The special issue of Amerikastudien/American Studies, entitled African American Literary Studies: New Texts, New Approaches, New Challenges, guest-edited by Glenda R. Carpio and Werner Sollors, takes stock of the field of African American studies at the beginning of the twenty-first century. Part of this undertaking is retrospective and author-centered: the issue features five newly discovered short stories by Zora Neale Hurston, a new story by Jamaica Kincaid, and an essay by Ishmael Reed. Part of this volume is a reaction to the new Hurston texts and comes in the form of essays introducing and commenting on Hurston and including new criticism on related topics, such as on Winold Reiss, the Black Renaissance, and Richard Wright. The “new challenges and directions” are found in essays written by George Hutchinson, Jeffrey B. Ferguson, Birgit M. Bauridl, George Blaustein, Kenneth W. Warren, and Ishmael Reed. In addition there are a number of reviews about recent publications.
There is a way to read this collection both forwards and backwards. Reading it in chronological order and starting with the first section, the reader makes an enjoyable acquaintance with the irreverent Hurston poking fun at the Bible, the migration narrative, and Harlem. The five stories are introduced and commented upon by the editors, Carpio and Sollors, and M. Genevieve West (who comments on “The Country in the Woman” and “She Rock”). Why are they worth our while? Read Jamaica Kincaid on her reaction to Hurston – irreverent and fun to read as well. And read the two letters that Carla Cappetti discovered and you will find more about irreverence.
The “New Approaches” section contains very interesting essays by Daphne A. Brooks on Hurston, the singer, a part of her anthropological life that most readers are not aware of; by Frank Mehring on Winold Reiss in Mexico, an essay that helps us understand the Mexican context of “Black Manhattan”; by Ernest Julia Mitchell II about the history of the concept of the “Harlem Renaissance” as part of an international and interracial “Black Renaissance”; and by Stephan Kuhl, who draws a connection between Richard Wright's Savage Holiday and the psychoanalytical case study of matricide, Frederic Wertham's Dark Legend.
The volume then moves into the twenty-first century and promises to point out new directions and new challenges. By referring to and analyzing Claude McKay's novel Banjo, Mexican Afromestizos, Cape Verden American identities, Afro-Deutsch identity and a memoir by Anita Reynolds, George Hutchinson challenges the specific North American assumptions underlying issues of transnationalism, internationalism, and diasporic identities. In this very thought-provoking essay Hutchinson draws on a wide background to argue and contest the many attempts to limit the concept of diaspora along the lines of the one-drop rule. Jeffrey B. Ferguson writes about the uses and abuses of blues as a touchstone for authenticity in African American literature and recognizes the challenge to what he calls “the old faith in black Americans’ unity” (711) in the post-civil rights era. Birgit M. Bauridl writes about the term “black” in contemporary black performance poetry, and George Blaustein picks up the international theme again (that is, after all, the uniting topic in the entire volume) by discussing the color line alongside the fall of the Berlin Wall in Paul Beatty's recent novel Slumberland (2008). Provocatively asking “What was African American Literature?” Warren – who is quoted in some of the other essays – proposes that as a collective enterprise of some aesthetic, political, and economic significance African American literature originated with the Jim Crow era and the elimination of black intraracial class difference, and, so to say, passed away with the civil rights movement. But, as I said earlier, there is a way to read this collection backwards, starting with Ishmael Reed's compelling and fervent plea for the need for ethnic studies (including black studies) in the wake of the Tea Party and then seeing the other essays and discoveries as proving his point. Black American studies are more necessary than ever, Reed says, and just such a collection, I would like to add, as the special issue of Amerikastudien/American Studies will prove the need for new approaches and challenges that include the move to the archives and lead to the discovery of Hurston's and other writers’ original texts, which in turn will generate analyses that rely upon a wide range of scholarship but still question the concepts, origins, and future directions of this field of inquiry.
