Thomas Beddoes was hasty. A man of multiple projects and vast reading, he found almost no place in histories of science for 150 years after his death at the age of forty-eight because, rather than spend years perfecting a masterwork buttressed by evidence that it would take another generation to refute, he poured himself into ephemeral print in poems, pamphlets, proposals and anthologies – genres political, medical, educational, chemical and aesthetic, separate or in combination, brief or baggy. He wrote for the occasion rather than for posterity, heralding discoveries based on speculative analogies and placing his own ideas among those of other writers. He was in this respect a more characteristic product of the Lunar Society and of his mentor Erasmus Darwin than was Erasmus's grandson Charles. Beddoes perpetuated the Lunar model of natural philosophy in which, within the circle of friends and allies, intellectual property was unimportant, interests covered many areas, and publication emerged from continuing debate in person and in correspondence. He also took forward the Midlands Enlightenment emphasis on useful knowledge: his investigations of nature were made with the aims of advancing commerce and improving health, aspects of a larger goal of benefiting society. This goal became political in the 1790s because the French Revolution, which made social justice and political liberty seem possible, created such alarm among the established classes that freethinkers became targets of both mob violence and government repression. Joseph Priestley's house and laboratory were destroyed; John Thelwall was arrested for sedition; Beddoes became persona non grata with Sir Joseph Banks and the Royal Society.
Since the history of science became a cultural history of knowledge production and reception, Beddoes has repeatedly been redeemed, or part-redeemed, from the neglect that Banks began and nineteenth-century historians continued. Dorothy Stansfield's comprehensive biography was followed by Roy Porter's study of Beddoes as a medical man; Mike Jay concentrated on the Pneumatic Institution context; the present authors began examining him as long ago as the 1980s. Together, they bring to The Enlightenment of Thomas Beddoes a total of over a hundred years’ scholarship into his chemistry, geology and politics. The result, as might be expected, is massive erudition: the volume offers more detailed portraits of the context in which Beddoes worked than have previously been available, portraits especially distinguished by their use of the manuscript correspondence not just of Beddoes himself but of many in his circle, including the Shropshire ironmaster William Reynolds, Davies Giddy, James Watt, William ‘Strata’ Smith and James Keir. The extensive quotation from these letters will be of great use not just to scholars of Beddoes but also to historians of dissenting intellectual networks. A less expected aspect of The Enlightenment of Thomas Beddoes is its form. The authors have chosen neither to write a collaborative monograph in one voice nor to co-edit a collection of essays by different hands. Rather like their subject, they have produced an unconventional, conversational collection: chapters written singly or together handle various aspects of Beddoes's career under different headings – chemistry, geology, politics, book collecting, educational theory – but nonetheless display considerable overlap, viewing the same information from different angles. The effect is sometimes like that of a cubist portrait: different facets are presented together on same plane. While the overall picture is sometimes fractured as a result, it also emphasizes Beddoes's multiplicity formally as well as thematically.
Levere's chapter on chemistry is not quite a survey: it wisely does not attempt to retell the by-now oft-told story of the Pneumatic Institution after Davy's arrival. Rather, it throws valuable new light on Beddoes's activities from his student days in Edinburgh, through his period as a lecturer at Oxford, into the early 1790s when he became a Bristol campaigner for medical and political reform. Tracking Beddoes's involvements through the letters of his friends, Levere shows that intellectual enthusiasm was his greatest asset, leading him to welcome new ideas and to forge mutually enlightening relationships with their proponents. Enthusiasm was also his chief weakness, causing him too quickly to hail new possibilities as truths. Embarrassing retractions that undermined his reputation followed. At Oxford he announced in one lecture that a cwm near Keswick was a volcanic crater, only to declare soon afterwards that this was an error. Later, Coleridge, disillusioned by this tendency, declared that he was ‘hunting a Pig with a buttered Tail – his whole Life an outcry of Eureka and all eurekas Lies’ (p. 61).
A side effect of Beddoes's willingness to accept new ideas was his impatience with traditional establishments. James Watt, Levere shows, regretted Beddoes's political publications, wishing he would keep his democratic politics and anti-Pitt diatribes private, so as to avoid damaging the prospects of pneumatic medicine. Beddoes, though, had always had to take on those who hampered innovation: no sooner did he commence lecturing at Oxford than he printed an attack on the dilatoriness of the Bodleian librarian. Moreover, as Hygeia was to reveal, he saw that pneumatic treatments could not succeed in spreading health to all classes in the face of the new occupational diseases caused by manufacturing industry. As Stewart shows in his chapter on the political context, Beddoes's advocacy of preventive medicine, a pioneering discourse comparable to that of John Ferriar and Richard Pearson, could not help but be radical because it necessitated social reform in reactionary times.
Enthusiasm for innovation made Beddoes seek out German and French writings that remained unknown to most British intellectuals. A chapter on his book collecting shows that his wide foreign reading enabled him to embrace Lavoisier's chemistry when most of his teachers were still phlogistians. He was also a key scientific reviewer for the journal that helped to establish the publishing firm of his Edinburgh friend John Murray. Scottish connections also led him, years before Playfair, to confirm plutonist arguments about rock formation from his own observations and to bring them to the attention of natural philosophers in Europe. Torrens concludes that he was ‘the first English Huttonian’ (p. 105).
Hutton, Murray, Priestley, Watt, Joseph Black, Thomas Wedgwood, Maria Edgeworth, William Smith, Joseph Johnson and, though less heavily featured, Coleridge and Southey: as a result of this volume, the Enlightenment of Thomas Beddoes is seen as a matter of a rare and prescient ability to recognize the innovatory work of others and to advocate it in person, in manuscript and in print. ‘Only connect’: Beddoes becomes pivotal in the culture of scientific, medical and political enquiry of the 1780s, 1790s and 1800s despite, or perhaps because of, his inability to make all his interests cohere in one focused work.
