As author Melvyn Stokes notes in his preface, the field of history and film has become crowded lately, with most of the works falling into one of two genres: the theoretically driven single-author work on a small number of films meant to highlight particular historical or filmic issues or problems (such as my History on Film/Film on History (2006)), and the often rather diffuse collection of disconnected essays by multiple authors utilizing different methodologies (such as my edited volume A Blackwell Companion to Historical Film (2013)). Stokes's claim is that his own book is different from both types in that it is single-author work which “focuses on a range of major subjects and themes in American history, arranged in a broadly chronological way” (1).
The heart of the book is a detailed analysis of some twenty-one major Hollywood films, but there are plenty of references to other works (some 150 in all) which show that Stokes has a vast knowledge of how American filmmakers have chosen to tell historical tales over almost a century. The explication of these works is distributed through ten chapters under the following unparallel but more or less chronological headings: “The American Revolution,” “Slavery,” “Abraham Lincoln,” “The Civil War,” “The War's Legacy,” “The Good Indian,” “The Golden Door (Immigration),” “The Great Depression,” “HUAC and Hollywood,” and “Remembering the Sixties.”
The author's self-explained strategy in handling these topics is to first “synthesize what historians and film writers” have said about the works in question, followed by his own analysis, which is meant to provide “new insights into … [the film's] treatment of history” (2). What this adds up to is a volume which admittedly “resembles a history textbook” (1–2). This particular truth underlines both the shortcomings and the strengths of the book, and provides a problem for any reviewer, for as we all (should) know, there is nothing as difficult to review as a textbook, a work usually designed to serve many masters at once.
In writing style, happily, the work is nothing like a textbook. The prose is casual and straightforward (no heavy film theory here) and eminently readable. The argument seems to proceed by a kind of accretion. For example, the chapter on the Civil War begins with a description of Lillian Ross's New Yorker article on the production and reception of John Huston's 1952 film Red Badge of Courage, and continues with a section describing many Civil War films that stretch all the way back to the earliest silent-film days, letting us know that most of them were unsuccessful at the box office. He follows with sections on the two undeniably most important films ever made about the conflict, the controversial and overtly racist work The Birth of a Nation (1915 – to which Stokes has devoted a fine entire volume), and the enormously successful Gone with the Wind (1940), which for generations of moviegoers became a chief source of their knowledge about the Civil War. Trying to account for why so relatively few films have been made on this most important American conflict, he makes the argument that between the world wars the major filmgoing audience was women, who did not like war films; and after the war, race issues, or rather their absence, haunted possible productions, at least until, in the wake of the civil rights movement, director Edward Zwick gave us Glory (1989). Though highly fictionalized, the film did divide time more or less equally between white and black Union soldiers and, more importantly, showed that the latter were deeply involved in their own freedom struggle. Alas, this small victory for historical truth did not endure. More recent films set against the Civil War, such as Cold Mountain (2003), have returned to a strategy of marginalizing black people once again.
Each chapter in the work is full of such interesting details and insights, but the overall problem is that the work seems aimed both at those who have studied American history and at those who have no knowledge of the subject; those who are familiar with film theory and analysis and those who have never thought much about how film constructs its meaning. There is way too little historical detail for those who are not familiar with the American past, and way too much for those who have studied some US history. When Stokes makes the claim that these topics and this approach have worked well in his own history-on-film classes over the last twenty years, there is no reason to disbelieve him. But as a contribution to the field of scholarship, the book does not really have much original to add to the current debates in this field.
