Roy Porter commanded, and continues to command in memory, the respect and affection of many historians of many persuasions. It is obviously fitting to assemble essays to express this, essays which engage with the range, the scholarship and the enthusiasms of the man. The editors and contributors also convey something of what it was about Porter's way of being a historian which touched, encouraged and in some cases inspired their lives and work. It makes for an attractive combination of the scholarly and the personal. There are eighteen essays, each short and making a point, and the result is a very readable, accessible collection.
The difficulties facing anyone wishing to create a coherent and integrated collection are obvious. Porter edited the journal History of Science for twenty-five years and knew his history of science, while he simultaneously elaborated the history of medicine, with a famous emphasis on the patient's view, the history of London and the history of the English Enlightenment. In this collection the emphasis is on the medicine – reflecting where he was employed, the influence he had as a teacher and the contemporary source of funding for many scholars. The sheer diversity of topics included here, however, is still enormous. The editors have not tried to control this but let contributors speak for themselves. Only Hal Cook, in an incisive introductory reflection, tackles the issue head-on, arguing that Porter should not be pigeonholed as a ‘social historian of medicine’ but understood to be ‘one of a generation of historians who were trying to recover a new vision of the past that emphasized the variety of how things were rather than the making of causal arguments’ (pp. 15–16). This, indeed, was at the heart of changes in the history of medicine over the last forty years which, once historians had declined the story of scientific progress, made the subject – let me put it bluntly – the history of the relations of more or less every aspect of individual expression and material life.
Certainly, this collection reflects a nebulous diversity which makes of the doing of history an end in itself. The editors, following their own lucid introduction, have created three sections – ‘The science of history and the politics of science’, ‘Bodies, commodities and social difference’ and ‘Minds, identities and social order’. The first awkwardly combines historiography and detail on scientific and medical reform in early nineteenth-century England. The second has highly particular studies of French dentists in London, ‘forced’ cucumbers, military disabilities, the lunacy associated with work and anxiety, sexual utopians, female Spanish anarchism and the blood-donation service. Giving the list, however, does not do justice to the essays, each of which has a purpose (cucumbers provide entrée to the culture of the natural and the artificial in the English eighteenth century) and a point to make, just as Porter's own delight in stories always had a cutting edge. The last section includes essays on the understanding of mental illness and also two cultural essays on the late nineteenth century concerning the will and links between the sciences and the arts. A lot of people will get a lot of pleasure and illumination from many of the contributions here. Where else will I so attractively learn about macabre death, from hypnotism, in a Hungarian castle, or about the roots of the English blood-transfusion service?
There is more here on the nineteenth century than on the eighteenth, almost nothing on the specialist content of scientific or medical knowledge (an exception is a Porterian critique of Foucault's early thesis on pathological anatomy in The Birth of the Clinic) and little on the large-scale claims which concerned Porter, such as the nature of the English Enlightenment (here the exception is an essay on eighteenth-century historical writing). Rather, what has inspired these essays is the seamless integration of history and the history of medicine; the view ‘from below’, especially the patient's view (exemplified by a study of soldiers' own demands for pensions); the role of ‘the market’; the particularity of events; and the manner in which individual people themselves experience and represent the demands of everyday life. These principles, assert the contributors, lead to the proper stuff of historical work.
