapter 7, Dawn Chatty historicizes the relationship between Syria's Bedouin tribes and the Syrian central government over several decades. In view of these tribes’ unique social and socio-political characteristics, he concludes that it is impossible, at least anytime soon, for the state to assert full sovereignty over them (146). In chapter 8, Ronan Zeidel focuses on the historical military-bureaucratic characteristics of the Iraqi state and its repressive and centralizing tendencies (184). He describes a Sunni-dominated state based on an urban core, seeking to control a mostly Shiʿi and Kurdish countryside, as a natural aspect of state formation in Iraq. This centralization of power excludes tribes from trying to increase their influence over the process of state formation. In chapter 9, Anthony Toth takes the political uprisings in Bahrain in February 2011 as a point of departure to examine the historical development of tribe-state relations in Bahrain. He concludes that Bahrain's ruling family combines traditional and modern practices to guarantee its survival and prevent any dramatic change to the country's political structure (188). Chapters 10 and 11 pursue the reverberations of the various debates about the nature of tribe-state relations, sketching intriguing directions for future scholarship.
The book has two weaknesses. First is its essentialism. The authors see local tribal cultures as fixed and static categories, which yields little new analysis of the confrontation between the local culture of tribes and nation-states. Secondly, while the book's authors historicize tribe-state relations in case countries, they omit or pay too little attention to important political events, such as social and anti-colonialist movements, Arab nationalism, and tricontinentalism. They instead focus on economic developments, and mostly on oil production. Yet the various epoch-defining political events in the history of Middle East, such as the Monsoon Revolution in Oman, the 1962–68 Yemeni Civil War, and the complex political and ideological structures leading to the emergence of Ba'ath parties and Muammar Gaddafi in Libya, go mostly overlooked.
To be sure, the true nature of the state in the contemporary Middle East has long eluded comprehension. Especially considering the recent turmoil in the region, this book's strength in explicating the reasons behind conflicts in the Middle East can be seen more easily than in other books. In a sense, the authors argue that it is politics more than geography that matters in explaining the political history of the modern Middle East. Those with a broad interest in the region or in the process of nation-state formation are likely to find some perspectives and ideas in this volume worth considering, especially in the final contribution by Joseph Kostiner.
