‘Unfolding Lives’ offers a fresh perspective and a valuable, well-written contribution to the growing literature exploring youth transitions. The book focuses on young people's developing gender identities, but the broader theoretical frames, through which the cases are examined, highlight the complexities involved in understanding young people's lives through periods of social change. Rachel Thomson explores longitudinal qualitative data drawn from four in-depth cases to emphasise how the constraints of influential structures interweave with young people's agency in their individualised projects of self. In this way, she underlines the inequalities of social locations shaping their different pathways and intricate relationships with social mobility, avoiding simplistic, individualised accounts of resilience or resourcefulness in explaining their outcomes. As the title suggests, the book explores continuities and changes in young people's lives, using a framework drawn from sociological theory. It provides rich data and interesting reading. Our reservations concern ways in which the theoretical material could have been extended.
In Chapter 1, Thomson establishes the context of the book and subsequent chapters. Selecting from the wider Inventing Adulthood study, which considered education, work, well-being, mobility and belonging, and home and intimacy as reported by 100 young adults from diverse backgrounds (Henderson et al., Reference Henderson, Holland, McGrellis, Sharpe and Thomson2007), Thomson identifies four case histories. She explains the book's biographical approach, drawing on data from interviews conducted over some five years, which she then interrogates through different social frameworks to explore the gendered nature of transitions to adulthood. Thomson also introduces two linked ideas of mobility – social mobility and young people's geographical mobility – which she later connects with concepts of localism and cosmopolitanism. These ideas relate to material on social (and bridging) capital, but these theories are not acknowledged or developed in later chapters. Resilience is a further concept introduced, but absent from subsequent discussion of conceptual material.
Thomson argues, in Chapter 2, that the longitudinal, biographical method is a useful way to explore the nuanced complexity of young people's identities in process. She acknowledges interviewees’ tendencies to ‘produce’ life stories (p. 16), and whilst ‘suspicious about the search for authentic voices within interviews’ she also argues that interviews can offer ‘profound insight’ (p. 17). Thomson highlights the theoretical resources used in the study, including Bourdieu's notion of habitus and social field and Foucault's work on the self. This chapter made considerable claims, and while communicating the case for the book's approach well, could have been condensed.
Thomson discusses her theoretical assumptions in some detail in Chapter 3. Drawing from diverse theorists, including Beck, Giddens and McNay, Thomson deftly constructs an analytic framework for understanding the individualised nature of gendered identity, but there were some missed opportunities for extending critical insights (for example, around resistance). Thomson draws attention to resistance in gender positioning, noting the increasing ‘detraditionalisation’ of gender in contemporary social life. As a literature review, this chapter provides the reader with a strong resource, but falls short of developing ideas to offer new insights.
Chapter 4 introduces Sherleen, an African Caribbean young woman from a working-class background, who draws on her extended family network to support her educational biography. Thomson skillfully discusses Sherleen's complex identity and ways in which she moves between provisional gendered identities, highlighting the fluid nature of her gendered self, configured and reconfigured over time. Sherleen navigates her way through ‘a sea of potential dangers and distractions’ (p. 66) to reach a somewhat more stable identity.
In Chapter 5 we meet Stan, from an aspiring middle-class family, whose reconstructed identity emerges from his new found Christianity and gaining a girlfriend. Stan's interview is deeply reflexive, showing awareness of his changing sense of self at the different stages of his life. As the chapter progresses, Thomson demonstrates a shift from aspirations towards gaining professional status to settling for a vocational position. Thomson's methodology is useful in providing a rich account of the complex nature of young people's transitions, but the chapter does not fully address the nuanced gender analysis promised in Chapter 3.
Devon, introduced in Chapter 6, is struggling to manage ‘the boundaries between gay and straight life and the articulation of sexual, gender, class and ethnic dimensions within his identity’ (p. 89). Thomson vividly conveys the transitional and individualised nature of his identity, which is being made and remade throughout his move to adulthood. Data from the longitudinal interviews enhance our understanding of the complexity of his changing and emerging identity. The deployment of the analytical framework in this chapter worked effectively, perhaps because of Thomson's acknowledged closer grasp of this dataset.
Chapter 7 focuses on Karin, living in Northern Ireland and highlights her individualised struggle for recognition among her peers, set against structural constraints and intergenerational pressures to achieve social mobility. Thomson uses the themes of education, play and family life to explore Karin's case history, while also revealing the tensions between Karin's rebellion and desire to succeed, and between asserting her own style through experimentation with different youth sub-cultures, and security and belonging. Thomson offers lively accounts from Karin's interview data, voicing the often contradictory pathways in Karin's reflexive project of self (Giddens, Reference Giddens1991). Again, the analysis could have been strengthened through clearer grounding in the theoretical frameworks presented in Chapter 3.
Chapter 8 takes up the stories of Sherleen and Devon a few years later, highlighting the value of considering temporality in sociological discussion. Although Thomson explains that these later accounts have been separated out to demonstrate ways in which biographical data continue to unfurl if we continue to study them, the order of chapters in the book's structure remains puzzling. Nevertheless, these accounts offer the reader powerful insights into story ‘endings’. The ways in which both Sherleen and Devon are beginning to resolve and synthesise their individualised identities, work or educational lives, friendships and family relationships contrast with starker contradictions experienced at earlier ages. Tensions remain around social and associated geographic mobility and family ties, and around privacy and autonomy, but this chapter is perhaps the best developed analytically and theoretically.
Chapter 9 moves from the empirically grounded cases to generate broader conceptual understanding by bringing the cases ‘into conversation’ (p. 151). Thomson adopts two frameworks for analysis: the first, biographical, drawing on Giddens’ theory of the reflexive self; and, the second, which links projects of the self within spatial and social structures and horizons, drawing on Bourdieu's (Reference Bourdieu1977) and Foucault's work (Reference Foucault, Bernauer and Rasmussen1994). Thomson successfully identifies commonalities in the trajectories of her cases without obscuring their distinct social locations, which underlie difference and unequal lives. Thomson references Bourdieu's work as somewhat deterministic (p. 153), which seems not to appreciate the complex ideas of habitus and potential for agency which he introduces in later work. These concepts would have been useful to interrogate and support aspects raised in this chapter concerning local ties versus access to social mobility, and the inequalities of different spaces and social locations.
In conclusion, Thomson summarises that ‘it is not possible to prise apart the three dimensions of gender identity, subjectivity and social and material possibilities’ (p. 173) in explaining young people's transitions. Drawing on notions of ‘tradition’, Thomson argues that the young people studied adopt differing concepts of what it means to be gendered individuals entering adulthood. She skillfully links reflexivity into broader debates about the construction of gendered identities, but falls short of extending insights through the development of social theories introduced earlier. Overall, the chapter presents a strong and fluent (if slightly truncated) argument, drawing together material on structures, individualised identity, subjectivity and possibilities for young people in a changing social world.
Despite criticism, this book provides a stimulating read for those studying youth transitions.
